Angry Vet and USAirways

One of my best friends is blind, and almost always travels with her dog. The dog goes on the floor by her feet, and I can't tell you how many times we've gotten off a plane and people never even knew the dog was there.

She likes the independence that a dog gives her. Then again, she's a former US Disabled Downhill Ski Team member, and current world champion and world record holder in Disabled Water Skiing so she isn't your typical blind person I guess.
 
Guy is an a hole. Plenty of them around, vet or not. US Air did the only thing they could do in the situation. I'd guess the front seats of that jet had vets too.......
 
One of my best friends is blind, and almost always travels with her dog. The dog goes on the floor by her feet, and I can't tell you how many times we've gotten off a plane and people never even knew the dog was there.

She likes the independence that a dog gives her. Then again, she's a former US Disabled Downhill Ski Team member, and current world champion and world record holder in Disabled Water Skiing so she isn't your typical blind person I guess.

Most legitimately phsyically-challenged people, in my experience, want to be treated like everyone else.

The ones that bought that stuff off of eBay want to run around the airport like they're Kim Kardashian.
 
I understand the reg, I just don't agree with it as a logical safeguard in any way. We let morbidly obese people and frail elderly people on the edge of death occupy seats, but A SERVICE DOG MUST GO UNDER THE SEAT. Nope. Sorry, that just doesn't sound like consistent logic to me.

When you figure out a way to strap a 60 pound dog into the seat so it stays there, is comfortable and won't slip out of the belt during a rapid G change, let me know. Until then, the dog can stay on the floor between the seats where it won't become a 60 pound projectile during turbulence. It's bad enough that we allow lap children but at least they weigh less than that.
 
"Lap Children"? We used to call them "Lap Rockets" at Skyway.

One high speed abort and they go a-flyin'!
 
Aside from the main issue, how did this quote make it into the article?

“If the aircraft were to experience something in the air and it needs to evacuate you don’t want that animal to be in the way of people getting off the aircraft,” spokesman John McDonald said

Either US Air has a terrible spokesman or the reporter didn't do much thinking. As @Cal Goat pointed out, the animal would not be in the way of people getting off the aircraft if it was on a seat; also, I generally refuse to evacuate an airliner in the air if something is "experienced." At least that's what I think was intended. I've never heard of an aircraft needing to evacuate itself.
 
At the end of the day, you can't have an animal on the seat.

The aircraft isn't the passenger's private vehicle.

You have to turn your iPod off, I don't care how hott the Justin Beiber track is you're listening to! :)
 
You pay for the space you take up on a plane. Its very simple logic. If a person wants to ensure their service animal(which yes, is usually just a pet) has space, they can buy a second revenue seat. But the airline has worked with the FAA and ADA to create a policy, and that dog is sitting on the floor either way. If you don't like the company's policy, don't buy a ticket on them, find another way to get where you're going. Airlines are private companies selling seats on an airplane flying from point A to point B as per the contract of carriage they outline when you buy the ticket, people seem to forget that.
 
You pay for the space you take up on a plane. Its very simple logic. If a person wants to ensure their service animal(which yes, is usually just a pet) has space, they can buy a second revenue seat. But the airline has worked with the FAA and ADA to create a policy, and that dog is sitting on the floor either way. If you don't like the company's policy, don't buy a ticket on them, find another way to get where you're going. Airlines are private companies selling seats on an airplane flying from point A to point B as per the contract of carriage they outline when you buy the ticket, people seem to forget that.

Reminds me of when I was commuting and there was a dog with the standard eBay "Service Dog" smock on.

The dog had no problem with dropping a deuce in the aisle and barking at cabin crewmembers as they performed their in-flight service.

I don't know, I'm probably an ass for saying this (or a lot of other stuff), but 90% of the "Service Dogs" that I see make me think "Really? REAAAAALLY?"
 
Sounds about right. I'll never forget the time a "service dog" got loose and started humping all the dogs it could find in the terminal while I helped a slow moving, overweight and frustrated Midwestern lady chase it around the UAX gates at SFO. To be honest, I just let it run a muck and made sarcastic comments to the woman about how obedient her service animal was. It was pretty hilarious. We didn't end up letting it on the plane because she failed to provide proper "documents" when questioned by my boss.
 
I guess I'm just a little jaded about the service dog.

I've seen people that are blind and deaf that refuse special accommodations, or when they do, they're about the nicest people on the jet, but the high-heeled Scottsdale socialite hops on a jet with a yappy Pomeranian with the "Service Animal" smock on, they want the world to come to an end because of their "comfort animal".

I can only imagine Jabba the Hutt boarding a jet with Princess Leia, chained and in-tow, early boarding a 757 saying "EETS A MAH COMFORT CONCUBINES!".

Wait... That was more Jar-Jar Binks. Sorry. #fail.
 
You pay for the space you take up on a plane. Its very simple logic..

Sorry pal, but that is simply not true. I have had more fat people spill over into my seat than I care to remember. And let's not even get into overhead bin politics. I hear you guys making your perfect-world, rules-are-black-and-white arguments, but the reality of airline travel is nothing like you're attempting to postulate here... Which strikes me as very odd since you normally come across as fairly clever fellow.
 
Largely your hands are tied and, sad to say, you're herding cattle as that's all you have time for.

It's a choice between a non-compliant passenger and removing the passenger, that's a situation which the non-compliant passenger isn't going to find an agreeable result with.
 
I once saw a miniature service Donkey. We took a lot of pics, it was cute.

Oh and it did have the eBay special sticker on it.
 
Largely your hands are tied and, sad to say, you're herding cattle as that's all you have time for.

It's a choice between a non-compliant passenger and removing the passenger, that's a situation which the non-compliant passenger isn't going to find an agreeable result with.

Yeah I get it. I'm just saying it's not the logically consistent or reasonable world we want it to be. It's not even about the dog, really. It's about the lack of reason across a diverse set of circumstances. Of course we won't always get it right, but my limited experience doesn't even approach the hyperbole that you and some other folks seem to be so confident about.

And I respect your experience in the airline world, but I happen to have 32 years of experience around legitimately handicapped people. So again, my bias just happens to be different on the subject of service animals.
 
I once saw a miniature service Donkey. We took a lot of pics, it was cute.

Oh and it did have the eBay special sticker on it.

For a long time at my previous shop we had a list of "approved" service animals (although it did say the list was not limiting) and on it was Helping Hands Baby Service Monkeys. I also saw a mini pony, a goat, a parrot and a pig come on board as "service" animals.
 
And I respect your experience in the airline world, but I happen to have 32 years of experience around legitimately handicapped people. So again, my bias just happens to be different on the subject of service animals.

Well, there's the issue right there. You are working around legitimately handicapped people so of course they are going to have legitimate service animals.
 
Yeah I get it. I'm just saying it's not the logically consistent or reasonable world we want it to be. It's not even about the dog, really. It's about the lack of reason across a diverse set of circumstances. Of course we won't always get it right, but my limited experience doesn't even approach the hyperbole that you and some other folks seem to be so confident about.

And I respect your experience in the airline world, but I happen to have 32 years of experience around legitimately handicapped people. So again, my bias just happens to be different on the subject of service animals.
Airlines don't like to budge on policy when stuff like this blows up in the media. It allows people to think they can get around airline policy if they make enough noise, and that isn't how it works with these huge cooperation's. Besides, as an airline guy, I can tell you that the MAJORITY (caps because its true) of service animals on airplanes are not legit service animals. I can also tell you letting service dogs occupy seats on planes would just lead to delays as rampers or cabin cleaners would be cleaning unrine and doo-doo off of seats left by the scores of fake service animals that fly each day. Is it fair to the people who really do have service animals they need to travel with? No, it's not. But as you said, its not a perfect world.

If you need someone to blame, blame the people who claim their un-housebroken yappy toy dog is a service animal and abuse the system to save money and time.
 
Back
Top