Seggy
Well-Known Member
I responded seriously to two of your posts now and was ignored. #sadface
Thanks for reminding me
I responded seriously to two of your posts now and was ignored. #sadface
It is employer paid but when one retires from the military they still get the benefits am I correct? Can you name a private employer who offers this good of a plan when someone retires? I'm sick of military folks who rail against teachers and other public service servants complaining about their retirements when the military folks get a pretty good socialized deal.
Huge difference dude. Civilian plans don't keep paying when one leaves the company (usually).
Yes, that's true. And, no, I can't. I was only confused why you said you might get nasty responses for basically telling military folks what they already know about their health care.
Of course it's socialized and of course it's a great benefit!
As for being sick of military folks who rail against teachers and other public service servants complaining about their retirements - well, there are doosh bags everywhere, man - even in the military.
I was responding to C-182 Flyer there - he was saying Tricare wasn't that great. I am saying it is pretty great. I was comparing quality of service between the two, not longevity.
It is employer paid but when one retires from the military they still get the benefits am I correct? Can you name a private employer who offers this good of a plan when someone retires? I'm sick of military folks who rail against teachers and other public service servants complaining about their retirements when the military folks get a pretty good socialized deal.
Huge difference dude. Civilian plans don't keep paying when one leaves the company (usually).
Name a private employer that asks of its employees what the military asks of theirs and we can talk.
I don't think anyone is saying they don't deserve it, we are questioning how someone can be so hypocritical. And in my experience a vast majority are just that.Name a private employer that asks of its employees what the military asks of theirs and we can talk. Like everything else, benefit plans are generally created to attract and retain people and usually they are designed to do that, but nothing more. If you answered a want ad and the job included dying for your company, killing for your company, extended periods of time away from your family with little notice prior to your extended absence, having to live in harsh conditions, etc - I would imagine that employer would have to offer a benefit plan at least as stout as the military does. If school teachers and other public employers had to do this perhaps nobody would bitch about it? The argument falls apart for you when you try to elevate all "public employees" to the level of military members because the jobs, risks and conditions are significantly different and can't be compared.
I don't think anyone is saying they don't deserve it, we are questioning how someone can be so hypocritical. And in my experience a vast majority are just that.
?!?It isn't hypocritical to have different pay and benefits for different jobs requiring different skill sets and tasks. To follow the same logic (as in "same employer, different benefits") it would be to say that Flight Attendants and Pilots should have the same pay and benefits. I mean, it is the same employer and all even though the job is different. To compare a school teacher or postman to a soldier is silly. It isn't hypocritical for someone to applaud or at least acknowledge that there is a difference in pay and benefits for a reason.
When the conflicts first started yes pay was significantly higher. Pay has dropped dramatically, guys going over there now make about $65k/yr and there is still a surplus of folks who want to do it.Compare the pay (cash) and benefits to the military.
I would imagine that the cash pay is significantly higher. Mercenaries (and in the truest sense, that is what they are) have always been paid better.
When the conflicts first started yes pay was significantly higher. Pay has dropped dramatically, guys going over there now make about $65k/yr and there is still a surplus of folks who want to do it.
?!?
I'm pointing out how folks with government pensions and healthcare are, as a general rule, pro-Republican, while the Republican mantra is traditionally "less government, no social welfare, anti-government sponsored healthcare".
I have not compared a school teacher to a solider.
No I'm suggesting it's hypocritical to want to yank "entitlements" when you yourself receive a nice pension and good health benefits run by the federal government.Someone else made the comparison.
Again, why is it hypocritical? Are you suggesting that just because someone worked in government they need to all partake in a "Big government is best" mindset? If that is the case you would never find a liberal doctor, never find a conservative blue-collar worker, etc. I like that people can divorce their professional lives from their personal beliefs.
No I'm suggesting it's hypocritical to want to yank "entitlements" when you yourself receive a nice pension and good health benefits run by the federal government.
You are probably the only Republican I have ever "met" who does not view SS and Medicare as an entitlement.Income and benefits that are earned are not "entitlements". In fact, "entitlements" as defined by Social Security and Medicare are not, at least in my mind, "Entitlements". Rather, they are a forced retirement and medical scheme that people have no choice but to pay into. It began as their money, and ultimately needs to become their money again. The fact that they are unsustainable in their current form is not the fault of the participants - they have no choice but to participate in the matter. I have no sympathy for people ripped off by Bernie Madoff for example - they made that choice. Social Security and Medicare are forced (actually, to the extent that the participants vote for the people in government, I guess they do shoulder some of the blame). But, government employees, be they postmen, or teachers, or soldiers are not the beneficiaries of "entitlements" - they are the beneficiaries of their work. That they should not have an opinion about "entitlements" or anything else is ludicrous.
You are probably the only Republican I have ever "met" who does not view SS and Medicare as an entitlement.