X-Plane is sued by a patent troll

I don't know anything about the patent on "internet shopping carts", but if the court determines that he has a legitimate patent on "internet shopping carts" then the companies using his patented internet shopping cart technology owe him something. If not, there are remedies for frivolous lawsuits.

Perhaps you should read up a bit more on why all these cases are held in Texas, and also, you never directly answered my question, so I can only infer that you would be OK and pay them when they come after you for products you legally purchased.
 
Perhaps you should read up a bit more on why all these cases are held in Texas, and also, you never directly answered my question, so I can only infer that you would be OK and pay them when they come after you for products you legally purchased.
In the example you provided, I would tell them to go pound salt, or better yet ignore it. Look, there are scammers in all areas of life. When you get a Nigerian 419 email do you reach for your checkbook or call your attorney? Come on, you're carrying this argument to the absurd. Some of the tech bloggers and Cuban are arguing for the elimination for software patents or reducing the length that a patent is in effect. Why? because they don't want to pay for technology others developed.
 
100%, correct, they want to get something for nothing. They also see many patents for partial technology just sitting around doing nothing and I know for a fact if I had a patent and Microsoft called me, I would not sale for cheap. But large corporations have done the same thing, many just steal it and say to the inventor take me to court. Something is only worth what you want to sale it for based on what someone wants to pay.
 
In the example you provided, I would tell them to go pound salt, or better yet ignore it. Look, there are scammers in all areas of life. When you get a Nigerian 419 email do you reach for your checkbook or call your attorney? Come on, you're carrying this argument to the absurd. Some of the tech bloggers and Cuban are arguing for the elimination for software patents or reducing the length that a patent is in effect. Why? because they don't want to pay for technology others developed.
I'm not carrying the argument anywhere, just found it curious that your first post implied that the people being sued were the thieves, but now I see you don't believe that because you would tell them to pound sand. Unfortunately, unlike the Nigerian scams, these guys are using our court system to extort money. You say you would tell them to pound sand or just ignore it. Let me know how that works out for you when the summary judgement is handed out against you.
 
There is a long list of things that would happen between not responding and a summary judgement. And I think anyone, whom finds themselves in a similar situation would consult a lawyer when the suit is filed in superior court.
 
. And I think anyone, whom finds themselves in a similar situation would consult a lawyer when the suit is filed in superior court.
You would think, but that's not what Pete said he would do. He didn't really understand what these trolls are doing when he first responded.
 
What did they say - Like 5 years in court and around $1,500,000 in legal fees just to fight this in court.

That's a lot of time and money wasted.
 
Old Pete
SFLAX

The problem is twofold: First and most importantly, the USPTO has been issuing patents for at least two decades with vastly inadequate vetting, leading to extremely general, vague patents that can be applied to technologies for which there is often ample "prior art". There have been many cases of patents awarded for methodologies already in use, or things that are very obvious.
The patent system is designed to protect innovation by providing a term-limited exclusivity for a novel design -- something that hasn't been seen before, is non-obvious, etc, as vetted with extreme rigor by the USPTO. Patent trolls are not simply "people or companies with patents", patent trolls are companies that patent something that's blatant and obvious, or already in use, and then go after the little fish who can't afford to fight them ... or companies that consist only of lawyers that buy up various patents, or acquire the "ip" of companies that are going out of business, or otherwise acquire a "portfolio" of patents to go after people with.

Before you make noise about people "stealing" other people's ideas, you need to realize that these "ideas" are akin to a patent for a notch-based system on a metal bar to trigger aligned rollers in an unauthorized entry protection device ... and that the "people" in this case didn't "invent" the patented "technology" -- they just acquired it.

-Fox
 
I should also mention that there's another distinction -- Software patents, by their very nature, are almost always -concept- patents, rather than -design- patents. That's a critical distinction, because "A method to..." has, in court, become "Any method to...".

We first started seeing this as a significant upcoming problem in the 1990s, in the computer industry. It was a problem before then, but never one with a significant chilling effect on innovation.

So, the next time you're using a piece of technology and you think "Geez, why couldn't they just make it do X as well as Y? Why aren't we progressing in our technological advancements? All the data is there!", reflect back on the current system of software patents and ask yourself if the lawyers who "own" these designs just to sue small businesses are "entitled" to the profits from "their" "invention" even though in the long run they're choking out the industry.

Now, we have similar problems with copyright, too... but that's something I won't go into at this time. Suffice it to say that my opinion is that IP law -- not its violation -- is one of the biggest problems we have in business in this day and age.

I wish I could just get my opinion through to people and make them listen, so they would examine it on their own and judge based on the realities of the situation, not based on loaded emotional words like 'piracy', 'theft', 'stealing', 'inventions', and the concept that just because something has been examined by a court or a jury that it must be logical and correct. ("Well, he was arrested ... he must be guilty! Why would the police arrest him if he wasn't guilty?")

In the end, though, I'm just a windbag tilting at windmills and pissing into the wind.

~Fox
Morbo said:
WINDMILLS DO NOT WORK THAT WAY
 
Back
Top