Researching flight training schools

captainphil

Well-Known Member
I visited ATP today and loved the facility. I was discouraged by the cost of the course but sent in an application today anyway under no obligation. I am currently deciding whether to finish up my instrument rating with ATP or with this flight school called Ventura at KFRG before my written exam expires. I would like any positive or negative input regarding any of these schools if you or someone you know has attended them.
 
Whatever you do, remember that part of the learning/seasoning process that forms a good pilot is taking time between ratings to apply what you attained during your training. There is a whole forum devoted to ATP here with many opinions.
 
Good luck.
Is the "application" so they can check out for financial ability to finish the course?
 
Bottom line. Do it the fastest, cheapest way possible. All in all, ATP is a good option because it does just that (cheap is a relative term). And you get your multi time.

Not all locations are the same. I have herd good things about the Phoenix location (IWA).

Good luck.
 
This will probably get moved there, but the forum devoted to ATP will probably have what you're looking for.
 
Bottom line. Do it the fastest, cheapest way possible. All in all, ATP is a good option because it does just that (cheap is a relative term). And you get your multi time.

Not all locations are the same. I have herd good things about the Phoenix location (IWA).

Good luck.
Fast and cheap are sometimes two mutually exclusive properties. Personally, since an instrument rating is another license to kill yourself, but at least you cant see it coming - I wouldn't want to rush that rating. But that's just my opinion as a CFII; there are many institutions which have accelerated courses, including instrument, which churn out competent rated pilots.

So as for "fastest, cheapest" I don't necessarily agree because of what is at risk.

A former student of mine had an excellent experience over at Action Somethingorother in Groton CT for his multi rating that he wanted to get out of the way over a weekend. You might look into if they have an Inst course. They seemed to do a thorough job.
 
I did my primary training at Mid-Island at ISP. The staff there is very professional and their prices are competitive for the area. Not sure if they have a twin to rent at ISP though. Can't speak positively or negatively for any other flight school out here, but Mid-Island has earned my loyalty. I particularly like the fact that it is still family owned and run.
 
Fast and cheap are sometimes two mutually exclusive properties. Personally, since an instrument rating is another license to kill yourself, but at least you cant see it coming - I wouldn't want to rush that rating. But that's just my opinion as a CFII; there are many institutions which have accelerated courses, including instrument, which churn out competent rated pilots.

So as for "fastest, cheapest" I don't necessarily agree because of what is at risk.

A former student of mine had an excellent experience over at Action Somethingorother in Groton CT for his multi rating that he wanted to get out of the way over a weekend. You might look into if they have an Inst course. They seemed to do a thorough job.

As a CFII as well I understand your concern. I was assuming that the OP is considering going to ATP to complete all of his ratings and get a job. If so, If stand by cheap and quick because a person will go straight into the right seat of a 172 to fly and gain a lot of experience quickly.

Now, and hopefully the OP and chime in, if this person is strictly going to get an instrument rating and fly IFR personally, occasionally, quality of training is paramount. In this case I would be looking at a school that has equipment similar to what the person would be flying by themselves and get a career CFII that has a few thousand hours and several instrument sign offs.

I had a family friend who did a weekend multi course. It was fast and cheap. He was a private pilot VFR. Weekend warrior. Got that quick multi rating, bought a C-310 and a few moths later put it in the dirt with his wife, kid, and four other people in the back. Not pretty.

I stand by cheap and quick if your trying to make a career out of it and your immediately going to start flying a lot after training. If your working of IFR for basically any other reason....spend the dough.
 
No flight school will ever tell you this. But this is the best, and cheapest, way to do this. It will benefit you and it will benefit the instructor because the instructor will not be giving up 75% of his earnings to the flight school.

The best way to finish up your instrument rating is to find a flight instructor in your local area that you get along with. Don't move. Don't try to rush the rating. Just get in there and do it.

Deal directly with the flight instructor. Pay him/her as you go. Do not go through a flight school.

You will pay less than you would if you were going through a flight school. But you will be paying the flight instructor more than they make if they were teaching you though a flight school. It's a win win for both of you. You will most likely get better instruction because there will not be any pressure to extract as much money as possible out of you.

The instructor may have his own plane or if he doesn't then he will know the best place for you to rent one. You can find a local flight instructor by asking around the local Civil Air Patrol or even searching on Craigs List. You can even call a local DPE and he may be willing to refer you to some flight instructors that are good. Remember, the DPE sees the good and the bad in this business and they know who the good instructors are. Folks in the aviation business will often be willing to refer you to instructors that are good.

I made a suggestion at the last Jet Careers get together that we have a section on jetcareers.com for flight instructors to post their availability and services by state and city.

Good Luck!

Joe
 
Joe makes a very good point.

I'm a Chief Instructor for a 141 flight school in Wash. DC. I say look for a smaller flight school in your local area. Stay away from the big pilot mills!

Dont get me wrong, I am not knocking their quality. I have three Instructors on my staff who went to ATP. But believe me, the fact that they were ATP had NOTHING to do with my decision to hire them.

We can do zero to hero at my local flight school for around $40K. I just spoke with one of my instructors who went to ATP. He did the SAME ratings for $59K. thats nearly $20,000 difference for the SAME ratings.
I had another instructor who came out of a different one of those schools with $120K in debt!

Cheapest option is like Joe said, find a local CFI.

Next best option is find a local flight school.
 
I'm going to echo what Ben and Joe have been saying. I just got my Private at a small airport for around $6,000, including the few hours that I had through Western and a few hours in a DA-40 out of GRR. I have friends at Western who are paying around $20,000 for the same exact rating. There is no reason to train in a Cirrus for the Private, it is completely overkill for what you need in my opinion. Find a local free lance instructor you like, explain your situation, sit down, and make a plan to get it done. Like Ben said, you should be able to go from zero to hero in under $40,000. Nothing against ATP, they seem to have a nice program, and a guaranteed cost. Unfortunately, that cost seems to always be rising, now up to $62,000 - not including your living costs or housing. If you want that 100 hours of multi-time, find a cheap twin (They do exist - ATP just doesn't want you to know that) and split the time - safety pilot, dual received, etc. Best of luck in your search.
 
The instructor may have his own plane or if he doesn't then he will know the best place for you to rent one. You can find a local flight instructor by asking around the local Civil Air Patrol or even searching on Craigs List.

Posting and asking here may help you find a local instructor, but finding an airplane might be the more difficult part.
 
Deal directly with the flight instructor. Pay him/her as you go. Do not go through a flight school.

Sometimes this works really well. Sometimes this is a terrible idea.

The problem I've seen with a lot of independent instructors is a lack of standardization, reliability, accountability, availability, objectivity, etc.

What syllabus are they using? They ARE using a syllabus...right?

Who's doing periodic "progress check" flights with the students? Who's double checking the instructor's work?

Will they be available to fly as often as you want? Will your schedule line up with theirs? What happens if they move, become unavailable, etc.?

What kind of safety standards are being followed? Are they insured?

I've seen a lot of people get screwed over by trying to do ratings on the cheap this way. They might end up with an instructor who, frankly, isn't a very good instructor, but the student doesn't know it until they bust their private pilot checkride because there was no objective oversight at any point during training. There was no flight school administration to standardize the instructors and ensure the instructor was following a syllabus, signing off students correctly, checking the progress of the students, and so on.

Other times, people have been screwed over when their instructor moves away or becomes unavailable. Now they have to find a different instructor who may or may not be using the same syllabus, textbooks, video courses, etc. It becomes an issue of wasted time, frustration, wasted money on new training materials, and on and on.

I also think there's something to be said for the proficiency an instructor gets from teaching at a flight school all day every day, rather than just a few hours on nights and weekends.

I'm just not a fan of this, "I'm going to piece everything together on my own and figure out how to fly," approach. I think there is a lot of value in a *good, reputable* flight school guiding the process.

The fact is, yes, flight school administration and oversight does cost more, but most of the time, the customer *gets* more. They're protected from a lot of pit falls they probably don't even know exist.

And this is coming from a guy who used to be an independent instructor.
 
Back
Top