What will the "Carrot" be?

bronco21016

I know H.T.M.L. (How To Meet Ladies)
This morning I started making my move away from 9E by getting an interview elsewhere. Unfortunately, I sat ready reserve all day so I obviously talked to a ton of people in the crew room and got a lot of conflicting advice about whether to stay or run. As it stands I'm about 60-70 from the bottom and in my mind all signs point to run unless some miracle cure-all is in this still secret TA.

My question is this... what in the world do they have up their sleeves to get the 4/5th of pilots that are getting the shaft in this deal to vote YES?

Obviously it's all speculation but I'd like to hear some possible outcomes because I'm just that impatient. Unfortunately, I really think it's gonna be a flow of some type and I really hope the majority isn't dumb enough to fall for that. Who knows though.
 
I don't want to be Debbie Downer but...

Remember that there are many other employees beyond pilots there. Management needs to be able to blame somebody other than themselves for the failure of the company, and pointing the finger at the pilot group is an easy way to do that. There probably isn't a carrot and management knows full well the 2000 guys who are going to lose their jobs either way are going to vote no. But this way when the mechanics and fas and office workers complain, the pilot group will be blamed for killing the company.

I saw it happen over here when we were offered 900s at terrible rates. We voted down the offer and for a few months it seemed like every fa, mechanic and gate agent wanted to kill us.
 
Bronco, this time last year we had around 200 JR to us, now it is down to about 50. If that plus the union saying there will be 200 furloughs starting 1st qtr, isnt enough for you to really get going on finding a new job I dont know what else will. People need to realize that IF there is a flow there will only be about 15 people going a month. That will get down to the 2000ish numbers pretty quick right?
 
5.5 yr FO around 1700ish on the list and I'm starting my exit strategy. Not sure what guys are saying to convince you to stay being your 50 from the bottom...but I'd like to hear it. Even if we got a flow, Delta has already said they will not hire next year and it would take an ungodly long time for it to hit us junior guys anyways. That being said just from hearing guys talk I would be surprised if this is voted down. This is all talk anyways until the language comes out...hopefully by the end of the week.
 
I know it's all talk... I just wanted to see what kind of wild ideas people could come up with. I can't fathom a 'flow' being the magic carrot that will get this voted in.

I'll say this. The guy that really wanted me convinced that there won't be ANY furloughs has a lot more interest than most in the company staying around. His idea was that everyone at 9E will be offered a chance to be at Delta and that enough will go between Delta and the hiring boom that is supposed to come from United, Airways, Blue that there won't be any furloughs. My interview elsewhere isn't until January so obviously I have time to take a look at this but he sure sounded confident.
 
The guy that really wanted me convinced that there won't be ANY furloughs has a lot more interest than most in the company staying around. His idea was that everyone at 9E will be offered a chance to be at Delta and that enough will go between Delta and the hiring boom that is supposed to come from United, Airways, Blue that there won't be any furloughs.

That guy is on crack. If you are that close to the bottom you have nothing to lose, you need to get out ASAP before everyone else starts to bail and the competition for jobs goes way up. I'm sure some magical flowthrough deal sounds appealing but it will never happen, at least not for someone that far down the list. Don't mean to sound harsh because I know your situation sucks, but GTFO quick man, while you still can..

Ask any one of us at Eagle how this flowthrough is working out. Guys have been waiting FOREVER to go.. always a promise around the corner they will start going again.. yet they are still here.. 20+yr Eagle guys hired in the late 1980's still "waiting" to flow through some day.
 
I know it's all talk... I just wanted to see what kind of wild ideas people could come up with. I can't fathom a 'flow' being the magic carrot that will get this voted in.

I'll say this. The guy that really wanted me convinced that there won't be ANY furloughs has a lot more interest than most in the company staying around. His idea was that everyone at 9E will be offered a chance to be at Delta and that enough will go between Delta and the hiring boom that is supposed to come from United, Airways, Blue that there won't be any furloughs. My interview elsewhere isn't until January so obviously I have time to take a look at this but he sure sounded confident.

If anyone thinks there won't be any furloughs, then I think they don't exist in this plane of reality. Movement due to hiring? Maybe, but like has been mentioned, there won't be any at Delta next year. If there IS a flow, the senior guys won't leave until 2014 at the earliest. That's assuming the senior guys actually LEAVE. A lot of the guys down in MEM don't have degrees, therefore they don't meet the mins at DAL. How will that affect their flow? There's an awful lot of competition out there for those jobs at Airways, United and Blue for next year. I mean, pretty much ALL of Comair is looking for a new job, then you've got CAs at XJT, ASA, Skywest, GoJets, Republic, etc in the mix as well as military and corporate/charter. Not to mention some of the guys going for those jobs at UAL, Airways and eventually Delta and AA are going to be coming from places like jetBlue, Virgin and Spirit.
 
I couldn't agree more kell.

My response I'm sure looked something like this when he started talking.

Bush%20confused.jpg
 
That and no matter what "carrot" they dangle, anyone leaving for another DCI carrier needs to think about what voting yes will do when Delta goes to resign the ASAs at the other carriers. Anyone who tells you that Delta won't go to XJT, RP, etc and use 9E as an example is lying...
 
So vote no so YOUR new job won't be screwed in contract negotiations? Haha we all know you're pretty much set where you're going.
 
So vote no so YOUR new job won't be screwed in contract negotiations? Haha we all know you're pretty much set where you're going.

No, its vote no so the bar isn't lowered so that when you lose your job due to you being junior, the next regional you get on has to go as low or even as low as 9E will be.

Think of is this way (assumptions made about the TA until details are released)*****...

A Yes Vote - If the TA is approved with a yes vote, then 1500 pilots will lose their job. The new contract will offer lower pay, QOL, etc so that the remains of 9E can struggle for a few more years. Other carriers that are in negotiations will then be using that as a comparison, which in turn will lower them to "compete" in the whipsaw game. Since you are junior, in addition to the other 1499ish pilots that will be looking for jobs, you will now have jobs that are lower paying due to the newly minted 9E contract.

Lets just say also for the pilots in the middle, who may take a year till they lose their job at 9E. If they go on unemployment, that varies but it only looks at between the highest 2-5 quarters or the last year. If the pay reduction under a concessionary contract makes their gross pay lower, then when they get furloughed, they pay is now even lower than it was before.

A no vote - If the TA isn't passed, 9E will wind down. We know of at LEAST 40 900's that will have to go somewhere, which will be a net gain of 400ish overall pilots. Some of the guys who are older at 9E will just retire and drop out of the pool. Now looking at a worst case, you will be competing with 2300 pilots for 400 additional gain at other carriers. Looking at a bast case scenario, mothership does purchase all 70 -900's, that's about 700 jobs-ish that may open up.As stated above, unemployment benefits will be higher here depending on where you stand and when you get furloughed.

So a summary, a yes vote will put you in more competition for less jobs, while a no vote will give you less competition for more jobs. Either way, you have no job in the future of 9E from what we know so far. What will help you better in the future?


***** - This is assuming the knowledge of no details on the TA but applying the previous 1113c terms. We can all assume what the details are, but when the union tells you to prepare looking for a new job, that is a grim sign.
 
So vote no so YOUR new job won't be screwed in contract negotiations? Haha we all know you're pretty much set where you're going.

Never said it would or wouldn't still get screwed, just saying don't think the vote at 9E doesn't potentially effect the next carrier.

lol all it takes is trans states to start meddling and that goes out the window to...
 
This morning I started making my move away from 9E by getting an interview elsewhere. Unfortunately, I sat ready reserve all day so I obviously talked to a ton of people in the crew room and got a lot of conflicting advice about whether to stay or run. As it stands I'm about 60-70 from the bottom and in my mind all signs point to run unless some miracle cure-all is in this still secret TA.

My question is this... what in the world do they have up their sleeves to get the 4/5th of pilots that are getting the shaft in this deal to vote YES?

Obviously it's all speculation but I'd like to hear some possible outcomes because I'm just that impatient. Unfortunately, I really think it's gonna be a flow of some type and I really hope the majority isn't dumb enough to fall for that. Who knows though.
I'm going to tell it to you like this Cuzzo, run! I'm no expert in the airline world except the only 2 things you need to know. Always keep your logbook/resume updated and never trust what they say until it's actually on property. Move on. There are other regionals/corporate/cargo jobs out there. Good luck Playboy.
 
So vote no so YOUR new job won't be screwed in contract negotiations? Haha we all know you're pretty much set where you're going.

I agree with him. If you vote "yes" and you're junior, you're leaving 9E regardless. If you go to the Skywest Inc family (for example), when it comes time to re-sign a deal with Delta, you won't just be competing with GoJets, you'll be whipsawed against GoJets and the new Pinnacle concessionary deal.

If you vote "no" and you're junior, you're leaving 9E regardless. At least with a non-concessionary deal, it'll be one less low-ball option for DAL to use in whipsaw negotiations.
 
The MEC reconvened at 7 p.m. this evening to consider whether to send the Tentative Agreement to the membership for ratification. The Negotiating Committee presented the final language for the Restructuring Agreement (which amends the terms of the JCBA) and a Bridge Agreement among Delta, Pinnacle, and ALPA (which includes fleet commitments and career progression, as well as longevity transition payments). After a full review of the documents, the MEC voted unanimously to recommend that the membership ratify the TA.

The Tentative Agreement differs substantially from the management’s 1113 proposal, but falls short of the original expectations of the MEC and the Pinnacle pilots. It reflects that Pinnacle Airlines is a financially insolvent entity in a regional industry that is contracting. These facts left Pinnacle wholly dependent upon Delta Airlines for survival. The terms of the Bridge Agreement recognize the pilots’ contribution to Pinnacle’s restructuring and provide us with a binding commitment from Delta that our airline will consist of at least 81 CRJ 900 aircraft. The Bridge Agreement also provides all Pinnacle pilots on the ISL with a career path to Delta. We view this as a significant achievement. However, because some of our pilots will face furlough as a consequence of the planned reduction of the CRJ 200 fleet over the next 2 to 3 years, the Bridge Agreement provides for furlough benefits packages that include pay, health care, passes, and an ATP for those with the requisite number of hours. Long Term Leaves (including Enhanced Long Term Leaves) will continue to be offered over the next several years, and we believe these leaves will greatly reduce the number of furloughs. The total number of projected furloughs for all of 2013 is approximately 150 pilots.

We plan to start road shows tomorrow in MSP (see details below), and we will release the full Tentative Agreement at that time. You will find that there are provisions that reflect the dire situation in which we find ourselves, but you will also find that numerous provisions that are important to us remain unchanged.

The MEC is recommending the Tentative Agreement to the membership for ratification not only because it is the only viable alternative to a wind down of the airline that would have been accomplished within approximately one year, but also because it provides all of our pilots with a meaningful range of options that would not otherwise have been available. Our goal was to ensure that all of our pilots are treated equitably in this transition, and although the provisions of the TA will affect pilots differently, we believe that you will find that the outcome is balanced.

The fact that this bankruptcy negotiation persisted as long as it did reflects our determination to get the best deal possible for our pilots. The bankruptcy court’s decision in our favor prevented us from facing unilaterally imposed terms and conditions, but could not change Pinnacle’s circumstances. It bought us time to negotiate terms that were far more favorable than those that were proposed by the company in August. We have attempted to offset or minimize the concessions every step of the way.

The irony of reaching a Tentative Restructuring Agreement exactly two years after the TA on the JCBA is not lost on any of us. All collective bargaining agreements reflect the economic environment in which they are negotiated, and this one is no exception. This TA represents a transitional period in which we hope to rebuild our contract and provide a stable platform from which our pilots will move to Delta and to other airlines as well.

We know that you will carefully consider all of the alternatives before you cast your vote in the New Year. We look forward to addressing your questions and concerns on the road shows, all-pilot calls, and through your P2P representatives. Thank you for your patience and support, and for maintaining a thoroughly professional and safe operation during a very challenging period.

Our unity is our strength.
 
Initial reaction makes me a little hopeful for the place but definitely not with me at the airline. They didn't mention how bad we got raped on pay though so we'll see.
 
Bridge program? Fancy word for another flow? I thought Delta management and Delta ALPA hated it. Be interesting to see the actual language tomorrow. If it's the previous Mesaba flow type deal, it's an instant no vote for me.
 
Depending on the language of the "bridge program" here's what's going to happen:

-FO votes yes
-FO applies to anywhere that guarantees a paycheck. Pilot job or not. Who cares
-FO takes LOA
-FO returns to get current when he can hold a line
-FO goes to Delta when their number is called

Oh my bad. Did I give away all of our plans?
 
Back
Top