I don't defend the TSA, but I'm not always one to join the BitchTrain without at least a basic idea viable alternative!
Derg. There's an untold backstory here that changes everything, everything about what people think they know about the TSA. And it answers the "alternative" question you pose.
I keep waiting for someone to post the story. Unfortunately it's one of those Tl;dr type stories. And controversial. Right now it's a PM topic.
.MikeD[/USER]
What do we replace them with? The same thing that happens in much of the government. You replace them with private industry. Does that mean that private industry makes the decisions or sets the standards? Of course not. Government needs only to set the standard and monitor the operation. The execution can be done better and with less cost than when done by the government. Nobody can argue that America's security is more at risk than Israel's or that we do a better job than they do. Their airport screeners are private contractors, not government employees. We should move up to their standard, not stay down at ours.So if we abolish the TSA, what do you replace them with? Another similar, if not worse, institution with a different name.
One of my coworkers, who considers GWOT to be a massive victory for 'merica, doesn't fully understand why I think the American people are the true losers in this deplorable police action.Dont worry, it's for your own good... why would you worry unless YOU ARE A TERRORIST!!!!
I cannot believe people still defend the TSA and think we are in any way better off with that agency existing.
1. Better HR, screening & background checks, and integrity checks.
2. Cheap is not always better. Cheap employees and guards = higher chances of criminal activities, and bribery, especially with a private for profit security/contractor. (#Get this passed security, u know how to get around it. Meet me at Gate 35; call your wife, she'll be alive.... or call your wife, she'll have the money).
3. "The Gov't" can get away with more in regards to searches or confiscating personal items than a private contractor.... (#Lawsuits).
4. TSA is made up of U.S. nationals. I'm not sure, but I assume it's illegal for a private corporation to require U.S. citizenship of it's employees. I may be wrong.
3. "The Gov't" can get away with more in regards to searches or confiscating personal items than a private contractor.... (#Lawsuits).
.......That is outside my experience area, however, any contractor would factor the cost of litigation into their bid for the contract .....
I rather TSA than private security/contractor. IMHO
1. Better HR, screening & background checks, and integrity checks.
2. Cheap is not always better. Cheap employees and guards = higher chances of criminal activities, and bribery, especially with a private for profit security/contractor. (#Get this passed security, u know how to get around it. Meet me at Gate 35; call your wife, she'll be alive.... or call your wife, she'll have the money).
3. "The Gov't" can get away with more in regards to searches or confiscating personal items than a private contractor.... (#Lawsuits).
P.s.
4. TSA is made up of U.S. nationals. I'm not sure, but I assume it's illegal for a private corporation to require U.S. citizenship of it's employees. I may be wrong.
Serious question: If you, as pilots, could offer SPECIFIC suggestions to improve the TSA and make it "better" (more efficient, actually catching terrorists/deterring terrorist actions), what specific things would you recommend?
Specifics, not just "do away with TSA", or "make them less stupid".
First I'd back way up and look at the available data that was used to justify, form and expand TSA to begin with. Those who have investigated those stats have discovered that TSA's cheerleaders cooked the books to create threat data and incidents that did not exist, or were greatly exaggerated. That justified TSA's existence and rapid growth, as well as the cost of the equipment they wanted to buy, like backscatter scanners. This fake/exaggerated data (Tl:dr) information came out in Congressional hearings and was covered on C-Span, but was barely mentioned in the general media.
In other words, before discussing the changes to be made, I'd make sure that the underlying facts that your discussion is based on are correct. Otherwise, we're trying to fix things that never actually needed fixing. Wasted effort. In many cases, we're chasing ghosts that don't exist, but created great theater for TSA's backers. That's why insiders (and a recent Congressional Report) frequently call this whole thing "TSA Theater."
.
P.s.
4. TSA is made up of U.S. nationals. I'm not sure, but I assume it's illegal for a private corporation to require U.S. citizenship of it's employees. I may be wrong.
..........found through investigation you mention, and determine if the way TSA is doing business today, really is working and actually countering a true threat. Or whether all or some of the measures we're seeing today are, in fact, still window dressing or not.
Why would you wait for someone else to post the story, yet won't do so yourself?
TSA is bloated with mgmt
Hires less than ideal candiates for the job.
Takes away any discretion from TSA grunts
One size fits all security measures
Fails to use common sense
TSA has failed to catch a lot of contraband from getting into airports.
TSA needs to revamped from the inside out reducing mgmt types
TSA needs to be randomly checked entering the airport as well.
Get rid of the badges, they are not law enforcement nor do they have any law enforcment powers.
Raise the hiring and training standards
Empower their employees to use discretion
Train the employees in customer service. If you treat the traveling public with the respect, dignity, and professionalism they deserve, the TSA will get the same in return in most cases.
Hold employess accoutable who make errors instead of a slap on the wrist and retraining
Modify the one size fits all security and use resources more effectively - screen passengers, and employess based on threat
-Get KCM up and running ASAP
-Modify security of airport personnel including better back ground checks
-Get the know traveller program up to speed
This now leaves you more time to more effectively screen the "unknown" travels or those who set off other red flags.
my .02 worth...