I like the idea of salary information a la "the other website". Perhaps expand it to a little more than airlines...like, say, CFIs, ferry pilots, etc. maybe even a range of daily rates for various types of aircraft in different parts of the country. I know the "what should I ask for a daily rate in a beercan 200?" questions come up quite a bit on here.
Also less political debates and more funny pictures of cats.
I think some more "day in the life" articles would be cool, and perhaps if you were to anonymize the articles you could even attach a blurb about what that person's W2 looked like last year, how many days away from home, etc. all in the interest of educating up and coming pilots.