Best Forward Speed

I hate 757's the FedEx one always gets vectored in front of me because I'm a small little metro, while they're a 75. What they fail to realize is I'm much faster then them within 30 miles of the airport. If you can't do 250 to the marker, get the hell out of my way. :)

Yup! The 1900 could fly 248 to the marker for all intents and purposes.

You do that in a 757, even to a ten-mile final and you're going to be working on your go-around procedure.
 
When I say best forward speed it usually is in connection with your #1 for the sequence. It is usually well out, and before I am going to nail speeds down on the sequence, as in your number one but I haven't vectored everyone behind you to get spacing, so go fast and I will ask you your planned speed later when I am going to slap speeds on everyone to keep spacing. Now there is a certain AAirline that typically will say their best forward is 260kts....in a 767. Thats why they always go second whether they are tied, or 10 miles in front, the back guys will always catch em.
 
When I say best forward speed it usually is in connection with your #1 for the sequence. It is usually well out, and before I am going to nail speeds down on the sequence, as in your number one but I haven't vectored everyone behind you to get spacing, so go fast and I will ask you your planned speed later when I am going to slap speeds on everyone to keep spacing. Now there is a certain AAirline that typically will say their best forward is 260kts....in a 767. Thats why they always go second whether they are tied, or 10 miles in front, the back guys will always catch em.
hehe


That same AAirline always seems to hire pilots with poor eyesight, or has dirty windshields. One or the other because they never see their traffic.
 
"Best forward speed" is standard U.S. phraseology, but it is NOT standard anywhere else in the world. Non-U.S. pilots may or may not know what it means.
 
"Best forward speed" is standard U.S. phraseology, but it is NOT standard anywhere else in the world. Non-U.S. pilots may or may not know what it means.

That's indeed Interesting. One would think though, deductively speaking, that with the traffic call and deconfliction plan that tower advised, that it would be inherently obvious even if the specific meaning wasn't understood. IE- would it make any sense to slow down, if priority traffic needed to cross behind you? That's where its kind of befuddling.
 
That's indeed Interesting. One would think though, deductively speaking, that with the traffic call and deconfliction plan that tower advised, that it would be inherently obvious even if the specific meaning wasn't understood. IE- would it make any sense to slow down, if priority traffic needed to cross behind you? That's where its kind of befuddling.

You're assuming that the English skills of the crew in question allowed for them to fully understand the situation and comprehend what was going on, rather than just reading a robot script of what to say when.
 
You're assuming that the English skills of the crew in question allowed for them to fully understand the situation and comprehend what was going on, rather than just reading a robot script of what to say when.

True, I am assuming that. Only because they acknowledged the original instructions, making me think they actually understood them. :D
 
I've been the 206 overtaking, in fact. And as far as why SWA is hauling ass on final, do you really need that explained? ;)


Sent from Seat 3D

You forgot the sarcasm tag on SWA "hauling ass", unless you meant to say mired in molasses. I can only assume you're referring to their MDW overrun, but even then, those "hey lets slam dunk ourselves" profiles that get flown 40% of the time are absolutely insane.
 
But everyone here knows the meaning of "best forward speed" when requested by ATC? It's the first time in 28 years of flying that I've heard its meaning questioned over the radio, much less by an airline crew.

Kind of like Line Up and Wait the first time I heard it.
 
The other night I ended up ticking off one of the STL approach controllers. He told me to maintain best forward speed. It was a bit turbulent and I didn't see an obvious reason to go faster, so I maintained normal cruise speed, about 150 knots. I wasn't going to give the pax a loud, rough ride for nothing. A few minutes later he came back in an irritated voice with, "Is that the fastest you can go???"

I said, "No, we can go faster, what speed do you need?" He said, "170 knots." I said, "Roger, will maintain 170 knots," and pushed the power up.

I'm not a mind reader, if a controller really wants something, they need to say it!

I'm surprised to hear this you JRH. The controller gave you an instruction which you presumably read back. Just because you don't see an obvious reason doesn't mean it isn't there.

The controller could very well know what your plane is capable of, and when he said best fwd speed, he expected a number close to that. You needn't be a mind reader- the controller said exactly what he wanted, and you chose to do your own thing. Now I'm sure if you had told him that you'd prefer to hold 150, there wouldn't have been a problem.

This stuff happens every day in a 152. The controller will request best fwd speed, and I tell them that I can only give them another x knots. Never had a problem before. Again, quite surprised to see you post something like that.
 
I'm surprised to hear this you JRH. The controller gave you an instruction which you presumably read back. Just because you don't see an obvious reason doesn't mean it isn't there.

The controller could very well know what your plane is capable of, and when he said best fwd speed, he expected a number close to that. You needn't be a mind reader- the controller said exactly what he wanted, and you chose to do your own thing. Now I'm sure if you had told him that you'd prefer to hold 150, there wouldn't have been a problem.

This stuff happens every day in a 152. The controller will request best fwd speed, and I tell them that I can only give them another x knots. Never had a problem before. Again, quite surprised to see you post something like that.
Eh, I'm with him though. Generally, best forward is what I'm already giving you. If you ask that, the speed isn't going to go up, but I'll do my best to keep it from coming down until I have to, and can keep the power up in the descent. Inside the FAF, I promise I'm already going as fast as our company allows... slooooooooow.
 
If the controller says best forward speed and you want to maintain your airspeed, would you agree that you need to keep the controller in the loop so he can adjust his plan?
 
I'm surprised to hear this you JRH. The controller gave you an instruction which you presumably read back. Just because you don't see an obvious reason doesn't mean it isn't there.

The controller could very well know what your plane is capable of, and when he said best fwd speed, he expected a number close to that. You needn't be a mind reader- the controller said exactly what he wanted, and you chose to do your own thing. Now I'm sure if you had told him that you'd prefer to hold 150, there wouldn't have been a problem.

This stuff happens every day in a 152. The controller will request best fwd speed, and I tell them that I can only give them another x knots. Never had a problem before. Again, quite surprised to see you post something like that.

Two points--one is what z987k said--I'm not going ridiculously slow to begin with. It wasn't like I was doing 120 knots at "holding" power settings.

The other is that I've been screwed over by controllers so many times before that I stopped trying to predict what they're wanting. On one occasion, the controller told me to maintain best forward speed, then proceeded to vector me to the far side of the airport, then back across the airport, then down a 15 mile long downwind...all at "best forward speed." Give me a break. That was an unusual example, but less extreme cases happen to me on a regular basis.

As I said before, I'm not trying to be difficult, I'm just not a mind reader. If a controller doesn't assign a speed, don't expect me to go a certain speed! If that difference of 20 knots is seriously going to change how I get sequenced with traffic, tell me from the start, "maintain 170 knots until X mile final," and I'll do it.

The flip side to this whole situation could be that the controller wanted me to maintain my present speed and not slow down unusually early. It's an ambiguous situation. Again, another reason why a specific speed instruction needs to happen. Words mean things.

I've had multiple experienced controllers tell me this is an appropriate stance to take.
 
i never used "best foward speed" its just a stupid clrn and has no meaning no value. if i have enought traffic where i even think i need a speed i give it so i know the value (out side the FAF).

back in my ZAU days i had a trainee working the DTW arrivals over Polar arrival ,fist A/C was a DC-9 followed by a B727. he gives the DC-9 "best foward speed cross XXX at FL230" then gives the B727 "maintain 300 kts cross XXX at FL230.i asken him what he thought the DC-9 would do . "Oh he will do 320 kts" i ask if he was sure "OH yes". well as the aircraft started down the B727 was 30 to 40 knots faster then the DC-9 and he was losing spaceing, again i asked if he knew what the DC-9 was doing. "oh yea 320" ( we started with 10 mit and were down to 8, Clevland center required 10 mit at the boundry)i finally ask the DC-9 "Say IAS" pilot came back with "270 kts". well that was that pilots best foward that day.
 
I disagree that the clearance is ambiguous. It seems perfectly clear to me. Would you prefer to hear "Maintain Vne"? Is that less ambiguous? When I'm told to maintain max forward speed, I push up the power and make sure I don't exceed any limitations. If for whatever reason I cannot get to my max speed, I let the controller know. It's happened before, and they've just moved on to plan B.
 
If you can't/won't go any faster, its pretty appropriate to say something. "Best forward speed" may not be in the book anywhere, but say a Skyhawk on final with a jet to follow. How else should I convey to the pilot "Hey don't go flaps 30 7 miles out at come in at 70 knots."? Should I say, full throttle till 5 miles out, power to 75% thence at Vfe select flaps 10, thence at 1.5 miles out reduce power to 60% initiate flaps 30, thence maintain 30% above stall until landing assured."?

The other thing is, when you have a situation where the controllers know that max forward speed for how you fly your airplane is 170, and you acknowledge and do 150, it may not seem like much. After all its just 12% slower, but it can be a big thing. After seven and a half flying miles you're gone one fewer mile than I had anticipated, which if I'm gunning for 2.5 miles between planes is a 40% difference.

Now I will agree that the controller should have asked what speed you'd do on final rather than assumed and 99% of the time its a pretty useless clearance, but it does have its place.
 
Back
Top