Runway Approach Hold Signs

Sisson2011

Well-Known Member
Question regarding the runway approach holding areas on taxiways. Are these signs mandatory to hold short of at all times or just when spefically instructed to "Hold short of runway 15 approach"? The reason I'm asking if because my captain and I thought one thing, however, the ATC tower told us the opposite. So now I need to get it clarified for future reference.

I've looked it up and my belief if you only hold short at the Runway Approach Holds if you're specifically told to do so. Otherwise you taxi up to the regular runway hold line. Is this correct?
 
I thought they were mandatory if the approach was in use, if not then you can disregard. Looking for reference though.

If you are referring to ILS critical area then they are mandatory unless cleared through when in use per 2-3-5 -3-b in the AIM. However 2-3-5-3 says 3. Taxiways Located in Runway Approach Areas. These markings are used at some airports where it is necessary to hold an aircraft on a taxiway located in the approach or departure area of a runway
so that the aircraft does not interfere with the operations on that runway. This marking is collocated with the runway approach area holding position sign. When specifically instructed by ATC “Hold short of (runway xx approach area)” the pilot should stop so
no part of the aircraft extends beyond the holding position marking. (See subparagraph 2−3−8b2, Runway Approach Area Holding Position Sign, and FIG 2−3−15.)
 
Well...I don't have an FAR/AIM verse to quote but I do have a few years experience driving the aircraft on the ground.

Usually it'll be on the ATIS or instructed by the controller.

I disagree with Matt13C because at many larger airports, ILS approaches are constantly in use in both VFR and IFR conditions and we're not told and do not hold short of the ILS critical area.
 
Well...I don't have an FAR/AIM verse to quote but I do have a few years experience driving the aircraft on the ground.

Usually it'll be on the ATIS or instructed by the controller.

I disagree with Matt13C because at many larger airports, ILS approaches are constantly in use in both VFR and IFR conditions and we're not told and do not hold short of the ILS critical area.

I am just quoting the AIM, disagree if you like. I have no experience at larger airports only small ones in GA aircraft.
 
I thought they were mandatory if the approach was in use, if not then you can disregard. Looking for reference though.

If you are referring to ILS critical area then they are mandatory unless cleared through when in use per 2-3-5 -3-b in the AIM. However 2-3-5-3 says 3. Taxiways Located in Runway Approach Areas. These markings are used at some airports where it is necessary to hold an aircraft on a taxiway located in the approach or departure area of a runway
so that the aircraft does not interfere with the operations on that runway. This marking is collocated with the runway approach area holding position sign. When specifically instructed by ATC “Hold short of (runway xx approach area)” the pilot should stop so
no part of the aircraft extends beyond the holding position marking. (See subparagraph 2−3−8b2, Runway Approach Area Holding Position Sign, and FIG 2−3−15.)

Well...I don't have an FAR/AIM verse to quote but I do have a few years experience driving the aircraft on the ground.

Usually it'll be on the ATIS or instructed by the controller.

I disagree with Matt13C because at many larger airports, ILS approaches are constantly in use in both VFR and IFR conditions and we're not told and do not hold short of the ILS critical area.

Enforcement of the ILS critical area is WX dependant. If it's below 800/2, then the critical area will be in effect. ATC will notify you as will the ATIS. At other times, and when VFR, it's not in effect, although ATC could have you hold there for any reason they wanted you to.
 
Enforcement of the ILS critical area is WX dependant. If it's below 800/2, then the critical area will be in effect. ATC will notify you as will the ATIS. At other times, and when VFR, it's not in effect, although ATC could have you hold there for any reason they wanted you to.

Thanks Mike.
 
Enforcement of the ILS critical area is WX dependant. If it's below 800/2, then the critical area will be in effect. ATC will notify you as will the ATIS. At other times, and when VFR, it's not in effect, although ATC could have you hold there for any reason they wanted you to.

Mike makes a good point: ATC will instruct you to hold short. As goes without saying, ask if in doubt.

I recently learned that it is 800 and/or 2 (AIM I-I-II), and that line up and wait clearance are also restricted to Wx better than 800 and/or 2 (http://www.faa.gov/documentLibrary/media/Notice/N7210.754.pdf)


As for the APPCH-Hold, all guidance (and anecdotal experience) indicates that, unless directed to by ATC, you are not obligated to hold.
 
I concur with Mike. Every so often we were asked by maint to accomplish an auto land and would ask ATC to enforce the ILS critical area.
 
I actually ran into something like this today. We were at Eglin and they've just modified taxiway H into a "Controlled Movement Area" or CMA, for when the F35-Bs get there. There are hold short signs up and everything. I asked the ground controller about it and he said that it is like an ILS critical area and you only have to hold short when ATC (or the ATIS) tells you to.
 
Back
Top