FAA Plans Major Reduction in VOR Coverage

Its hard to get a vector to final when you are still 250 miles away, Most of the RAIM outages I have experience cover an area the size of Tennessee or Mississippi. You won't get a vector from that far away.

You sure? DC-9 drivers get vectors like that all the time.

"Turn right heading 090, direct PXV when able."
 
Yeah, that'll be real nice for people that want to file when they rent but the fbo doesn't keep the gps up to date....which seems to be everywhere.

What is stopping you from filing /G with an expired DB?


The entire system doesn't have to go down, if you lose RAIM, it does happen sometimes when its not forecasted, over a small area of the country, lets say with in 150NM of BNA, you just screwed up BNA, ATL, CHA, TYS, MEM, HSV, SDF, and LEX. Thats just the major airports around here. Navigation goes away, if ATC still want to be able to use arrivals through that area ATL MEM and IND center are going to be vectoring a lot of traffic. Thats not even taking all the smaller airports and GA traffic into account. Hell, even if everyone knew RAIM wasn't available for lets say 6 to 12 hours in a certain area, its going to create a cluster for both ATC and everyone flying in that area.

You can only use a WAAS GPS as the primary means of navigation, making RAIM irrelevant.

"Availability is the probability that a navigation system meets the accuracy and integrity requirements. Before the advent of WAAS, GPS could be unavailable for up to a total time of four days per year.The WAAS specification mandates availability as 99.999% (five nines) throughout the service area, equivalent to a downtime of just over 5 minutes per year."

I may be wrong, but I am pretty sure WAAS completely eliminates RAIM functionality, although I admit, I am unclear about it.
 
What is stopping you from filing /G with an expired DB?
Procedure changes. I think at least 2 of the GPS procedures at my home field have changed in the past 2 months. One of the planes I was flying had a 430 with a database that expired in 2008. I don't think I want to be filing /G with that thing.
 
Procedure changes. I think at least 2 of the GPS procedures at my home field have changed in the past 2 months. One of the planes I was flying had a 430 with a database that expired in 2008. I don't think I want to be filing /G with that thing.

Yeah, I wouldn't either, but if they updated them yearly or something, it wouldn't be that bad. As long as you can verify that they haven't changed, you can still use them, but 2008 is probably out of the question.
 
Admittedly it's a little bit laziness on my part too. Do I REALLY want to have to verify every procedure that I might have to use, then do the same for an alternate, etc? It just seems like a headache.
 
I remember when I started flying in 05, being told all the time that VORs were going to go away soon and everyone was just going to use GPS like they do in Europe. I'm not surprised to read this at all, I don't really agree with it though. I rarely use VORs, if I do, its just under the hood doing instrument training. However, it is nice to know I have them there as a back up. For years now, Europe has been functioning after having had most, if not all, of their VORs dismantled. I know they don't have anywhere near the volume of GA we have over here, but it must work for them.

And I'd imagine FBO's would start to update the databases on their rental aircraft if there weren't any VORs for a few hundred miles.
 
You sure? DC-9 drivers get vectors like that all the time.

"Turn right heading 090, direct PXV when able."

Just some thoughts from the other side.

A one off hack vector knowing full well that after a little bit the DC-9 will be in range of a VOR and resuming their own NAV is a little different than say a hack vector from TYS to MEM. Center is still going to have to approximate the entry point on the boundary to the star STAR. At the same time, departures will still have to be on something approximating the SID and STAR arrivals contained within something approximating the arrival corridor.

At that point it goes from a hip shot vector to micromanaging 5 left/5right. Sure its probably no worse than a storm front coming through with the on the spot bargaining on airspace and off the cuff procedures, but in storm situations usually it doesn't effect an area the size of a state and some sectors can take the extra pressure off of the effected ones. A GPS outage, however unlikely, does under this scenario.

In my little slice of heaven I have four VORs, I imagine 3 would go away under this. I would have 10 other sectors to wheel and deal with while micromanaging everything. God forbid the fourth is undergoing maintenance, which it does on a very regular basis. Where I'm at, I could manage 90% of the time. At a place where arrival rates are a serious deal, they'd be in SERIOUS trouble trying to separate airplanes.

Even worse. Where I work our tertiary backup radar is all but useless (located in a valley). Our secondary backup, the long range, hasn't functioned in several months. Our primary has two channels and not long ago one channel went down just long enough for it to get repaired before the other channel went down. I know enough non radar to keep planes from hitting. It requires having actual navigable routes and fixes to hold at, but in the terminal environment at least it isn't formally taught anymore.
 
I'm torn on this one. Both sides have benefits and consequences. Save money/ comprise reliability.

On the positive, less VOR's means less Victor airways- more airspace for aerobatic activities.
 
That is because the -9 is Chuck Norris, and the Dash 8 is not.

(with due respect to Dash Drivers)


I may have to gun for you now man! lol



Just some thoughts from the other side.

A one off hack vector knowing full well that after a little bit the DC-9 will be in range of a VOR and resuming their own NAV is a little different than say a hack vector from TYS to MEM. Center is still going to have to approximate the entry point on the boundary to the star STAR. At the same time, departures will still have to be on something approximating the SID and STAR arrivals contained within something approximating the arrival corridor.

At that point it goes from a hip shot vector to micromanaging 5 left/5right. Sure its probably no worse than a storm front coming through with the on the spot bargaining on airspace and off the cuff procedures, but in storm situations usually it doesn't effect an area the size of a state and some sectors can take the extra pressure off of the effected ones. A GPS outage, however unlikely, does under this scenario.

In my little slice of heaven I have four VORs, I imagine 3 would go away under this. I would have 10 other sectors to wheel and deal with while micromanaging everything. God forbid the fourth is undergoing maintenance, which it does on a very regular basis. Where I'm at, I could manage 90% of the time. At a place where arrival rates are a serious deal, they'd be in SERIOUS trouble trying to separate airplanes.

Even worse. Where I work our tertiary backup radar is all but useless (located in a valley). Our secondary backup, the long range, hasn't functioned in several months. Our primary has two channels and not long ago one channel went down just long enough for it to get repaired before the other channel went down. I know enough non radar to keep planes from hitting. It requires having actual navigable routes and fixes to hold at, but in the terminal environment at least it isn't formally taught anymore.


I am glad to have a controller back up my thoughts.
 
Just some thoughts from the other side.

A one off hack vector knowing full well that after a little bit the DC-9 will be in range of a VOR and resuming their own NAV is a little different than say a hack vector from TYS to MEM. Center is still going to have to approximate the entry point on the boundary to the star STAR. At the same time, departures will still have to be on something approximating the SID and STAR arrivals contained within something approximating the arrival corridor.

At that point it goes from a hip shot vector to micromanaging 5 left/5right. Sure its probably no worse than a storm front coming through with the on the spot bargaining on airspace and off the cuff procedures, but in storm situations usually it doesn't effect an area the size of a state and some sectors can take the extra pressure off of the effected ones. A GPS outage, however unlikely, does under this scenario.

In my little slice of heaven I have four VORs, I imagine 3 would go away under this. I would have 10 other sectors to wheel and deal with while micromanaging everything. God forbid the fourth is undergoing maintenance, which it does on a very regular basis. Where I'm at, I could manage 90% of the time. At a place where arrival rates are a serious deal, they'd be in SERIOUS trouble trying to separate airplanes.

Even worse. Where I work our tertiary backup radar is all but useless (located in a valley). Our secondary backup, the long range, hasn't functioned in several months. Our primary has two channels and not long ago one channel went down just long enough for it to get repaired before the other channel went down. I know enough non radar to keep planes from hitting. It requires having actual navigable routes and fixes to hold at, but in the terminal environment at least it isn't formally taught anymore.

If the GPS system went down, do you think the NAS would continue to operate? Or said another way, wouldn't the priority be to get aircraft on the ground, but prevent them from being launched should such a failure occur?
 
I used to be the guy that was yelling and screaming about how ditching NDB's was a horrible idea, until I realized that I sounded like the guys that probably said the same thing about getting rid of radio range flying, and how much of an improvement the new technology was.

Dead reckoning and pilotage are still suitable replacements for long range nav in the domestic United States, to say nothing of current radar coverage.

Get rid of VOR's and NDB's.

Bring back Flight Navigators to the airlines!

I'm torn on this one. Both sides have benefits and consequences. Save money/ comprise reliability.

On the positive, less VOR's means less Victor airways- more airspace for aerobatic activities.

If GA would pay their user fees, none of this would happen regards VORs disappearing. :)
 
If the GPS system went down, do you think the NAS would continue to operate? Or said another way, wouldn't the priority be to get aircraft on the ground, but prevent them from being launched should such a failure occur?


Short answer yes we'll make it work somehow (lets be clear I'm talking about if we shut down a huge number of VORs as is proposed). Yeah departures would stop. And its the guys in the air I'd worry about.

Long answer, let me drag you into the ATC world of what ifs.

Every morning at the TRACON side of things we get a call asking about our arrival rate. 48 (or 48 arrivals an hour)? Sure! No weather, we're VFR with good winds. Now the GPS system fails. Center has few if any points to hold at. My STARS are for the most part useless (not to mention center guys trying to issue vectors is a joke... I kid... kinda). I'm calling downwind turns when otherwise I'd have the luxury of saying at X fly heading XYZ. Maybe that 48 rate isn't coming, but I can promise you a 30 is. Holding is a severe issue because well where do they hold? Our one working VOR would be at the confluence of 7 center sectors. That'd be a sick stack. I have to work twice as hard, effectively a 60 rate. We may have been able to hold it together on that VFR day but one or two banged in sick. By the time the over time calls get in, its over.

Its honestly a difference of views. Your view of safe isn't professionally mine (though I'd say as a pilot two miles between two skyhawks is plenty). Professionally for me, thats a deal. What works for you may not work for me.
 
We still do ocean crossings in 767s without GPS. Don't get rid of VORs yet!
DME-DME-IRU very hard to do without DME-DME.


Short answer yes we'll make it work somehow (lets be clear I'm talking about if we shut down a huge number of VORs as is proposed). Yeah departures would stop. And its the guys in the air I'd worry about.
Occurs to me, how many facilities are actually able to do surveillance approaches these days?
 
Great idea..bet all of our ability to navigate on one of the most fragile systems out there (I love GPS-makes our lives alot easier, but that doesn't stop it from being a fragile system).
 
Its honestly a difference of views. Your view of safe isn't professionally mine (though I'd say as a pilot two miles between two skyhawks is plenty). Professionally for me, thats a deal. What works for you may not work for me.

That's fair, and in general, the reason I fall on this side of things is because 99% of my work is done in VFR conditions. I shot three approaches on my last trip, which is three more approaches in one trip than I've flown in 3 months I think. My average day consists of picking the airport out from 50 miles out (but we won't tell you we can see it from 50 miles out we're not 110% positive it's the right airport, because we've only been to X outstation 2 times in the last year) and then doing a visual approach.

The chances of having a hard IMC day across the entire country on the day that the GPS system randomly craps the bed is just about as likely as the entire VOR system crapping the bed, which is, of course, possible. I know as pilots we love to think of our VOR's as impervious to any interference, but that's not the case.
 
[quote="Occurs to me, how many facilities are actually able to do surveillance approaches these days?[/quote]

Not enough to be a viable option 99.9% of the time. The only one I've ever shot has been decommissioned.
 
Back
Top