FAA Plans Major Reduction in VOR Coverage

braunpilot

What day is it?
While I understand why they want to, I don't think now is the right time. Maybe it is and I'm just old fashioned.

http://www.flyingmag.com/news/faa-plans-major-reduction-vor-coverage?cmpid=010312

The FAA recently released a proposed rule for a gradual but major reduction in the VOR navigation system in the United States. The proposal transitions navigation services to performance-based navigation (PBN) such as GPS and WAAS, and would keep only VORs at what the FAA calls the “Core 30” airports around the country and VORs located above 5,000 feet.

With the increased use of GPS and proven accuracy of WAAS approaches, the FAA appears to view the cost of operation of the VOR system as excessive. According to the FAA proposal 80 percent of the 967 VORs have reached their “economic service life” and cost the agency $110 million per year. The document also claims that replacing all VORs would cost $1 billion.

But while this measure would save the budget crunched government agency a significant chunk of money it seems a little premature to begin a major reduction of the established navigation system. The system could prove immensely valuable in case of GPS interference, a threat that is real and has recently been widely discussed in relation to LightSquared’s launch of a new broadband network.

While the proposal would enable pilots who fly at the major airports and at higher elevations to navigate in case of a GPS failure, what would happen to the pilots flying in remote areas if the satellite signals are compromised? And there is no question that the GPS system is far superior, but there are still pilots who rely strictly on the VOR system for navigation - those without GPS receivers in the cockpit.

You can read the proposed rule by clicking here and make comments on its content until March 7.
 
GPS maybe a superior system when it comes to accuracy, BUT its very susceptible to interference and easily jammed. Something as simple as a amplified TV antenna went into self oscillation and jammed GPS reception for a whole harbor in California. http://www.gpsworld.com/gnss-system/signal-processing/the-hunt-rfi-776

First they killed the most robust/redudant land and air navigation system we had (LORAN) and now we are going kill the majority of our air navigation system and put all our eggs in one basket (GPS).

If we just took a fraction of the money we send to countries that hate us in the form of foreign aid, we could easily have kept funding the VOR and Loran systems.
 
Yeah, that'll be real nice for people that want to file when they rent but the fbo doesn't keep the gps up to date....which seems to be everywhere.
 
$110 mill a year to operate the VORs seems like a drop in the FAA's operations bucket. Even a billion over something like 10 years to replace them doesn't seem that far out of line.
 
I fly IFR with a VFR GPS if I'm lucky. I really enjoy navigating for VOR to VOR on airways. I've never been much a direct to guy.
 
Here I was hoping to get a job at the FAA flying around and repairing VORs for a living... Guess I need to come up with a new plan. ;)
 
I used to be the guy that was yelling and screaming about how ditching NDB's was a horrible idea, until I realized that I sounded like the guys that probably said the same thing about getting rid of radio range flying, and how much of an improvement the new technology was.

Dead reckoning and pilotage are still suitable replacements for long range nav in the domestic United States, to say nothing of current radar coverage.

Get rid of VOR's and NDB's.
 
The VOR by the airport I used to work at was a piece of crap that had only a few usable radials, and even those were good out to just 8 miles. Pretty damn useless, but the FAA wouldn't invest the money to fix it, even though we were told there were new Doppler VOR systems sitting on a shelf ready to be installed. Seems the FAA was happy with requiring aircraft flying in the area to be GPS equipped, and that was 3 years ago already.
 
The VOR by the airport I used to work at was a piece of crap that had only a few usable radials, and even those were good out to just 8 miles. Pretty damn useless, but the FAA wouldn't invest the money to fix it, even though we were told there were new Doppler VOR systems sitting on a shelf ready to be installed. Seems the FAA was happy with requiring aircraft flying in the area to be GPS equipped, and that was 3 years ago already.
There's nothing like hearing Approach say, "Beercan 207, we show you about a mile left of the final approach course for the VOR 26," when your needle is centered, because there's a blankety-blank building that the airport allowed to be built that is scalloping the signal. And your receiver was just tested and found in tolerance. And, and, and... (And the mountains are about a mile and a half left of course, of course.)

That said, out west, I really want to keep VORs. It's not like we can do a lot of "cleared direct" out here anyway. I have seen the light that is advanced RNAV and still want to keep the green world around.
 
I used to be the guy that was yelling and screaming about how ditching NDB's was a horrible idea, until I realized that I sounded like the guys that probably said the same thing about getting rid of radio range flying, and how much of an improvement the new technology was.

Dead reckoning and pilotage are still suitable replacements for long range nav in the domestic United States, to say nothing of current radar coverage.

Get rid of VOR's and NDB's.
Unless you are IMC... Then all else goes out the window...
 
While I agree that GPS is a great tool, I find it interesting that even in our E-6B, with all the bells and whistles, the navigation system is designed to utilize scanning DME off of VOR stations to provide primary navigation.

I think we could do without VOR, but I do believe that it's the beginning of a further path of possibly retiring maintenance on ILS systems and other precision items. If I've learned only one thing in the military, it would have to be "doing more with less" just means you'll be asked to do even "more with less" next time around.

And with GPS always having the option of being "degraded" by the military, I don't think that relying on GPS as our ONLY source of precision guidance isn't the best option.

Call me Chicken Little if ya like... I can see both sides, but think that more study and information would need to be gathered first.
 
And with GPS always having the option of being "degraded" by the military, I don't think that relying on GPS as our ONLY source of precision guidance isn't the best option.

Selective Availability has been gone since Bill Clinton was president. In addition to that, the Block IIF (newest generation of satellites) don't even have the hardware/software equipment for SA.
 
Yeah, and if the entire GPS system has gone down AND it's IMC you've probably got larger problems on your hands.



The entire system doesn't have to go down, if you lose RAIM, it does happen sometimes when its not forecasted, over a small area of the country, lets say with in 150NM of BNA, you just screwed up BNA, ATL, CHA, TYS, MEM, HSV, SDF, and LEX. Thats just the major airports around here. Navigation goes away, if ATC still want to be able to use arrivals through that area ATL MEM and IND center are going to be vectoring a lot of traffic. Thats not even taking all the smaller airports and GA traffic into account. Hell, even if everyone knew RAIM wasn't available for lets say 6 to 12 hours in a certain area, its going to create a cluster for both ATC and everyone flying in that area.
 
The entire system doesn't have to go down, if you lose RAIM, it does happen sometimes when its not forecasted, over a small area of the country, lets say with in 150NM of BNA, you just screwed up BNA, ATL, CHA, TYS, MEM, HSV, SDF, and LEX. Thats just the major airports around here. Navigation goes away, if ATC still want to be able to use arrivals through that area ATL MEM and IND center are going to be vectoring a lot of traffic. Thats not even taking all the smaller airports and GA traffic into account. Hell, even if everyone knew RAIM wasn't available for lets say 6 to 12 hours in a certain area, its going to create a cluster for both ATC and everyone flying in that area.

If the signal goes away, you get a vector to final, shoot the ILS like you were planning, and then go to the overnight.

This is not Armageddon. If it were up to pilots, we'd still have LORAN boxes in our planes "just in case." Thankfully, we're not in charge of making those decisions because we'd go completely overboard every time.
 
If the signal goes away, you get a vector to final, shoot the ILS like you were planning, and then go to the overnight.

This is not Armageddon. If it were up to pilots, we'd still have LORAN boxes in our planes "just in case." Thankfully, we're not in charge of making those decisions because we'd go completely overboard every time.
Its hard to get a vector to final when you are still 250 miles away, Most of the RAIM outages I have experience cover an area the size of Tennessee or Mississippi. You won't get a vector from that far away.
 
Back
Top