AMR files Chapter 11...

Friend of mine lost about 1.2 million in retirement/pension from the US Airways bankruptcy, which absolutely sucks... but he planned for the worst ahead of time and he's still in good shape. He flight instructed on the side for years (and sub leased the aircraft also) had another aircraft on a 135 plus owns property and small bar. He did it right and had plenty of side work. He said a lot of other pilots at his company literally had no 401ks or retirement savings whatsoever and got absolutely screwed which I couldn't believe (I'm 28 and I already have a 401K).

He's ex military and the advice he gave me is this... no one cares about your finances more than you do and no one cares about your career more than you do so its your responsibility to take care of yourself. I say get it while the gettins good, make your money and save your money because the cow always dies eventually. If your have an excess of 2500 to 3000 per month on your paycheck and your burning at Margaritaville and Club Space then shame on you.

Not saying I don't hate the management of these companies for what they do... but did we expect anything else? I also recommend the book "Who moved my Cheese?" Good reading!
 
There's a large difference between suspecting that you're likely to be robbed at gunpoint and suggesting that armed robber is a good guy just trying to provide for his family in a tough economy, so what's the big deal, anyway. Especially if the armed robber is paid more in a day than you'll see in a year.

I've met my share of grovelling bootlickers in my time, but honestly..."It's not their fault"???????
 
mandatory retirement age would be increased to age 70, according to devil on my shoulder saying. :p

The retirement age is going to increase to the point where it will be mandatory for the eldest pilots to have the quick donning masks on at all times :P
 
He said a lot of other pilots at his company literally had no 401ks or retirement savings whatsoever and got absolutely screwed which I couldn't believe (I'm 28 and I already have a 401K).

That is because their contract guaranteed their pension and their retirement. Just like you expect to pick up your paycheck on Friday, they expected to get their compensation that was agreed to when they began working.
 
That is because their contract guaranteed their pension and their retirement. Just like you expect to pick up your paycheck on Friday, they expected to get their compensation that was agreed to when they began working.

That seems like a mind-numbing obvious point and yet I seem to have to explain that to people too. Do people just hate pilots for having a pension and decide to deride them any chance they get instead of recognizing the obvious?
 
That seems like a mind-numbing obvious point and yet I seem to have to explain that to people too. Do people just hate pilots for having a pension and decide to deride them any chance they get instead of recognizing the obvious?



No they just think with the average intelligence probably above average that they should know to never trust anybody else with your money, and to always have a backup plan.
 
No they just think with the average intelligence probably above average that they should know to never trust anybody else with your money, and to always have a backup plan.

In theory, sure.

However, there is a sort of "generation gap" that we're not talking about. The average pilot who got the shaft in the last decade with little chance of recovery before mandatory retirement most likely won that job under a different set of circumstances than you or I.

Back in the day, you put forth a honest days work and you get an honest days pay. You work X number of years and you'll receive Y when you retire.

Now you and I are babies of Lincoln Savings & Loan, 9/11, the dot com bubble, the real estate crash, the subprime mortgage crisis, the Boeskies, the Millikens, the Lays, the Fastows, etc so we've been brought up under a different set of expectations and norms.

It's wholly disingenuous for anyone, including myself, 40-something or younger, to exclaim "Ha! Dummies didn't have a backup plan for retirement and made the foolish error of trusting A and B funds and pensions".

We really have to widen the aperture.
 
In theory, sure.

However, there is a sort of "generation gap" that we're not talking about. The average pilot who got the shaft in the last decade with little chance of recovery before mandatory retirement most likely won that job under a different set of circumstances than you or I.

Back in the day, you put forth a honest days work and you get an honest days pay. You work X number of years and you'll receive Y when you retire.
life under Glass–Steagall Act of 1932.

Now you and I are babies of Lincoln Savings & Loan, 9/11, the dot com bubble, the real estate crash, the subprime mortgage crisis, the Boeskies, the Millikens, the Lays, the Fastows, etc so we've been brought up under a different set of expectations and norms.
life after the repeal (or dismantling) of the Glass-Steagall...Depository Institutions Deregulation and Monetary Control Act of 1980, the Garn–St. Germain Depository Institutions Act of 1982, and the Gramm–Leach–Bliley Act of 1999.
 
Sidekicks.jpg
 
No they just think with the average intelligence probably above average that they should know to never trust anybody else with your money, and to always have a backup plan.

Although Doug has a much clearer POV and comments steeped in history, and my point is tawdry I'll add it anyway.

You, pullup, and I are products of the time. Isn't it a little unfair to expect our reality to be the reality of our father's when things have shifted so rapidly? Furthermore how do we expect them to make the switch and save up for something they thought was taken care of (as it was for their fathers) in a timely manner? Tough for me to make the leap.
 
Although Doug has a much clearer POV and comments steeped in history, and my point is tawdry I'll add it anyway.

You, pullup, and I are products of the time. Isn't it a little unfair to expect our reality to be the reality of our father's when things have shifted so rapidly? Furthermore how do we expect them to make the switch and save up for something they thought was taken care of (as it was for their fathers) in a timely manner? Tough for me to make the leap.

A few years ago, I heard a news report that stated the average 30 year old man today makes less than his father did at 30, inflation adjustment included. Given all things on the economic slide.. it would appear that there's been a dramatic slide in the way business is conducted now versus then. Everybody wants more for less and nobody wants to think about how we pay the bill.

The real kick in the taint is that every time somebody's retirement plan gets pulled out from under them, we all wind up paying for it one way or the other. Social security, medicare taxes, social decline, so on, so on.

It's as if the corporate goons don't just want to outsource everything to sweatshops elsewhere.. but that they want us reduced to sweatshops here, too.
 
I am relieved to see that some members here "get it". Thank you to Doug, Dale, genot and Jynxy. Since 1978 over 200 airlines have either merged, been taken over or have gone out of business in the US alone with the majority of them occurring in the 80's and 90's. This was not the norm nor what happened for our Fathers who flew the line and for their sons like me during most of my career. Many of you will not even remember that many of the Legacy Carriers were started and owned and run by pilots. This was the case with smaller operations as well.

If someone would have told me that a a man such as Captain Sullenberger would wind up carrying PB&J sammies with him in his flight bag because he no longer was provided with crew meals and would live to see his retirement at the end of his career go up in smoke after decades of dedication, I would had not believed them. I could not envision a day where mainline pilots could no longer afford to retire and had to keep flying.

It began with deregulation but it did not end there. Pilots became pilots because of their love of flying and aviation and because it was their dream. Many of them came from the Military after WWII. They went to work for what were Legacy Flag Ship Carriers out of pride, even patriotism back in the day, out of being even a small part of aviation history and because they knew they had a future with a global company, (or one that had the potential to become global) a company who promised them many things in return for all their training, paying dues and dedication. Hell, some of them even started their own carriers. There were no Regional airlines as we know them today.

So I can see in part why the younger generation of pilots is completely unaware and not emotionally attached as to the plights of pilots in their 50's, 60's and those even older who have since retired. But it would be valuable to know and understand the history of these men and the history of the carriers and their CEO's and exactly what has taken place in the last few decades to truly understand where these older generation pilots are and why and how this happened. Spouting off some of the clueless and flippant comments that I have seen here, is sad to me, disrespectful and dangerous. Therefore by the grace of God may you not go there yourself in the future. There are many lessons to be learned.

In my Father's day and in most of my own there was no need for a back-up plan as some have suggested. You trained, you flew, you worked hard, you loved what you did, you were proud of what you did and you were rewarded, respected, valued and treated as you should be. The carriers made money and the employees made money. You believed in your company and they believed in you. That was it. That is how it was and it was that way for many decades for all pilots. You had security. I thought to myself, I am working for a pioneering company that began in 1931. We had been the makers of commercial aviation history. They had begun as a partnership with Boeing. How better does it get? My Father was here for 30 years! He had a wonderful career. I am set. If you were a mainliner and especially if you were flying internationally as I was, you had it made. As it tuned out decades later, not so much.

CEO's and owners used to be more like David Neeleman at JB. That all changed in the last three three decades at all of the major carriers. Unless you understand the history in detail of this, and what these owners and various CEO did, have done and continue to do, you really have no idea as to the causations of what has happened to our industry and why you see the mindset and generation gap between the older pilot groups and the newer pilots and what the older groups have lived through and how they got to be where they currently are.

I would suggest the book Hard Landing by Thomas Petzinger as an historical and educational read for anyone who cares.
 
Back
Top