Hmmm....mine showed up really cheap on ebay, and was a really nice airplane....so that's how I picked.
The -2 is, IMO, the best of the breed. You get the 165hp engine, the baggage compartment (straight 108's don't have that, 01 and up does), rudder trim, but you don't have the ugly gigantic tail of the -3. Handling wise, the -3 has a bigger rudder, but it's probably a wash, since it has a bigger tail, the 108, -1 and -2 are easier to deal with in x-winds (I'm told).
I don't think you can go wrong, look for a good airplane in great mechanical condtion, and you'll be happy either way.
Mine's metalized, which I was indifferent about, there's not much weight difference, I can leave it outside if need be (I don't) but the rags look better, so it's a wash. Google N9087K to see my bird