WalterSobchak
Well-Known Member
Now it is I agree. You have two carriers represented by a common JCBA owned by the same company so, Yes THIS now becomes an asset transfer.B.S. Mesaba jets coming to Pinnacle is not a merger. It's an asset transfer.
However Express I was owned by NWA(1997) and it transfered flying to Mesaba who was independant. That in no way reflects a holding company transfering assets within. It is one company giving a completely different company aircraft. (See both carriers are owned by DIFFERENT companies)
Under your logic how is this any different? There is no merging of the 2 certificates such as NWA/DAL. Its an asset transfer from the 9L certificate to the XJ certificate. You only like things if they benefit you though.The only true "merger" is the Colgan aircraft coming to Mesaba turboprops, and the net result being "Mesaba" and the Colgan certificate disappearing. This is a merger.
OK. We can agree on that. However the Pinnacle Corporation has merged its management with Mesaba and merged positions to create synergy. (See numerous memo's with the "new" management team). So they are being moved from one operating certificate to another withing one holding company with one pilot group represented by one CBA. OK you are right on this one.A bunch of RJs being moved from Mesaba to Pinnacle is NOT a merger. It is an asset transfer.
Actually they were. We have a thing called "scope" at Mesaba. In our Previous CBA it was outlined in section 1 of our 2004 JCBA. Also the 2007 bill (McCaskill-Bond Bill 2007 Airline Seniority reform) prohibits this. So you are completely wrong on both accounts.Had we not done the whole "one list" thing, don't think for a second that pilots would be "entitled" to come with the 900s. And if they did, Pinnacle was under no obligation to integrate them into DOH or even relative.
Go become a Flight Attendant. They live off blind rumors and bliss. I pretty sure the steel workers could use a good man like you. I hear there are really quick upgrades over there.Funny thing is, our FA union took a hardstand and outright called the CRJ-900 movement an asset transfer, not a merger. They are bent on making sure the Mesaba XJs get stapled.
You argue with yourself all you want because you have done a wonderful job. When you want to leave the kids table and sit with the adults and have a factual discussion let us know. The same way the 9L planes/pilots are being operated via the Mesaba procedures is a "transfer" as well. So your logic is still conflicting here. Accept you are trying to find a way to make your position seem more mighty.Anyway, gee, thanks for the "favor" of offering 3-to-1. I will argue that the RJs coming to 9E is not a merger, the only true merger is among Colgan and Mesaba props. That will become one operating certificate. XJ 900s will come to Pinnacle, become Pinnacle standardized, and operated the Pinnacle way. This is not a merger, just a transfer of airplanes.
Had one contract not gone through Pinnacle Corp would have been forced to operate 3 seperate certificates. See Section 1 of 2004 XJ CBA and the previously noted Airline Seniority bill.Had "one list" not gone through, you'd be looking at the rough end of a 3-to-1 integration as best case scenario. I like you how you capitalize "it was a FAVOR done for them." We'd love to return that favor...![]()
Considering you are worried "about your upgrade" why are you even bringing up LOA 21? Were you even in Jr High when that happened? Because that "screwed you"? You are representing yourself well by showing how you think one pilot group should be pillaged to suit your upgrade. We know your feeling about this. If you can bend it to suit you its gospel. If it conflicts with your desires you argue with reality.
BTW you still keep responding? I thought you were done with this?