Pinnacle Mesaba Colgan Transition and merger

Yup sounds about right red book vs green book, NWA vs Republic. The story I told was actually something I could see cherokee cruiser doing. It was all because the the FO and FE were older/more senior at their previous airline and pissed because they werent Capt yet. Let me assure you though that crap happened way too often. Just did a BFR with a old retired NWA guy a few months ago as well and he backed up everything I was ever told growing up. Lots of stories about the same crap. Hopefully it doesnt end up like that here


When I was jumpseating on the NWA 727........1996 it was.......all three crew were from different tribes, if you will. We're up at cruise, and the FE makes a little smalltalk to me; weird since we'd been sterile cockpit all the way up to cruise and still were so. So during the course of the smalltalk, the usual stuff about background etc, I ask the FE about where the Capt and FO are from background-wise (civil, military, etc). He answers "Don't know. Don't care. You'll have to ask them." And both the Capt and FO aren't doing any talking to each other either except for all business.

Un-comfortable! :)
 
Yup sounds about right red book vs green book, NWA vs Republic. The story I told was actually something I could see cherokee cruiser doing. It was all because the the FO and FE were older/more senior at their previous airline and pissed because they werent Capt yet. Let me assure you though that crap happened way too often. Just did a BFR with a old retired NWA guy a few months ago as well and he backed up everything I was ever told growing up. Lots of stories about the same crap. Hopefully it doesnt end up like that here

Hopefully Chair-ohh-key gets his upgrade from Bloche and leaves and quickly as God damn possible. Not much of a co-worker to have to deal with, obviously. If this SLI doesn't work out how he wants it to, hopefully his head explodes and non of us have to deal with the blowback of his inability to deal with this merger.
 
There hasn't been any growth at Pinnacle Inc in a few years, almost 4 years since the 16 900s were selected for Delta flying. The $191 million convertible note from the NWA bankruptcy was used to buy Colgan with 20 million, and the remaining money to buy Colgan Q400s. All the while, Pinnacle told our ALPA that our ALPA contract proposal would bankrupt the company. That money could have been used to get us a new contract, grow us more, and get us Q400s.


What? Mesaba is a guaranteed shrinking carrier, losing all their Saab flying with Delta. They were lucky to use connections with Pinnacle Holdings to get 7 Saabs flying out of LGA for US Airways Express. The other 3 dozen plus Saabs are all heading to the desert. Not much to offer, considering that if Mesaba was standalone carrier, they would be furloughing hundreds of pilots and FAs as a result of Saabs being parked. As for Colgan, what have they bought to the table? Everyone knows that Colgan is a tarnished name, an embarassment since Flight 3407. There's a reason Pinnacle wants the Colgan name disappeared altogether.


Well, cheers. No amounts of beotching on this forum will change anything. It's Bloch's final decision. But I'm hardly alone when I say this: hopefully the pitchforks won't have to come out.

You just COULDN'T say Colgan, huh? As a Colgan pilot, while that LGA flying is ours and always has been, I'm happy we can bring Mesaba brothers and sisters off the street.

Like it or not CC, this seniority list is going to come out and it's not going to be ANYTHING like any of our groups want. So- PREPARE YOURSELF.
 
Can you say with 100% faith that Pinnacle would be hiring right now?


I can. 'Course it's not for growth reasons. The only reason we didn't furlough when everyone else did was because management a) couldn't get people to come to class when hired and b) runs things so short staffed in the first place that we were properly staffed for the first time in a LOOOOONG time when our hours were cut back. We were canceling flights occasionally due to sick calls or crews out of position, yet they STILL would occasionally trot out the "furlough" flag. Honestly, we needed to hire about a year before we actually started. By the time we DID start, enough guys had left to places like jetBlue and Emirates (along with a few that just said "screw it") that we're behind the eight ball now.
 
I can. 'Course it's not for growth reasons. The only reason we didn't furlough when everyone else did was because management a) couldn't get people to come to class when hired and b) runs things so short staffed in the first place that we were properly staffed for the first time in a LOOOOONG time when our hours were cut back. We were canceling flights occasionally due to sick calls or crews out of position, yet they STILL would occasionally trot out the "furlough" flag. Honestly, we needed to hire about a year before we actually started. By the time we DID start, enough guys had left to places like jetBlue and Emirates (along with a few that just said "screw it") that we're behind the eight ball now.

Makes you feel any better I saw 5 delayed ASA airplanes in MEM for lack of crews (late arriving I believe). Heh
 
Then shut up.
Why? Mr. Internet Internet Tough Guy. Don't tell me what to do, thanks very much.

So that being said, rather than being sympathetic, I hope you specifically get the shaft. I can be an ass too, and I guarantee you I'm damn good at it.
I think the more and more you Colgan people post in this thread, the more your true colors truly show up. Hoping that someone specifically gets a shaft speaks volumes of your character. And from your posts, you don't have to say that "you can be an ass too." I think it is clear you are one, and "damn good at it." Those are your own words......

Easy there everyone...

Is it time for people to step back from the keyboard?
Ya think? Instead of having an adult conversation, people here have resorted to personal attacks against me. No matter, I've seen this before in the Gulfstream/Jet U threads.
 
lol.. umm... how much of that 191 million note came off your back? Your ranting about money the company made before you had any considerable time in. I have to ask, with Delta pawning off the regionals, cutting flying, shifting planes around left and right, how "stable" do you think your job was? Can you say with 100% faith that Pinnacle would be hiring right now? As far as I can tell, there really hasn't been any "growth" on those crj-200's. By purchasing Messaba, PNCL has taken a step to make sure that they keep the flying they have. Colgan has been growing pretty steadily, before and after PNCL. Total growth post 2007 is only like 250-300 pilots.
The 191 million came off the collective pilot group's back, the Pinnacle pilots, not me alone. And YES, our future at Pinnacle, as a standalone carrier, was great all the way until 2017. That's when the first contract is due up for the CRJ-200s with Delta. The CRJ-900 contracts weren't due up until later. Up until the Delta merger, we did have NWA and DAL as partners. But our regional contracts are one of the longest in duration, and we are on of only a few carriers who haven't had any airplanes parked. So YES, my future was far more secure than a Mesaba future of parking several dozen fleets. Even if we didn't purchase Mesaba, we'd still be fine. Keep in mind, with the purchase of Mesaba, our Delta relationship only extended the contract duration for the CRJ-900s. The CRJ-200s are and still were guaranteed under contract through 2017, with or without the Mesaba purchase. There was no net change there. As for us hiring, look at kellwolf's post above. The short answer is, YES, we would be hiring. Attrition, people getting hired elsewhere, some getting fed up, etc.

Without all 3 pilots groups, each company likely would have been much worse for the wear. Grow up, and stop yelling me me me, it gets old, and I'm pretty sure the only people that are saying the same things as you, are similar, junior FO's.
See above paragraph. Pinnacle Airlines had its RJ contracts with Delta for long duration, longer than any other regional today. The Mesaba purchase did not extend the duration of our CRJ-200s, only extended the duration of the contracts for the CRJ-900s. The 200s are still due up in 2017. The 900s go through 2023 (I believe). But if we didn't purchase Mesaba, our long term contracts were still in effect and unharmed. So no, we as Pinnacle were not "worse off" before. IMO, we are worse off acquiring a guaranteed shrinking carrier. How can anyone with a straight face say that acquiring an airline that is parking over 3 dozen airplanes is a "good" idea. With the Saabs gone, the pilots and FAs will be furloughed. As a standalone carrier, Mesaba would take the burden alone by itself. But with this SLI, this furlough burden will also fall on the shoulders of Pinnacle and Colgan pilots, depending on where they fall on the list.

Your bring up the LGA usairways flying... just curious, but, what is the 9e relationship with airways? What is the 9e relationship with CAL? or UAL for that matter? You were flying code share for 1 carrier, with all your eggs in 1 basket.
It was technically two carriers, NWA and DAL, that merged in one. Even with one carrier, our RJ contracts were (and still are) long term, one of the longest in the industry. Nothing wrong with feeding one carrier. In fact, one of the most stable regionals today, Eagle, has served one carrier only. And they have done it for decades without trouble. Now when their RJ contracts are up, then it may be a different story, but they have gone strong. Pinnacle is no different.
 
Well, cheers. No amounts of beotching on this forum will change anything. It's Bloch's final decision.

Why? Mr. Internet Internet Tough Guy. Don't tell me what to do, thanks very much.

You are the only one on this forum beotching. HAHAHAHAHA. I really hope you don't get a random drug test from the company. At this point I am not so sure you would pass. Or maybe that would be best for everyone at the combined group. One less know-it-all.
 
Hoping that someone specifically gets a shaft speaks volumes of your character.


mirror.jpg


Might wanna look in one of these before you go making statements like that.....
 
mirror.jpg


Might wanna look in one of these before you go making statements like that.....

Absolutely not, kellwolf! When did I ever say I want someone to get the shaft? All I've said, over and over again, is I don't want a JUNIOR pilot to go above a more senior Pinnacle pilot, say hired in 2007, for an upgrade on a CRJ at Pinnacle. That is not wishing shafting for someone. If anything, it is not wanting to get shafted as a Pinnacle FO.

As for DOH, I used to think it would be fair. DOH simply credits you for time that you've spent at your airline. Period. So how would that be unfair? Now, I'm starting to not want DOH, not because of Colgan, but because of Mesaba. They bring a pretty senior group into our mix, and DOH would make them out like bandits, with the resulting layoffs from the 3-dozen plus Saabs being burdened onto the Pinnacle/Colgan pilots. In fact, if it was DOH all the way, most of Colgan guys would get the shaft for the impending furlough as a result of all the Saab parkings.

To recap, I have never hoped that someone gets the shaft. So, I do not need to look in the mirror.
 
Hey Cherokee_Cruiser:

Your a 250 HR wonder right? No offense but its true right?

I got lucky by getting hired at Colgan in 08' and I was fortunate to upgrade a few months ago. It was pure luck and being in the right place at the right time. You need to realize that you also got a lucky break and got hired with a ridiculous amount of flight time. Back 10-15 years ago you'd still be instructing and trying to get a job flying a Navajo with cancelled checks in the middle of the night. Instead your pushing buttons and slinging gear in a big pretty RJ and you have a much better story to sell to chicks in bars.

Don't be angry if a "junior FO", as you call him, upgrades before you. Most of the "junior FOs" at Colgan got hired affter the 250hr wave and had a buttload more time than you, and the ink actually dried on their commercial ticket. If they chose to buy their jobs their DOH would probably be senior to yours anyhow.

I would rather have ANY COLGAN pilot act as PIC on an aircraft carrying my entire family rather than some clown that got hired into a jet with 250hrs that would probably cry to mommy the first time the autopilot didn't work.

Do you even have enough PIC time to upgrade?

I have the utmost respect for just about every Pinnacle and Mesaba pilot. I really hope this thing works out and the Pinnacle and Mesaba guys that really paid their dues get to upgrade. Personally I don't deserve to be an RJ CA yet and neither do you CC. Don't worry about me taking any RJ openings anytime soon.

So far CC you made it up to the number two position on my 9E/XJ Dbag list. There's only two on the list so you should be honored, it's and elite group :)
 
.

As for DOH, I used to think it would be fair. DOH simply credits you for time that you've spent at your airline. Period. So how would that be unfair? Now, I'm starting to not want DOH, not because of Colgan, but because of Mesaba. They bring a pretty senior group into our mix, and DOH would make them out like bandits, with the resulting layoffs from the 3-dozen plus Saabs being burdened onto the Pinnacle/Colgan pilots. In fact, if it was DOH all the way, most of Colgan guys would get the shaft for the impending furlough as a result of all the Saab parkings.

To recap, I have never hoped that someone gets the shaft. So, I do not need to look in the mirror.

So now you don't want DOH or Relative, you might as well stop talking because it's obvious you are not going to be happy regardless of what happens. There's not much options left for this SLI.
 
The 191 million came off the collective pilot group's back, the Pinnacle pilots, not me alone. And YES, our future at Pinnacle, as a standalone carrier, was great all the way until 2017. That's when the first contract is due up for the CRJ-200s with Delta. The CRJ-900 contracts weren't due up until later. Up until the Delta merger, we did have NWA and DAL as partners. But our regional contracts are one of the longest in duration, and we are on of only a few carriers who haven't had any airplanes parked. So YES, my future was far more secure than a Mesaba future of parking several dozen fleets. Even if we didn't purchase Mesaba, we'd still be fine. Keep in mind, with the purchase of Mesaba, our Delta relationship only extended the contract duration for the CRJ-900s. The CRJ-200s are and still were guaranteed under contract through 2017, with or without the Mesaba purchase. There was no net change there. As for us hiring, look at kellwolf's post above. The short answer is, YES, we would be hiring. Attrition, people getting hired elsewhere, some getting fed up, etc.


See above paragraph. Pinnacle Airlines had its RJ contracts with Delta for long duration, longer than any other regional today. The Mesaba purchase did not extend the duration of our CRJ-200s, only extended the duration of the contracts for the CRJ-900s. The 200s are still due up in 2017. The 900s go through 2023 (I believe). But if we didn't purchase Mesaba, our long term contracts were still in effect and unharmed. So no, we as Pinnacle were not "worse off" before. IMO, we are worse off acquiring a guaranteed shrinking carrier. How can anyone with a straight face say that acquiring an airline that is parking over 3 dozen airplanes is a "good" idea. With the Saabs gone, the pilots and FAs will be furloughed. As a standalone carrier, Mesaba would take the burden alone by itself. But with this SLI, this furlough burden will also fall on the shoulders of Pinnacle and Colgan pilots, depending on where they fall on the list.


It was technically two carriers, NWA and DAL, that merged in one. Even with one carrier, our RJ contracts were (and still are) long term, one of the longest in the industry. Nothing wrong with feeding one carrier. In fact, one of the most stable regionals today, Eagle, has served one carrier only. And they have done it for decades without trouble. Now when their RJ contracts are up, then it may be a different story, but they have gone strong. Pinnacle is no different.

Your "contract" honestly, isn't worth anything.

When/if amr sells eagle then what?

Are you loo king at this with such short term vision that you don't care what happens in 5/6 years? What if you fail a training event eg upgrade, and get stuck at 9e for a few years?

Why are you so worried about colgan guys? Almost all of our 2007 hires are captains already, and despite what you may think, they (most) don't see a crj 200 as a step forward.

If you are so worried about upgrade, why don't you bid over to the q where you can already hold a captain spot?

I hope you do see that colgan is running like 14 upgrades a month right now, and will continue to for a while.

I've heard strong rumors that another 15 q's are coming late '11, or early '12. While you are fussing about a colgan guy taking your spot, your missing that 9l has rights to one of the hottest planes in the regional game right now. This thing makes money, and doesn't burn much gas. Its funny that you are worried that the pilots from the only growing operation are gonna come steal your crj spot, when we don't even have enough to run our own place.

Seriously, relax, in tge end it wil all work out.
 
Absolutely not, kellwolf! When did I ever say I want someone to get the shaft? All I've said, over and over again, is I don't want a JUNIOR pilot to go above a more senior Pinnacle pilot, say hired in 2007, for an upgrade on a CRJ at Pinnacle. That is not wishing shafting for someone. If anything, it is not wanting to get shafted as a Pinnacle FO.

As for DOH, I used to think it would be fair. DOH simply credits you for time that you've spent at your airline. Period. So how would that be unfair? Now, I'm starting to not want DOH, not because of Colgan, but because of Mesaba. They bring a pretty senior group into our mix, and DOH would make them out like bandits, with the resulting layoffs from the 3-dozen plus Saabs being burdened onto the Pinnacle/Colgan pilots. In fact, if it was DOH all the way, most of Colgan guys would get the shaft for the impending furlough as a result of all the Saab parkings.

To recap, I have never hoped that someone gets the shaft. So, I do not need to look in the mirror.

But in a non-DOH merger....uh, wouldn't the senior XJ guys be getting the shaft? Basically, you just don't want to get the shaft. Anyone else, as long as it doesn't interfere in your upgrade, is fair game. Fact is, SOMEONE is going to get the shaft in this merger. As long as it's not you, you really don't care, despite your rhetoric on this board. Your actions and statements reveal that. How many times have you said the phrase "as long as it doesn't interefere with Pinnacle FOs, especially 2007 hires" or something similar? It's a loaded statement that speaks VOLUMES about your true feelings. Keep talking all you want about how you don't want someone to get the shaft, your other statements clearly show you don't care as long as you don't get jumped in seniority by anyone. Maybe the Colgan guys could just drop down a few grand to take a shortcut, too. Would that suddenly make it okay?
 
Absolutely not, kellwolf! When did I ever say I want someone to get the shaft? All I've said, over and over again, is I don't want a JUNIOR pilot to go above a more senior Pinnacle pilot, say hired in 2007, for an upgrade on a CRJ at Pinnacle. That is not wishing shafting for someone. If anything, it is not wanting to get shafted as a Pinnacle FO.

As for DOH, I used to think it would be fair. DOH simply credits you for time that you've spent at your airline. Period. So how would that be unfair? Now, I'm starting to not want DOH, not because of Colgan, but because of Mesaba. They bring a pretty senior group into our mix, and DOH would make them out like bandits, with the resulting layoffs from the 3-dozen plus Saabs being burdened onto the Pinnacle/Colgan pilots. In fact, if it was DOH all the way, most of Colgan guys would get the shaft for the impending furlough as a result of all the Saab parkings.

To recap, I have never hoped that someone gets the shaft. So, I do not need to look in the mirror.

Do you realize that late 2008 hires at Colgan already upgraded? You need to look somewhere else for your problems, man, blame them on some other underserving pilot group. This is why I hate these SLI threads, get over it man, just get over it. With all the options that Colgan has on Q's, it's a net growth especially with how many of the people at Colgan that are Junior to you using DOH, since that's what you loved so dearly at one point in time. You know what? The Colgan's bought a plumbing company with the hard earned money off of us Colgan pilots. I demand to be senior to all the plumbers and want some of their pipes (hahaha) ! This is life man......, and it's working out for the positive in your case.
 
Hey Cherokee_Cruiser:

Your a 250 HR wonder right? No offense but its true right?

I got lucky by getting hired at Colgan in 08' and I was fortunate to upgrade a few months ago. It was pure luck and being in the right place at the right time. You need to realize that you also got a lucky break and got hired with a ridiculous amount of flight time. Back 10-15 years ago you'd still be instructing and trying to get a job flying a Navajo with cancelled checks in the middle of the night. Instead your pushing buttons and slinging gear in a big pretty RJ and you have a much better story to sell to chicks in bars.

Don't be angry if a "junior FO", as you call him, upgrades before you. Most of the "junior FOs" at Colgan got hired affter the 250hr wave and had a buttload more time than you, and the ink actually dried on their commercial ticket. If they chose to buy their jobs their DOH would probably be senior to yours anyhow.

I would rather have ANY COLGAN pilot act as PIC on an aircraft carrying my entire family rather than some clown that got hired into a jet with 250hrs that would probably cry to mommy the first time the autopilot didn't work.

Do you even have enough PIC time to upgrade?

I have the utmost respect for just about every Pinnacle and Mesaba pilot. I really hope this thing works out and the Pinnacle and Mesaba guys that really paid their dues get to upgrade. Personally I don't deserve to be an RJ CA yet and neither do you CC. Don't worry about me taking any RJ openings anytime soon.

So far CC you made it up to the number two position on my 9E/XJ Dbag list. There's only two on the list so you should be honored, it's and elite group :)
This is completely irrelevant. One always needs to meet the upgrade time requirements at their airline, regardless of when they started. For Pinnacle, it's 2,500TT if you already have 1,000TT at the company. I hit that mark in 2009. But there was no hiring, no movement at Pinnacle. Pinnacle management was too busy buying Q400s for Colgan and trying to pay off a loan debt to think about hiring and upgrading, even when people were still trickling away (attrition).


So now you don't want DOH or Relative, you might as well stop talking because it's obvious you are not going to be happy regardless of what happens. There's not much options left for this SLI.
There is an option. Do what arbitrator Dana Eischen (sp) did for the Republic/Frontier/MidEx/Lynx SLI......

Your "contract" honestly, isn't worth anything.

When/if amr sells eagle then what?
The contract is worth enough that we haven't parked any airplanes. Unlike Comair, Mesaba.......
And Eagle could be sold, but we'll have to see. They are on the expensive side, and no one wants to buy a large regional these days.
 
But in a non-DOH merger....uh, wouldn't the senior XJ guys be getting the shaft? Basically, you just don't want to get the shaft. Anyone else, as long as it doesn't interfere in your upgrade, is fair game. Fact is, SOMEONE is going to get the shaft in this merger. As long as it's not you, you really don't care, despite your rhetoric on this board. Your actions and statements reveal that. How many times have you said the phrase "as long as it doesn't interefere with Pinnacle FOs, especially 2007 hires" or something similar? It's a loaded statement that speaks VOLUMES about your true feelings. Keep talking all you want about how you don't want someone to get the shaft, your other statements clearly show you don't care as long as you don't get jumped in seniority by anyone. Maybe the Colgan guys could just drop down a few grand to take a shortcut, too. Would that suddenly make it okay?

Don't you worry about senior Mesaba guys. The 300 or so guys that are there, hired prior to 2000. More than 1/3 of them have guaranteed spots at Delta once Delta starts hiring again. They will bail. And keep in mind, the senior Mesaba guys were gonna get shafted once the Saabs were gone, by losing their QOL with a decreasing/shrinking pilot group from resulting furloughs. In fact, one can argue that the SLI is a savior to the senior Mesaba guys, whether its DOH or relative. And yeah, I don't want anyone junior to jump over a senior pilot when it comes to us, Pinnacle, the buying airline for one airline that was shrinking with Saabs parking, and another that is expanding tremendously due to Pinnacle buyout and financial lending for Qs. And what's the "drop a few grand for a shortcut" comment? Plenty of Colgan pilots came out of Gulfstream, Jet U, ALLATPs, and the likes, with 250-500 hrs. No different than Pinnacle.
 
Back
Top