Pinnacle Mesaba Colgan Transition and merger

Nope, I don't think SLI can be a deal breaker, unless you wanna go all Airways on us. The deal is done, just wanting to see the "90 day terms" ;)

Well jynxjoe, and I mean this with all due respect, your career expectation at Mesaba without the Pinnacle purchase would have been furlough once all the Saabs had hit the desert. With down to 41 CRJ9s and 19 CRJ2s, Mesaba as a 60-airplane carrier would not be able to save the furloughs of many pilots and FAs (on the order of hundreds). Therefore, this career expectation should be handled 'properly' by the arbitrator. So, my hope is there will be no need for us to go all Airways on you. The arbitrator will hopefully be smart enough to include this career expectation in his SLI award.......
 
Well jynxjoe, and I mean this with all due respect, your career expectation at Mesaba without the Pinnacle purchase would have been furlough once all the Saabs had hit the desert. With down to 41 CRJ9s and 19 CRJ2s, Mesaba as a 60-airplane carrier would not be able to save the furloughs of many pilots and FAs (on the order of hundreds). Therefore, this career expectation should be handled 'properly' by the arbitrator. So, my hope is there will be no need for us to go all Airways on you. The arbitrator will hopefully be smart enough to include this career expectation in his SLI award.......

Nothing personal here, but when it comes to SLI, you are looking at SLI from just your own personal situation ( I recognize the fact that this is human nature and I have also looked at it that way to some extent like everyone else ). My point is this, you made mention of being a little more than displeased if a Colgan pilot were to come across certificates and be senior and upgrade ahead of you. You must realize what a relative seniority integration works, right? It is all about maintaining your QOL, schedule, seat, bid, etc...whatever is the most important to you with respect to seniority. After the SLI if they were to go with the relative seniority model, what do you really lose if you remain let's say for the sake of argument 5-10% of where you are on the current list? Your bid position at worst given the current state of the company and growth would likely result in your upgrade within the time-frame that you envision. It is really irrelevant if your "number" goes from 1500-2000 in a joint list as long as you are within a fair percentage of your originally bidding position prior to SLI.
Ultimately, in my opinion the SLI has to recognize the fact that each pilot group brings certain elements to the table, however, we might disagree on the merits of those elements. A straight down the rack DOH integration will be a miserable failure and anyone that has a lick of sense would see that. Do you really want to to work within a structure that totally failed to respect what everyone brought to the table? It is a recipe for terrible labor relations and will put another thorn in the side of ALPA. We really, really don't want a US/AW deadlock here and I don't think that is what the arbitrator is going to do, but no one can be certain till it is a done deal.
Cruiser, I think you will likely find yourself in the left-seat sooner than later and hopefully just slightly pissed off vs. feeling like you hit the lottery with a despondent 9L F/O sitting next to you that is regretting the moment he voted "YES".
 
This thread WAS going so well... Now we are back to speculation and self rationalization.... That goes for all 3 groups by all 3. I simply trust my guys and hope for the best. None of our personal or professional "opinions" can help the situation- apparently they CAN and WILL destroy any morale and unity that could possibly exist. We are ALL going to feel shafted (regardless of where you are), so accept that and look at the bright side of continued movement through the list due to attrition that is starting to happen. If we start the "who won" and "who lost" game before the game even begins how will that translate with mixed crews down the line?
 
And there ya have it, folks. He doesn't care what happens as long as he gets his. Dolla, dolla bill ya'll. Gottsa to get my money. Etc, etc. Who cares what's fair as long as CC gets to upgrade.

No, I said I wouldn't care who jumps where after upgrade. What my problem is if any junior guys go above me in a relative integration, and then upgrade into a left seat at Pinnacle.

A straight down the rack DOH integration will be a miserable failure and anyone that has a lick of sense would see that.
LOL! Why? Crediting a pilot for time spent at his individual airline is a "miserable failure"????? Only a Colgan pilot could say that with a straight face..........

As far as I'm concerned, Colgan deserves a DOH merger. Your growth came at Pinnacle's expense. It's about time to give back to the entire group.
 
Your not the first person to get screwed in a merger and yes the purchasing airline sometimes does have its original pilots get screwed look at DAl/NWA and DAL FOs losing a couple years to NWA FOs, and DAL pilots getting displaced out of their long time bases (could be wrong info being that it came from my father but we have talked about the merger many times since it happened and how it affected both pilot groups) So it may take you a little longer to upgrade, life goes on. Jist try to be happy to that you had a job the past few years when others did not. Your a part of a pilot group that needs everyone to help, you need to think what is best for everyone not just yourself ( of course easier said than done)



No, I said I wouldn't care who jumps where after upgrade. What my problem is if any junior guys go above me in a relative integration, and then upgrade into a left seat at Pinnacle.


LOL! Why? Crediting a pilot for time spent at his individual airline is a "miserable failure"????? Only a Colgan pilot could say that with a straight face..........

As far as I'm concerned, Colgan deserves a DOH merger. Your growth came at Pinnacle's expense. It's about time to give back to the entire group.
 
LOL! Why? Crediting a pilot for time spent at his individual airline is a "miserable failure"????? Only a Colgan pilot could say that with a straight face..........

As far as I'm concerned, Colgan deserves a DOH merger. Your growth came at Pinnacle's expense. It's about time to give back to the entire group.[/QUOTE]


You have a very selective memory, I can remember growth and upgrades long before PNCL showed up. I'm not sure what your intentions are, but the only thing you are acheiving in this thread is "stirring the pot." They're are plenty of upgrades at 9L, I am pretty sure no one wants YOUR upgrade in DTW. Now, as far as your comment of giving back to the entire group...

...must be one of the silliest comments I have seen on this board. :dunno:

Every group brought something to the table. (period)
 
No, I said I wouldn't care who jumps where after upgrade. What my problem is if any junior guys go above me in a relative integration, and then upgrade into a left seat at Pinnacle.

How is that different? You don't mind the 2008 FO at Colgan jumping you in seniority as long as it's AFTER you upgrade? You can't say both statements and mean both of them. Go back and re-read your statement. If you think it doesn't sound self-centered and "me first," I'm really glad I won't have to fly with you as an FO....
 
You have a very selective memory, I can remember growth and upgrades long before PNCL showed up. I'm not sure what your intentions are, but the only thing you are acheiving in this thread is "stirring the pot." They're are plenty of upgrades at 9L, I am pretty sure no one wants YOUR upgrade in DTW. Now, as far as your comment of giving back to the entire group...

...must be one of the silliest comments I have seen on this board. :dunno:

There hasn't been any growth at Pinnacle Inc in a few years, almost 4 years since the 16 900s were selected for Delta flying. The $191 million convertible note from the NWA bankruptcy was used to buy Colgan with 20 million, and the remaining money to buy Colgan Q400s. All the while, Pinnacle told our ALPA that our ALPA contract proposal would bankrupt the company. That money could have been used to get us a new contract, grow us more, and get us Q400s.

Every group brought something to the table. (period)
What? Mesaba is a guaranteed shrinking carrier, losing all their Saab flying with Delta. They were lucky to use connections with Pinnacle Holdings to get 7 Saabs flying out of LGA for US Airways Express. The other 3 dozen plus Saabs are all heading to the desert. Not much to offer, considering that if Mesaba was standalone carrier, they would be furloughing hundreds of pilots and FAs as a result of Saabs being parked. As for Colgan, what have they bought to the table? Everyone knows that Colgan is a tarnished name, an embarassment since Flight 3407. There's a reason Pinnacle wants the Colgan name disappeared altogether.


Well, cheers. No amounts of beotching on this forum will change anything. It's Bloch's final decision. But I'm hardly alone when I say this: hopefully the pitchforks won't have to come out.
 
How is that different? You don't mind the 2008 FO at Colgan jumping you in seniority as long as it's AFTER you upgrade? You can't say both statements and mean both of them. Go back and re-read your statement. If you think it doesn't sound self-centered and "me first," I'm really glad I won't have to fly with you as an FO....
Oh, no, no, I would mind still. If junior FOs take upgrades over other Pinnacle pilots, due to a relative crap, then I sympathize with them too. I would be ticked at that. And of course, it would affect me too, because they would push me more down the list by upgrading senior above me. So in the end, it's all inter-twined.
 
Oh, no, no, I would mind still. If junior FOs take upgrades over other Pinnacle pilots, due to a relative crap, then I sympathize with them too. I would be ticked at that. And of course, it would affect me too, because they would push me more down the list by upgrading senior above me. So in the end, it's all inter-twined.

OK. So I've read through your last several posts in this thread. Ya know, I'm all for playing nice but obviously all you really care about is you. Way to make friends with your now brothers and sisters in arms. So that being said, rather than being sympathetic, I hope you specifically get the shaft. I can be an ass too, and I guarantee you I'm damn good at it. Have a great night. :)
 
Easy there everyone...

Is it time for people to step back from the keyboard?

This is the Airline Pilot forum section. Standard ops for here. :D

If we start the "who won" and "who lost" game before the game even begins how will that translate with mixed crews down the line?

About as good as it did for Northwest. Ever JS on one of their planes with a mixed crew, and you'll know what I mean. Most uncomfortable 727 JS I ever did......
 
This is the Airline Pilot forum section. Standard ops for here. :D



About as good as it did for Northwest. Ever JS on one of their planes with a mixed crew, and you'll know what I mean. Most uncomfortable 727 JS I ever did......

Very true have heard first hand of guys holding a grudge and literally say you can do everything on your own, in some hard imc with a pretty complicated approach procedure. I really hope this all does not come to this. Not professional or safe.
 
There hasn't been any growth at Pinnacle Inc in a few years, almost 4 years since the 16 900s were selected for Delta flying. The $191 million convertible note from the NWA bankruptcy was used to buy Colgan with 20 million, and the remaining money to buy Colgan Q400s. All the while, Pinnacle told our ALPA that our ALPA contract proposal would bankrupt the company. That money could have been used to get us a new contract, grow us more, and get us Q400s.


What? Mesaba is a guaranteed shrinking carrier, losing all their Saab flying with Delta. They were lucky to use connections with Pinnacle Holdings to get 7 Saabs flying out of LGA for US Airways Express. The other 3 dozen plus Saabs are all heading to the desert. Not much to offer, considering that if Mesaba was standalone carrier, they would be furloughing hundreds of pilots and FAs as a result of Saabs being parked. As for Colgan, what have they bought to the table? Everyone knows that Colgan is a tarnished name, an embarassment since Flight 3407. There's a reason Pinnacle wants the Colgan name disappeared altogether.


Well, cheers. No amounts of beotching on this forum will change anything. It's Bloch's final decision. But I'm hardly alone when I say this: hopefully the pitchforks won't have to come out.

lol.. umm... how much of that 191 million note came off your back? Your ranting about money the company made before you had any considerable time in. I have to ask, with Delta pawning off the regionals, cutting flying, shifting planes around left and right, how "stable" do you think your job was? Can you say with 100% faith that Pinnacle would be hiring right now? As far as I can tell, there really hasn't been any "growth" on those crj-200's. By purchasing Messaba, PNCL has taken a step to make sure that they keep the flying they have. Colgan has been growing pretty steadily, before and after PNCL. Total growth post 2007 is only like 250-300 pilots.

Without all 3 pilots groups, each company likely would have been much worse for the wear. Grow up, and stop yelling me me me, it gets old, and I'm pretty sure the only people that are saying the same things as you, are similar, junior FO's.

Your bring up the LGA usairways flying... just curious, but, what is the 9e relationship with airways? What is the 9e relationship with CAL? or UAL for that matter? You were flying code share for 1 carrier, with all your eggs in 1 basket.

From my time at colgan, my advise it Relax dude... it hurts a lot more when you're all tight and puckered up... no matter how much lube you use.
 
C'mon guys. We're a community here, right? So some people are upset at the way things are. Things happen, and we may not be in the best position or where we may want to be. Lets agree to disagree.
Not trying to be a mediator here, just don't wana see us fight or be against each other.
 
Everyone knows that Colgan is a tarnished name, an embarassment since Flight 3407. There's a reason Pinnacle wants the Colgan name disappeared altogether.

This is the kind of asinine and obnoxious attitude that one has to expect from someone that is obviously very ignorant of their own airline's own dubious operational and safety record. I really don't intend to insult or group together any other 9E pilots with the idiot that made this statement and after awhile anyone with even a large amount of patience and tolerance will have heard enough. Was 3407 a heinous accident? Absolutely..
Has it had a major effect on the people here at Colgan in the aftermath? Very much so...Have we taken measures to prevent it from happening again? An emphatict yes! Please try and stay on point if you can with your whining and carrying on about how the pilots of Colgan Air are going to interupt your precious upgrade into that underpowered POS you are so desperate to get into the left-seat of then wax poetic about what a great supporter you are of your fellow pilots...
 
Well jynxjoe, and I mean this with all due respect, your career expectation at Mesaba without the Pinnacle purchase would have been furlough once all the Saabs had hit the desert. With down to 41 CRJ9s and 19 CRJ2s, Mesaba as a 60-airplane carrier would not be able to save the furloughs of many pilots and FAs (on the order of hundreds). Therefore, this career expectation should be handled 'properly' by the arbitrator. So, my hope is there will be no need for us to go all Airways on you. The arbitrator will hopefully be smart enough to include this career expectation in his SLI award.......

Try not to have a stroke.

You are doing great by the way, please continue.
 
Very true have heard first hand of guys holding a grudge and literally say you can do everything on your own, in some hard imc with a pretty complicated approach procedure. I really hope this all does not come to this. Not professional or safe.

When I was jumpseating on the NWA 727........1996 it was.......all three crew were from different tribes, if you will. We're up at cruise, and the FE makes a little smalltalk to me; weird since we'd been sterile cockpit all the way up to cruise and still were so. So during the course of the smalltalk, the usual stuff about background etc, I ask the FE about where the Capt and FO are from background-wise (civil, military, etc). He answers "Don't know. Don't care. You'll have to ask them." And both the Capt and FO aren't doing any talking to each other either except for all business.

Un-comfortable! :)
 
Back
Top