Logging second in command count as Total?

Not necessarily. There's been no formal interpretation on this but clouds are rarely solid forever and see-and-avoid responsibility remains with the pilot. So if the flying pilot wants to wear the hood, there's nothing in the regs that removes the requirement for a safety pilot. The only qualm I have is whether the first time the issue is presented to the FAA, it's in the context (intentionally or not) of two pilots with no good reason for the flying pilot to wear the hood in the clouds - except the non-flying pilot's desire to build time. Abuse of legitimate activities can unfortunately lead to bad legal decisions that affect everyone else.

btw, one more twist on the SIC issue: if the flight is under IFR, the safety pilot must be instrument rated. It's in 61.55 and it was sort of snuck in by the FAA without fanfare.

I did mention the IFR part! I agree that it should be okay for the safety pilot to log time when the PF is under the hood, in the clouds. But I have seen nothing in writing from the FAA to back up my opinion.

Since I can make a counter example: Pilot A files an IFR flight plan, for a flight in IMC, and is current in category/class/ratings for the flight. Pilot B is the sole manipulator who is also current in category/class/ratings. Pilot B obviously logs PIC. But clearly from FAR 1.1, Pilot A was acting PIC. What can Pilot A log? Nothing.

I would write to the FAA for an opinion on the scenario you propose, but I'm afraid of what the answer would be.
 
I did mention the IFR part! I agree that it should be okay for the safety pilot to log time when the PF is under the hood, in the clouds. But I have seen nothing in writing from the FAA to back up my opinion.

Since I can make a counter example: Pilot A files an IFR flight plan, for a flight in IMC, and is current in category/class/ratings for the flight. Pilot B is the sole manipulator who is also current in category/class/ratings. Pilot B obviously logs PIC. But clearly from FAR 1.1, Pilot A was acting PIC. What can Pilot A log? Nothing.

I would write to the FAA for an opinion on the scenario you propose, but I'm afraid of what the answer would be.

Pilot A can log PIC anytime pilot B is under the hood. If no hood, no logging. Thats why its a loophole, it doesnt work in all situations, as in your above example.
 
I would write to the FAA for an opinion on the scenario you propose, but I'm afraid of what the answer would be.
That's sometimes the problem with asking. Questions are sometimes asked in areas that are a bit gray and are looking for clear black lines. A clear black line asnwer is often going to be based on the worst version of the hypothetical you present. Unfortunate but understandable.
 
But don't most planes that need type ratings have an endorsement as well for SIC? What happens to the complex/hp/tw flyers? Is there anything for SIC or can I jump up and SIC a tw without an endorsement?
I'm not sure if you got an answer to this question. Take a look at 61.31 (requirements for acting as PIC) and 61.55 (requirements for acting as SIC),

See anything about endorsements in 61.31? See anything about them in 61.55?
 
Back
Top