Logging second in command count as Total?

SIC can only be logged in aircraft that require a SIC by the type certificate or by a company's FAA approved OPS spec. You could log it as PIC and total if you wanted to act as a safety pilot.
I had a huge argument with a fellow pilot about this. He insisted that a safety pilot is SIC and I actually had to go home, find the specific FAR by number and send him an email.

He's been happy about the PIC hours he's been getting with me now.
 
You could log it as PIC and total if you wanted to act as a safety pilot.

Or you could log it as SIC if the other pilot was acting PIC.

As for the view-limiting device, I don't know of of any regulations prescribing the requirements, other than you not be able to see outside. I lower the seat and keep my head down ;)
 
Or you could log it as SIC if the other pilot was acting PIC.

As for the view-limiting device, I don't know of of any regulations prescribing the requirements, other than you not be able to see outside. I lower the seat and keep my head down ;)
you can't log SIC in a single pilot plane like say a 172. You know that! I think you're trolling...
 
On this topic I always like to quote Mark's website FAQ:

May a Safety Pilot Log PIC Time?


It depends. If the safety pilot is also acting as PIC (in charge of the flight), then the safety pilot may log PIC time while the flying pilot is under the hood. If not, the safety pilot is permitted to log second-in-command time. To understand the answer, make sure that you first understand the "golden key" to logging mentioned in the general logging PIC FAQ - the FAA treats "acting as pilot in command" and "logging pilot in command time" under FAR 61.51 as completely different concepts. Unless 61.51 specifically directs you to it, answering a logging question by including the word "acting" or pointing to any other FAR is always a mistake.

Logging PIC time as a safety pilot is one of those times that 61.51 tells you to look somewhere else. As usual, let's start with 61.51. 61.51(e)(1)(iii) tells us that if you are a private or commercial pilot, you may log as PIC any time you are acting as PIC (in charge) of a flight on which more than one pilot is required by the regulations. More than one pilot may be required because the aircraft is not certified for single-pilot operations. But there are other situations as well. One is set up for us by 91.109(b):
No person may operate a civil aircraft in simulated instrument flight unless - (1) The other control seat is occupied by a safety pilot who possesses at least a private pilot certificate with category and class ratings appropriate to the aircraft being flown.
So, a second "safety pilot" is required by the regulations while the "manipulator" is under the hood. If the two pilots agree that the safety pilot is acting as PIC, the safety pilot can log the time as PIC.


An important, but often misunderstood part of this rule is that in order to act as PIC in this context, the pilot must be qualified to do so. That means being current and having the appropriate endorsements in addition to ratings. Think it's a little sneaky? Trying to get around the rules by looking for technicalities? Here's what the FAA Chief Legal Counsel said about it more than 10 years ago in 1992:
In your second question you ask "how shall two Private Pilots log their flight time when one pilot is under the hood for simulated instrument time and the other pilot acts as safety pilot?" The answer is the pilot who is under the hood may log PIC time for that flight time in which he is the sole manipulator of the controls of the aircraft, provided he is rated for that aircraft. The appropriately rated safety pilot may concurrently log as second in command (SIC) that time during which he is acting as safety pilot.

The two pilots may, however, agree prior to initiating the flight that the safety pilot will be the PIC responsible for the operation and safety of the aircraft during the flight. If this is done, then the safety pilot may log all the flight time as PIC time in accordance with FAR 1.1 and the pilot under the hood may log, concurrently, all of the flight time during which he is the sole manipulator of the controls as PIC time in accordance with FAR 61.51(c)(2)(i). Enclosed please find a prior FAA interpretation concerning the logging of flight time under simulated instrument flight conditions. We hope that this interpretation will be of further assistance to you.
 
Safety pilot, where the safety pilot is not the ACTING pilot in command.
the safety pilot is a PIC in that case. the safety pilot is solely responsible for the where the plane goes and how the plane stays in VMC since they are (hopefully if you're doing it right) in VMC.

I see it as a loophole because as you say the safety pilot should be SIC, but I also think Walmart not paying taxes in florida is travesty.
 
the safety pilot is a PIC in that case. the safety pilot is solely responsible for the where the plane goes and how the plane stays in VMC since they are (hopefully if you're doing it right) in VMC.

I see it as a loophole because as you say the safety pilot should be SIC, but I also think Walmart not paying taxes in florida is travesty.
I think you need to read some of the FAA Chief Counsel interpretations on the subject. Including this one from 1993:
http://www.faa.gov/about/office_org...0/interpretations/data/interps/1993/Hicks.rtf

If you want something more current, you can try this one from 2009:
http://www.faa.gov/about/office_org...rpretations/data/interps/2009/Louis Glenn.pdf

Pretty consistent for a "loophole" huh?

Bottom line: A safety pilot is a required crewmember under 91.109. The FAA has interpreted that to mean that safety pilot ops are 2-pilot required ops. A safety pilot who is acting as PIC may log PIC under 61.51(e)(1)(iii). A safety pilot who is not acting as PIC may log SIC under 61.51(f)(2).
 
I think you need to read some of the FAA Chief Counsel interpretations on the subject. Including this one from 1993:
http://www.faa.gov/about/office_org...0/interpretations/data/interps/1993/Hicks.rtf

If you want something more current, you can try this one from 2009:
http://www.faa.gov/about/office_org...rpretations/data/interps/2009/Louis Glenn.pdf

Pretty consistent for a "loophole" huh?

Bottom line: A safety pilot is a required crewmember under 91.109. The FAA has interpreted that to mean that safety pilot ops are 2-pilot required ops. A safety pilot who is acting as PIC may log PIC under 61.51(e)(1)(iii). A safety pilot who is not acting as PIC may log SIC under 61.51(f)(2).
[FONT=&quot]The appropriately rated safety pilot may concurrently log as second-in-command (SIC) that time during which he or she is acting as safety pilot.[/FONT]

[FONT=&quot][/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]Ok you're right in this case. But wait:[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]
[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]However, the two pilots may, prior to initiating the flight, agree that the safety pilot will be the PIC responsible for the operation and safety of the aircraft during the flight. If this is done, then the safety pilot may log all the flight time as PIC time in accordance with FAR 1.1 and the pilot under the hood may log, concurrently, all of the flight time during which he is the sole manipulator of the controls as PIC time in accordance with FAR 61.51(c)(2)(i). [/FONT]

Why would you, as a safety pilot, NOT want to log PIC? Do you just not want the responsibility of the flight?
 
the safety pilot is a PIC in that case. the safety pilot is solely responsible for the where the plane goes and how the plane stays in VMC since they are (hopefully if you're doing it right) in VMC.

Nothing says the flight can't be under IFR, or in weather less than VMC.

The need to keep a visual lookout for traffic does not go away just because visibility goes below 3 miles - there may well be other legal VFR traffic to look out for.

Definitely not trolling, thanks for the references, Midlife!

Here's another one. If you are flying in IMC, can you log actual instrument time? Answer: Maybe. The definitions of IMC and instrument time have nothing to do with each other.
 
The safety pilot may want to log PIC, but he may lack the necessary endorsements.
ah! That's something I've run into (the hypothetical situation in my mind) and I've asked people this:

If a plane needs a type rating or an endorsement to act PIC (like a Lear, or a Complex, HP, TW, etc), you obviously can't log PIC if you are not even the one controlling the aircraft.

But don't most planes that need type ratings have an endorsement as well for SIC? What happens to the complex/hp/tw flyers? Is there anything for SIC or can I jump up and SIC a tw without an endorsement?

but anyway: Drunkenbeagle: I completely understand what you are saying about vis but if you are in the clouds, you can't really look for traffic, so the other guy is no longer a required crewmember. How can he be?
 
but anyway: Drunkenbeagle: I completely understand what you are saying about vis but if you are in the clouds, you can't really look for traffic, so the other guy is no longer a required crewmember. How can he be?

IMC does not mean in the clouds.

INSTRUMENT METEOROLOGICAL CONDITIONS- Meteorological conditions expressed in terms of visibility, distance from cloud, and ceiling less than the minima specified for visual meteorological conditions. [Pilot Controller Glossary]
61.51(g) Logging instrument flight time. (1) A person may log instrument time only for that flight time when the person operates the aircraft solely by reference to instruments under actual or simulated instrument flight conditions.

If you are in Echo Airspace 100' below a cloud, are you in IMC? Yes. May you log instrument time? No.
 
ah! That's something I've run into (the hypothetical situation in my mind) and I've asked people this:

If a plane needs a type rating or an endorsement to act PIC (like a Lear, or a Complex, HP, TW, etc), you obviously can't log PIC if you are not even the one controlling the aircraft.

But don't most planes that need type ratings have an endorsement as well for SIC? What happens to the complex/hp/tw flyers? Is there anything for SIC or can I jump up and SIC a tw without an endorsement?

61.55 (wow, only had to turn one page!)
Sec. 61.55 — Second-in-command qualifications.

(a) A person may serve as a second-in-command of an aircraft type certificated for more than one required pilot flight crewmember or in operations requiring a second-in-command pilot flight crewmember only if that person holds:
(1) At least a private pilot certificate with the appropriate category and class rating; and

(2) An instrument rating or privilege that applies to the aircraft being flown if the flight is under IFR; and

(3) The appropriate pilot type rating for the aircraft unless the flight will be conducted as domestic flight operations within United States airspace.

(b) Except as provided in paragraph (e) of this section, no person may serve as a second-in-command of an aircraft type certificated for more than one required pilot flight crewmember or in operations requiring a second-in-command unless that person has within the previous 12 calendar months:

(1) Become familiar with the following information for the specific type aircraft for which second-in-command privileges are requested—

Basically, to act as SIC, you need at least a PPL certificate in category and class. You do not need a type rating in the US (though you do need the training from 61.55(b)). You do not need any ratings or endorsements, other than an IR for IFR flight.
 
IMC does not mean in the clouds.

INSTRUMENT METEOROLOGICAL CONDITIONS- Meteorological conditions expressed in terms of visibility, distance from cloud, and ceiling less than the minima specified for visual meteorological conditions. [Pilot Controller Glossary]
61.51(g) Logging instrument flight time. (1) A person may log instrument time only for that flight time when the person operates the aircraft solely by reference to instruments under actual or simulated instrument flight conditions.

If you are in Echo Airspace 100' below a cloud, are you in IMC? Yes. May you log instrument time? No.

I know the difference between IMC and VMC. That's why I specifically said in the clouds
 
Correct, for the portion of the flight that it is not possible to look for traffic, in theory the safety pilot should log nothing.
ok, I wasn't 100% sure if that was the correct way to do it or not.

How's the bay area today? Yall been getting a lot of marginal weather I've been looking at... Last weekend sucked there...
 
Correct, for the portion of the flight that it is not possible to look for traffic, in theory the safety pilot should log nothing.

Not necessarily. There's been no formal interpretation on this but clouds are rarely solid forever and see-and-avoid responsibility remains with the pilot. So if the flying pilot wants to wear the hood, there's nothing in the regs that removes the requirement for a safety pilot. The only qualm I have is whether the first time the issue is presented to the FAA, it's in the context (intentionally or not) of two pilots with no good reason for the flying pilot to wear the hood in the clouds - except the non-flying pilot's desire to build time. Abuse of legitimate activities can unfortunately lead to bad legal decisions that affect everyone else.

btw, one more twist on the SIC issue: if the flight is under IFR, the safety pilot must be instrument rated. It's in 61.55 and it was sort of snuck in by the FAA without fanfare.
 
Back
Top