Flying the Nylon Wing

BravoHotel

Well-Known Member
Okay. I have a point to ponder. In my roughly 400 hours of flying skydivers, 750 ish tt, I have about 1400 landings...As a skydiver I have close to 300 jumps I recently downsized from a 9 cell semi elliptical 170 Sq Ft Hornet to a 150 Sq ft 7 cell Spectre and my landings have been crap ever since...You would think I would understand why, but I don't.

I know the planform is different, the 7 cell parachute has a steeper approach angle then the 9 cell, the 7 cell doesn't seem to plane out, or go into ground effect like the 9 cell does. So landing an airplane, and a 9 cell seems to have some similarities. The yoke and the control toggles are you control input to the wing, but, it feels about the same, a two stage approach the round out, bleed off the airspeed bleeds and you finish the landing with either pulling down the toggles or pulling back the yoke, I get nice greaser and tip toe landings.

But with the 7 cell, its hit or miss, it is either beautiful or ass over tea kettle landing. I haven't hurt my self yet, only a couple of grass stains on my jump suit, but it is embarrassing, any constructive opinions out there would be appreciated!!!
 
Nah, dropzone.com doesn't know jack when it comes to "pilot speak" for these situations ;)

I have much more limited experience in the skydiving world (made jump #64 last Friday!), but I'm trying to learn everything I can about canopy flight...

The thing I've seen is that even though a canopy is a wing, it's hard to draw direct comparisons to the wings we're used to operating in aircraft. They're so different in both rigidity and control surfaces.

One of the problems I've run in to in studying canopy flight is that lots of skydivers can tell you what an input will *do* but they can't explain in technical terms *why* it will do it...therefore it's hard to anticipate what a new input will do, because I don't have a good understanding of the dynamics involved. Front riser turns will produce a diving turn, while braked toggle turns will keep the turn "flat"...but most skydivers have no way of explaining what is happening to AoA, air spilling out from under the canopy, shifts to the center of gravity, etc. during these maneuvers.

I think of the canopy as a "warping wing" similar to the Wright brothers' first warping wing designs for turning. Inputs to the canopy (risers or toggles) can change AoA and/or drag, and those inputs might not be possible in an airplane using flaps and ailerons.



Ok, now what this long example all leads me to--stop trying to think of the canopy the same way you think of an airplane. There are certain general characteristics that carry over between the two (lift and drag, or glide range, for example) but the performance possibilities of a canopy are very different than those of an airplane. Airplanes don't have recovery arcs. Canopies don't have elevator or rudder control surfaces.

When you're flying an airplane, fly an airplane. When you're under canopy, fly a canopy. Think of them as two different machines.

This is kind of like a helicopter vs. airplane. Both are flying machines governed by the laws of physics, but their actual controls and capabilities are very different. Try to start from scratch when you're learning to fly canopies and think "beyond the box" of airplane wing characteristics.


Now, for your specific issue of rough landings...I've been jumping a 9-cell Sabre2 170 for the past 30 jumps or so. I'm thinking of buying a rig with a 7-cell Triathlon 160, so I plan to demo it within the next few weeks. The advice our S&TA gave me? Be ready to flare hard and not have much forward movement under the Triathlon. I can't explain why, he just said that's the way they land. It's probably a combination of several factors.

Hopefully this helps.
 
What no flaps 20 on approach and go 'rounds? Darn...I better read the Parachute and its Pilot. -Bryan S Germain
 
Back
Top