giving holding clearances to your students

gymhaus

Rockin out with my chocks out
Hi all. Lately I have been in a debate with a few other instructors on proper terminology for instructing a student to hold. I know for a vor you use radials and would say something like "cessna 123ab hold east of the xyz vor on the 090 radial make left turns, efc 1200 local" or something similiar but I forget the terminology for a gps or ndb. I remeber the term "bearing" since there's no radials but is it a bearing to the point or from it? I can't seem to find a good source online or in my books for advice so thanks for any help in advance.
 
"Hold over ABCEF as published," would be my way of saying it ;)

But seriously, I don't know if there even is a technically correct way of saying what you're trying to say. Nor does it happen much in real world operations. Customized holds over NDBs or GPS waypoints are really, really rare.

I've had some bizarre, nonstandard holding instructions before. ATC has sort of made up their own phraseology. Things like, "Hold over your present position, expect clearance to (initial approach fix) in five minutes." And that was in IMC. After confirming with ATC there was no specific fix they wanted us to hold over, I told the pilot I was training, "Ok...umm...let's do right 360s, I guess." A few minutes later they cleared us direct to the IAF for a GPS approach.

I guess what I'm saying is...I don't think knowing the answer to your question matters very much. I wouldn't worry about it.
 
Hey bud. Thanks for the quick reply and a few of the instructors at my school would agree with you as they argued the same point: "hold as published", but my theory is if when my students fly or learn from me, I should give them the hardest scenarios they will ever face so that they will always be safe in the future on their own as well as it'll make there checkride a breeze. That being said if I teach them the worng way it'll actually hurt their learning.
 
The AIM is pretty clear on all the elements of a holding clearance, but as the previous poster stated, ATC definitely doesn't always do things "by the book." Any hold I've had to do has been over a published fix, and most of the time my clearance was to "hold as published over ABCDE fix, EFC 1234Z, maintain blah blah blah and report entering the hold at ABCDE.
 
VOR holds as you have described. NDB holds: hold south on the 360 bearing to the station. DME holds: hold SW of the 10 dme fix of BXK VOR on the 030 radial 3mi legs.
 
If you were to give me an NDB hold and just give me the bearing, I would have to ask if that's bearing to or bearing from. Bearing from is the same as a VOR radial, so it's easier to just always give it that way.
 
Hey bud. Thanks for the quick reply and a few of the instructors at my school would agree with you as they argued the same point: "hold as published", but my theory is if when my students fly or learn from me, I should give them the hardest scenarios they will ever face so that they will always be safe in the future on their own as well as it'll make there checkride a breeze. That being said if I teach them the worng way it'll actually hurt their learning.

No doubt, those are excellent goals to aim for.

Just remember to balance out the details with "real world" and practical training.

I've met fresh instrument pilots who could rattle off all sorts of minutia from the AIM such as how to handle equipment failures, check RAIM on a GPS, etc., but didn't understand how to file a flight plan and pick up a clearance out of an untowered airport. They were so prepared for the hard, unexpected situations that they missed some of the obvious ones during their training.

Not saying you're doing this, just something to have in mind for the future.

Keep up the good work!
 
The AIM is pretty clear on all the elements of a holding clearance, but as the previous poster stated, ATC definitely doesn't always do things "by the book." Any hold I've had to do has been over a published fix, and most of the time my clearance was to "hold as published over ABCDE fix, EFC 1234Z, maintain blah blah blah and report entering the hold at ABCDE.
The shortest non-published one I've received was simply "hold SE of the SAF VOR. Expect further clearance..."
 
Tell them to hold on the east side of some cloud you pass by and remind them to pay particular attention to WCA so they don't drift from the cloud.
 
You're basically mean ;)

I resent that, evil is not synonymous with mean! :bandit:

On a more serious note, I found many students just assume I'll always give them proper instructions. In other words, they leave their brains on the ground. Little goofs like this might be mean, but they sure help keep the students brain between their ears where it should be. Besides, I thought brain teasers were supposed to be healthy for us?
 
On a more serious note, I found many students just assume I'll always give them proper instructions.
I had an dual instrument student for whom situational awareness in relation to navaids seemed to be pretty intuitive. I set up a VOR intersection hold and accidentally gave him one where the holding course wasn't on either of the radials making up the intersection. He told me it doesn't work within 3 seconds of my giving the instruction. I was impressed.
 
During my instrument training and checkride i had to hold at an intersection and the clearance that my instructor gave me was always something similar to:

Intercept V3 to VALKA hold south of VALKA on V3 left turns EFC etc... but he would sometimes use Hold east of VALKA right turns and/or switch it to Distance legs.

Hope this helps!
 
Thanks to all. I looked in the AIM prior to posting this but I couldn't find much. Any references/page numbers you found? That's a good idea to give wrong clearances later on to see if they're thinking.
 
No doubt, those are excellent goals to aim for.

Just remember to balance out the details with "real world" and practical training.

I've met fresh instrument pilots who could rattle off all sorts of minutia from the AIM such as how to handle equipment failures, check RAIM on a GPS, etc., but didn't understand how to file a flight plan and pick up a clearance out of an untowered airport. They were so prepared for the hard, unexpected situations that they missed some of the obvious ones during their training.

Not saying you're doing this, just something to have in mind for the future.

Keep up the good work!


Very true. Sometime's I have found myself getting too detailed on a subject that it makes more important things less important. Also the case where after the oral and later in the day you remember something you forgot to tell them..."Ahhhh man"! Thanks
 
I'm not really sure why, but at my old flight school being able to do an unpublished hold at a GPS waypoint was a Really Big Deal.
 
During my instrument training and checkride i had to hold at an intersection and the clearance that my instructor gave me was always something similar to:

Intercept V3 to VALKA hold south of VALKA on V3 left turns EFC etc... but he would sometimes use Hold east of VALKA right turns and/or switch it to Distance legs.

Hope this helps!

Funny. I received that same exact hold for my Instrument checkride a couple years ago... Or was it my II?
 
Holding Phraseology is in the "ATC Bible", FAA Order JO 7110.65T. You can find it at http://www.faa.gov/documentLibrary/media/Order/ATC.pdf.

The section you want to look at is 4-6-4. It says the following:

When issuing holding instructions, specify:
a. Direction of holding from the fix/waypoint.
b. Holding fix or waypoint. (NOTE-The holding fix may be omitted if included at the beginningof the transmission as the clearance limit.)
c. Radial, course, bearing, track, azimuth, airway,or route on which the aircraft is to hold.
d. Leg length in miles if DME or RNAV is to be used. Specify leg length in minutes if the pilot requests it or you consider it necessary.
e. Direction of holding pattern turns only if leftturns are to be made, the pilot requests it, or you consider it necessary.


PHRASEOLOGY-
HOLD (direction) OF (fix/waypoint) ON (specified radial,course, bearing, track, airway, azimuth(s), or route.) 

If leg length is specified,

(number of minutes/miles) MINUTE/MILE LEG.

If direction of turn is specified,



LEFT/RIGHT TURNS.
So, for an NDB, you might hear:

N1234, Hold Southeast of PWF on bearing 350, 3 mile leg, left turns.
 
Back
Top