Amateur hour at US Airways

Yes, we all make mistakes,
Then let it go. People have off days and $% up.
but ones like this that have far-reaching effects and are avoidable,
yep. But you know what? That's why they;re mistakes.

Ooh look. Typo. I made a mistake.

aren't the kind that I would would try and write off. I hope these guys at least learned something from this.

They didn't write it off. THEY OWNED UP TO IT.

If anything, you make my eyes go cross eyed and I hope you learn something from this [discussion].

Not everyone is agreeing with you here, I hope you can see that./
 
Preaching to the choir, my friend. I know exactly what you mean and where you're coming from. What I'm saying is that this public perception is the unfortunate enemy you have to fight against, whether deserved or not. Sucks, but it is.

I'm not a politician, so I don't see how getting the public on my side really matters. I'm far more concerned with getting pilots on our side, the union side. Once we have that, the public can choose to fly or not. It's kinda like listening to people grip about professional athletes (entertainers), while pay and seat attendance fluctuate, everyone feels (me included) they make too much but that doesn't mean I'm not gonna watch football/baseball.

/side note
I say let the supply demand side settle down with the pilots making a good wage, if that means less jobs then so be it. I've had plenty of rewarding jobs outside aviation I'll go back to that if needed.
 
Then let it go. People have off days and $% up.

yep. But you know what? That's why they;re mistakes.

Ooh look. Typo. I made a mistake.

What, are you twelve? Nice argument.

They didn't write it off. THEY OWNED UP TO IT.

If anything, you make my eyes go cross eyed and I hope you learn something from this [discussion].

Not everyone is agreeing with you here, I hope you can see that./

So everyone has to agree with me in order for me to have a fair point? Thats some nice groupthink there.

Yeah, they screwed up. Doesn't make writing a thread/post about it wrong. It happened, and I've given them credit for acknowledging that. I can also very much see where pax would be rightfully annoyed by delays that are avoidable, whether a mistake or not. If you can't see the other side of the coin, then you're simply blind.
 
Mike, I think you need to call up their chief pilot and report them.

But realistically, my guess would be that the only "amateur" thing they did was make a PA that didn't totally explain the situation. You may understand more than the average passenger, but that doesn't mean that it's fair to bash their professionalism and abilities because they don't cater the information to your level of understanding.

Different pilots have different explanations for situations that arise. There are guys out there that would rather have passengers think that they're an idiot instead of freaking out the nervous flyers by mentioning the word "mechanical" in a PA. It's too bad they didn't adequately explain the situation, but that doesn't mean they suck at their job.
 
Mike, I think you need to call up their chief pilot and report them.

:D No, I'm not like some of the air police we have here at JC.

But realistically, my guess would be that the only "amateur" thing they did was make a PA that didn't totally explain the situation. You may understand more than the average passenger, but that doesn't mean that it's fair to bash their professionalism and abilities because they don't cater the information to your level of understanding.

Different pilots have different explanations for situations that arise. There are guys out there that would rather have passengers think that they're an idiot instead of freaking out the nervous flyers by mentioning the word "mechanical" in a PA. It's too bad they didn't adequately explain the situation, but that doesn't mean they suck at their job.

Didn't say they sucked at their job, only that Im surprised that they're surprised that missing release might actually mean that you don't takeoff. And there was no mechanical anyway in this case, although I see exactly what you mean by that statement.
 
What, are you twelve? Nice argument.



So everyone has to agree with me in order for me to have a fair point? Thats some nice groupthink there.

Yeah, they screwed up. Doesn't make writing a thread/post about it wrong. It happened, and I've given them credit for acknowledging that. I can also very much see where pax would be rightfully annoyed by delays that are avoidable, whether a mistake or not. If you can't see the other side of the coin, then you're simply blind.

Yes....I'm twelve.


The point I made is that no, not everyone has to agree with you to make a fair point. Rather, you make a point. You, however, are deaf to the argument that while you have made a point you fail to acknowledge that you might not have the entire story and could (quite possibly) be wrong.

So while calling me blind may be convenient, I find it hypocritical as you can see by a half dozen arguments posted in contrast to yours - but without so much as an acknowledgment that they are valid as well.

:beer:
 
Unless i'm sitting in the jumpseat, I try not to armchair quarterback another crew member since I don't have all the info.
 
Yes....I'm twelve.


The point I made is that no, not everyone has to agree with you to make a fair point. Rather, you make a point. You, however, are deaf to the argument that while you have made a point you fail to acknowledge that you might not have the entire story and could (quite possibly) be wrong.

So while calling me blind may be convenient, I find it hypocritical as you can see by a half dozen arguments posted in contrast to yours - but without so much as an acknowledgment that they are valid as well.

:beer:

Ive acknowledged every point of view here as to their merits. So if you don't see that, then you're blind....or not reading.
 
Considering that the crew was socializing with one of the FAs as they were still at the gate, there's no excuse.

Gotcha...next time we're at the gate I'm gonna go ahead and knock out the before takeoff checklist...you know, flap verifications, telling the flight attendant to be seated, etc. How silly of me to not have that taken care of at the gate.
 
Eh, I've done TUS-PHX plenty of times and had a similar situation. We didn't take too long doing anything, advised ATC when we were pushing so they could get a release time. By the time we were taxiing to the runway they finally got back to us with close to an hour delay. PHX was clear with good weather, like always. I'll never completely understand the release times in the ATC system, and I'm not sure anyone truly does. I've had plenty of similar situations on the east coast too.
 
:D No, I'm not like some of the air police we have here at JC.

;)
Just remember, it's not that great a distance from posting flight specifics on google-referenced forums to someone getting called into the CP's office.

Didn't say they sucked at their job, only that Im surprised that they're surprised that missing release might actually mean that you don't takeoff. And there was no mechanical anyway in this case, although I see exactly what you mean by that statement.

But my point is, how do you know there wasn't a mechanical other than taking their word for it...like I said, passengers don't always get the whole truth. When I'm in a jumpseat, I know exactly what's going on--but riding in the back is a different story.
 
;)
Just remember, it's not that great a distance from posting flight specifics on google-referenced forums to someone getting called into the CP's office.

While very true, it's not like this flight being late is a complete unknown situation to anyone at the airline. Thats a stretch. There was no crime or violation/bust we're talking about.

But my point is, how do you know there wasn't a mechanical other than taking their word for it...like I said, passengers don't always get the whole truth. When I'm in a jumpseat, I know exactly what's going on--but riding in the back is a different story.

Just what the FO/FA said post flight when deplaning after I asked.....no mention. Of course that doesn't mean that it wasn't the reason, I'm again only going by what was said.

My only thing I find interesting/funny is the admitted surprise at the delay.
 
Usually when we have a flight miss a wheels up time (EDCT) - our soc folks are already on the phone to atc command center asking for the next available. Things that I have seen work in our favor is requesting a different altitude/changing your route - mainly the star transition.
 
Wow. Talk about dooshbags coming out of the woodwork.

"How do you know the pilots didn't lie about the situation?"
"How do you know it wasn't their fault?"
"What if it was mechanical and they lied about it?"
"Why are you complaining?"
"Why didn't you drive?"
"Anybody else can b*tch about a flight except you, MikeD."
"Your armchair quarterbacking something that they told you happened."
"Nobody has to agree with you."
:rolleyes:
 
Just went for a jog and thought of another thing.

How about a green-on-green crew situation, or something similar?

i.e. captain recently came to the Airbus from the right seat of the 757, and the first officer just came back from 2 years of military deployment. Each has only been back to work for a month or two and they are paired together. Would it not be prudent to make sure both are on the same page when the trip starts as far as just taking it slow and making sure everything is done just right?

Just another example of what could have been going on up there, and that's not the type of thing I'd want to include in the PA either.
 
Back
Top