The *almost dreaded* Flight Review

I always thought about it in terms of 1) making sure the guy was going to be safe, and 2) CYA.


When someone would make an appointment for a BFR I'd usually send them to Gleim for some 'homework' prior to their flight. Their pilot refresher course costs $30, and covers all the high points you're going to want to cover with them, but comes with handy proof for your files that the guy has had some groundschool. They can bring in their completion certificate when they come for the flight. I always made a copy for my file, as a CYA.

Although there is some additional cost, I felt it benefited the person by letting them get their head back in the game, knowledge-wise, and by the time they'd arrive for the flight, we could spend that required hour talking about things they were unsure of, had further questions about, or the FAA flavor of the year areas of special interest. I never had a problem filling up that hour.
 
What was the plane and what was the cost?

I know of 2 places around the Daytona area that do it. One does it with a Twin Seebee, another with a Grumman Goose. There is a place over in Central Florida (exact location escapes me right now), that runs a Twin Seebee as well. Plus Sheble out in Arizona runs a BE-18 on floats. Quite a few places to do it, but you've got to have a truckload of money. I'd love to do it, but just can't find the money.
 
When the Applicant for a BFR crashes the airplane or violates some reg's it comes back on you. Same as a DE.

I think this may be more legend than reality. Not to say it's OK to give a wink-wink Flight Review, but the standing assupmtion is that you'll only sign off a pilot if they perform adequately.
 
When the Applicant for a BFR crashes the airplane or violates some reg's it comes back on you. Same as a DE.

I think this may be more legend than reality. Not to say it's OK to give a wink-wink Flight Review, but the standing assupmtion is that you'll only sign off a pilot if they perform adequately.

The worst I've ever heard is that the FAA comes and wants to see the records of the FR. If someone has a story that is first or second hand account, or well documented, of the FAA coming after a CFI for someone who just passed a flight review and had an incident/accident/violation, I'd like to see it.
 
If someone has a story that is first or second hand account, or well documented, of the FAA coming after a CFI for someone who just passed a flight review and had an incident/accident/violation, I'd like to see it.
Me too. Let's nip this in the bud. The FAA does not "come after" a cfi when a pilot crashes or causes a violation. They may "investigate" the pilot's recent history, but the fact that you signed off a recent FR does not implicate you in any way.

Anyone have a story of conflict?
 
Me too. Let's nip this in the bud. The FAA does not "come after" a cfi when a pilot crashes or causes a violation. They may "investigate" the pilot's recent history, but the fact that you signed off a recent FR does not implicate you in any way.

Anyone have a story of conflict?

Even the lawsuit horror stories are mostly urban ledgend.

Lawyers sue anybody with "deep pockets" (Cessna, Lycoming, the city, the FAA, ect). Your average CFI living below the poverty line isn't on their target list.
 
Even the lawsuit horror stories are mostly urban ledgend.

Lawyers sue anybody with "deep pockets" (Cessna, Lycoming, the city, the FAA, ect). Your average CFI living below the poverty line isn't on their target list.

I carry some liability insurance when I instruct, but I decided a long time ago that if I ever got sued, I'd just show up at the lawyer's office with my student loans from college and ask how much of it they wanted, because I'd gladly share.
 
Instructors, provide adequate instruction and the FAA won't come after you with teeth.

Evidence: One of our instructors did a BFR with a guy in his Bonanza, the next day the guy geared up his Bonanza. Sure the FAA talked to the CFI, but it was because they wanted information about the guy...not to check up on the instructor.
 
The FAA posted a letter about a year ago where they announced they would talk to the CFI who last flew with a pilot receiving a violation. This is not "coming after you", but seeing if there was something you noticed in the pilot's flying skills. I'll see if I can find the letter- it was posted here.
Now if a pilot has a violation or an accident and in the review of the pilot's records the FAA comes across some problems in training they may come after you. For example, if you sign off a flight review after a .5 flight they may have some issues. Or if you do an IPC that is not conducted IAW the PTS covering the required maneuvers they may come after you. Or an accident by a student pilot on a solo and you have no record of the required training.
 
I love BFRS because its a good way to review knowledge in one shot, as opposed to over a period of time with a regular student. Plus you meet some very interesting characters sometimes.

When a person walks in to book a BFR, our flight school hands out a take-home BFR quiz that covers the basics. When they come back, we go over it to make sure they understand, and not just copied word-for-word from the FARS and POH. We'll then talk about anything else that may affect him at a local level. The ground is usually 2 hours and I've never been hassled for taking longer/shorter than that. Some people need more of a refresher, some are still on top of it.

So, if the BFR were 100% up to me, I'd write up a take home quiz, and put it somewhere a student can download at their leisure.
 
Thanks for all the input in this thread, I'll be "one of those characters" coming in to do a BFR and maybe an IPC in the near future. I miss the hell out of flying...
 
Back
Top