The *almost dreaded* Flight Review

JLF

Well-Known Member
I'm not a big fan so far of doing them so far. I've come to find out that I really need to call these people in advance of their flight review to let them know what is expected.

  • No knowledge of the requirements of a flight review ("hey, a yeah, I need to do 1hr with a CFI."
  • Looks at the FAR/AIM like... Hrmmm, I'm not sure if I remember that book, or not.
  • No charts
  • No W&B, or a clue as how to do one.
  • No idea of the airspace we're in, or the airspace we'll be entering.
This is just a few examples. Now, if a guy / gal has been out of the game for a while it is totally understandable that they wouldn't be up to par on a lot things; even some of the things mentioned above. I realize that. HHoowweevveerr, my experience has been that they show up thinking they need to prang 3 on and their good.

Mine involves some discussion, a flight review "test" modeled after AC 61-98A and then an aircraft specific questionnaire to cover the checkout.

I would like to hear some opinions from people that have been there, done that, longer than I, about how they conduct flight reviews. It's been a rough start for me. They've mostly been people who have been out of the game for years.

As a CFI, the CYA factor is the highest of anything I've signed my name to yet.

To the FR recipient, please lol... Bring a current FAR/AIM, some sort of wx check, a TFR check, and an attitude that you really do want to cover your own bases.

P.S. IPCs will come in a future post. Primer: Showing up with one 5 year old Jepp and thinking that'll work.

whew... after that it's weekends. Lets vent. :pirate:



this post was brought to you by the worst CFI thread and Mojitos.
 
I'm not a big fan so far of doing them so far. I've come to find out that I really need to call these people in advance of their flight review to let them know what is expected.

  • No knowledge of the requirements of a flight review ("hey, a yeah, I need to do 1hr with a CFI."
  • Looks at the FAR/AIM like... Hrmmm, I'm not sure if I remember that book, or not.
  • No charts
  • No W&B, or a clue as how to do one.
  • No idea of the airspace we're in, or the airspace we'll be entering.
This is just a few examples. Now, if a guy / gal has been out of the game for a while it is totally understandable that they wouldn't be up to par on a lot things; even some of the things mentioned above. I realize that. HHoowweevveerr, my experience has been that they show up thinking they need to prang 3 on and their good.

Mine involves some discussion, a flight review "test" modeled after AC 61-98A and then an aircraft specific questionnaire to cover the checkout.

I would like to hear some opinions from people that have been there, done that, longer than I, about how they conduct flight reviews. It's been a rough start for me. They've mostly been people who have been out of the game for years.

As a CFI, the CYA factor is the highest of anything I've signed my name to yet.

To the FR recipient, please lol... Bring a current FAR/AIM, some sort of wx check, a TFR check, and an attitude that you really do want to cover your own bases.

P.S. IPCs will come in a future post. Primer: Showing up with one 5 year old Jepp and thinking that'll work.

whew... after that it's weekends. Lets vent. :pirate:



this post was brought to you by the worst CFI thread and Mojitos.
You're on the right track.
 
I'm not a big fan so far of doing them so far. I've come to find out that I really need to call these people in advance of their flight review to let them know what is expected.

  • No knowledge of the requirements of a flight review ("hey, a yeah, I need to do 1hr with a CFI."
  • Looks at the FAR/AIM like... Hrmmm, I'm not sure if I remember that book, or not.
  • No charts
  • No W&B, or a clue as how to do one.
  • No idea of the airspace we're in, or the airspace we'll be entering.
This is just a few examples. Now, if a guy / gal has been out of the game for a while it is totally understandable that they wouldn't be up to par on a lot things; even some of the things mentioned above. I realize that. HHoowweevveerr, my experience has been that they show up thinking they need to prang 3 on and their good.

Mine involves some discussion, a flight review "test" modeled after AC 61-98A and then an aircraft specific questionnaire to cover the checkout.

I would like to hear some opinions from people that have been there, done that, longer than I, about how they conduct flight reviews. It's been a rough start for me. They've mostly been people who have been out of the game for years.

As a CFI, the CYA factor is the highest of anything I've signed my name to yet.

To the FR recipient, please lol... Bring a current FAR/AIM, some sort of wx check, a TFR check, and an attitude that you really do want to cover your own bases.

P.S. IPCs will come in a future post. Primer: Showing up with one 5 year old Jepp and thinking that'll work.

whew... after that it's weekends. Lets vent. :pirate:



this post was brought to you by the worst CFI thread and Mojitos.

http://www.faa.gov/pilots/training/media/flight_review.pdf
First I start out by asking them some questions... how often they fly, what they fly, what type of flying they normally do.
1. I have them do the FAA flight review course. This covers many of the regulations. Depending on the type of flying they have done I may also have them do one of the AOPA ASF courses.
2. I tell them to plan a cross country- IFR if instrument rated, VFR if not- and to have the proper publications for the flight. They can use whatever means of planning the cross country they wish, computerized or manual. This includes getting the weather products and filing a flight plan.
3. I have them do a weight and balance for the flight as well as performance planning.
http://samdawsoncfi.com/Performanceplanning.html
4. I have them do an open book POH quiz for their airplane or the airplane they will rent.
All of this is done prior to our meeting and costs them... a little time.
I tell them up front that our ground will probably last 2 hours, then about 1.5 of flying if everything goes well. If they have not flown much, maybe long. But I am up front with them and try to manage their expectations. If they don't like it they are free to go elsewhere and I sleep well at night.
 

Thanks Blackhawk and royer, royer.

Blackhawk, if I had asked even one of these guys to bring me a flight plan I think the FBO would've imploded. The sleeping well at night thing does appeal to me though.

I absolutely feel them out as to the type of flying they do / will do. In my mind it shouldn't matter though.

Let me ask you guys this. This is in regard to curtailing the flight review (like the FAA guidance supposes) to the type of flying the individual pilot does.

At the end of the day, do you sign a VFR guy off that couldn't pass a Private Pilot Practical Examination? The private obviously encompasses a lot. A lot more than a lot of pilots engage in.

I know what the easy answer to that is.
 
I love giving flight reviews. They are really some of my favorite flights.

I brief them of what I want prior to us meeting, and that gets rid of some of the frustration you posted.
Prepare:
VFR X-C via your method of choice.
Weight and balance, I'm 190 with 10 lbs of bags.
These are the types of questions I'm going to ask you "abc123". (I'm not looking to trick him and I don't expect him to spend 12 hours the day before trying to memorize the blue book just so he can forget it after he regurgitates it to me. I want him to know how to look them up and reference them when needed.)
Make sure all charts are current and be familiar with them.

Easy-peasy.

That's not to say that some haven't take multiple lessons. Here are two of my favorites.

1. Long story but the FR ended with me actually saying, "Don't bust class Bravo anymore, understood?"

2. A nice guy, an electrician, who had been out of flying for a while; part of the FR is to take me to Red Oak Iowa via pilotage, the student gets close and we happen to be in the East practice area...convenient.
This guy though started off lost. Soon enough we hit Shenandoah Iowa, it was about the right distance, but about 15-20 miles west of Red Oak. He is in the pattern making Red Oak traffic calls. We land, never mind the runways don't line up with Red Oak, then the greatest "I was lost but now I'm found" look came over his face when he read the big sign...."Welcome to Shenandoah".

He then agreed it would take longer than one flight to get him back into flying shape.
 
At the end of the day, do you sign a VFR guy off that couldn't pass a Private Pilot Practical Examination? The private obviously encompasses a lot. A lot more than a lot of pilots engage in.

I know what the easy answer to that is.
Actually, probably, yes. I mean, does an individual NEED to be able to do a PTS-perfect turn-around-a-point for me to judge them to be safe to fly for the next 2 years? No, not really. Do they need to know the Offishul Skool o' Flite procedure for performing the Power-Off Stall PTS Dog Trick? No, not really. Should they be able to safely recover when I set them up in a stall scenario? Absolutely! And their traffic patterns should be somewhat square, and the landings should be on the 2 big wheels first, with the upwind one touching down first in a crosswind...yadda yadda yadda.
 
To the FR recipient, please lol... Bring a current FAR/AIM, some sort of wx check, a TFR check, and an attitude that you really do want to cover your own bases.

P.S. IPCs will come in a future post. Primer: Showing up with one 5 year old Jepp and thinking that'll work.
[/SIZE]

I don't think it is really necessary to make someone invest in a bunch of current charts that they will use once during a flight review. Especially an FAR/AIM (I've only bought one when I have a checkride). In the real world, it isn't something I carry with me, and if I need to look something up, it is more current on the internet anyway.

The world is not going to end if you do a practice approach with an out of date plate either, but you didn't hear me say that ;)
 
2. A nice guy, an electrician, who had been out of flying for a while; part of the FR is to take me to Red Oak Iowa via pilotage, the student gets close and we happen to be in the East practice area...convenient.
This guy though started off lost. Soon enough we hit Shenandoah Iowa, it was about the right distance, but about 15-20 miles west of Red Oak. He is in the pattern making Red Oak traffic calls. We land, never mind the runways don't line up with Red Oak, then the greatest "I was lost but now I'm found" look came over his face when he read the big sign...."Welcome to Shenandoah".

He then agreed it would take longer than one flight to get him back into flying shape.

I don't blame em for staying the hell away from RDK. Every time I've been there, an idiot pilot crosses the intersecting runway while I'm attempting to land. It'd be great to hold short, even better to announce himself on CTAF. Too many close calls for comfort, I remember having A nice 152 pass right over me in the pattern, I don't enjoy seeing facials expressions from other pilots in the sky:crazy:
 
To lazy to read all the replies but I'll but in some input. I absolutely dreaded doing BFR's. All the risk w/ no reward. IMHO what I was looking for was a pilot that wouldn't kill himself and others, and wouldn't get him or myself violated.

That was pretty much my only criteria.

Go do a short X-C to somewhere near 50 nm's away (Controlled Preferably). On the way out there they lose their GPS if they have one and lose it for the rest of the leg. Once at the airport we do multiple landings, flapless, etc...On the way back we hit the maneuvers, hood work, and VOR Nav.

My BFR's always lasted about 1.5-2.0 on the hobbs w/ about 2 hours of ground before hand. Granted I almost lost my job over the length of my BFR but that's another story.
 
To lazy to read all the replies but I'll but in some input. I absolutely dreaded doing BFR's. All the risk w/ no reward. IMHO what I was looking for was a pilot that wouldn't kill himself and others, and wouldn't get him or myself violated.

Whats the "risk" with a FR? If you have covered all the bases and logged everything, and they performed to acceptable standards (which the FAA has given you the authority to determine) then why would you be worried?

I understand the thinking that you have never flown with this person besides the hour or two for the FR so you don't really know what kind of pilot they may be. But the regs spell it out and leave it up to the CFI to determine they can safely operate the aircraft. Its actually similar to what a DPE does on a daily basis.
 
Whats the "risk" with a FR? If you have covered all the bases and logged everything, and they performed to acceptable standards (which the FAA has given you the authority to determine) then why would you be worried?

I understand the thinking that you have never flown with this person besides the hour or two for the FR so you don't really know what kind of pilot they may be. But the regs spell it out and leave it up to the CFI to determine they can safely operate the aircraft. Its actually similar to what a DPE does on a daily basis.

When the Applicant for a BFR crashes the airplane or violates some reg's it comes back on you. Same as a DE.
 
Actually, probably, yes. I mean, does an individual NEED to be able to do a PTS-perfect turn-around-a-point for me to judge them to be safe to fly for the next 2 years? No, not really. Do they need to know the Offishul Skool o' Flite procedure for performing the Power-Off Stall PTS Dog Trick? No, not really. Should they be able to safely recover when I set them up in a stall scenario? Absolutely! And their traffic patterns should be somewhat square, and the landings should be on the 2 big wheels first, with the upwind one touching down first in a crosswind...yadda yadda yadda.

I absolutely agree.

I don't think it is really necessary to make someone invest in a bunch of current charts that they will use once during a flight review. Especially an FAR/AIM (I've only bought one when I have a checkride). In the real world, it isn't something I carry with me, and if I need to look something up, it is more current on the internet anyway.

The world is not going to end if you do a practice approach with an out of date plate either, but you didn't hear me say that ;)

They can print them free of charge at the FBO. I don't look at an IPC as just shooting practice approaches. There are just certain things I need to see before I'll sign someone off as current.

To lazy to read all the replies but I'll but in some input. I absolutely dreaded doing BFR's. All the risk w/ no reward. IMHO what I was looking for was a pilot that wouldn't kill himself and others, and wouldn't get him or myself violated.

That was pretty much my only criteria.

I feel the same way, but I also realize that it is my own fault so far. I think a short phone call would go a long way in the future. Maybe even email them the aircraft checkout questionnaire before hand to get the gears turning.

Thanks people!
 
Back
Top