Whats more common?

My experiance with other Flight Schools though is that this is not the case. I have walked in for a check out and had the CFI say lets go fly, no weight and balance for this particular flight or checking the weather. Now I end up saying hold up In a polite way in these situations and crunch the numbers my self and check Duats quick.

I have never seen a part 61 flight school do W&B routinely for Cessna 172's. It isn't really necessary, unless you have a very overweight student ;)

If the weight doesn't change between flights, I see no reason to recompute it.
 
all this weather stuff i guess i'll chime in with a scenario. Say you are flying and are about to shoot an instrument approach in MVFR conditions. Say you are over the FAF and tower calls you and advises you that RVR or visibility is less than that shown on the approach plate. So you continue the approach anyways. along the approach you lose an engine and crash.

So now the FAA and NTSB pull the tapes and hear that tower has advised you that the RVR or reported visibility was said to be less than that on the approach plate. You however could see the airport from the FAF no problem and didn't notice fog or any visual issues on the ground. In this case, it would seem to me that the Feds are NOT going to side with you on the issue seeing as you can't prove you could see the airport.

So i guess its what you can prove...
 
I never said it's illegal. It's a matter of proof. If you use DUATS or call then you get a majority of the info that you are looking for and a paper trail. After that go on to whatever site you want, but at least you have the paper trail and proof that you received weather and other pertinent info.

When I taught Ground School I always told my students that we can debate regs till the cows come home. But if I where you id just play it safe, have a paper trail, and the piece of mind that comes with it.

The argument is academic. Nothing you're suggesting is "wrong" or "bad", I think it's just that those of us doing daily operations kind of chuckle at the idea of calculating a W&B for every flight in the same aircraft or getting a full WX brief for a local flight. Once you start flying day in/day out in the same aircraft under the same circumstances, that kind of stuff isn't really necessary. Now, if you're training students (which I'm not), then it's a good thing to practice with them. It's just a "real world" vs. "flight academy" mindset.
 
Has anyone on here even bothered to read or cite 91.103?

In the scenario posed by the original poster, it would've been completely legal to go without a brief. In particular, we're concerned with 91.203(a)

§ 91.103 Preflight action.
Each pilot in command shall, before beginning a flight, become familiar with all available information concerning that flight. This information must include—

(a) For a flight under IFR or a flight not in the vicinity of an airport, weather reports and forecasts, fuel requirements, alternatives available if the planned flight cannot be completed, and any known traffic delays of which the pilot in command has been advised by ATC;

For local flights, you're good to go.
 
Back
Top