Night lost comms

Aviator1988

Well-Known Member
So i had an actual lost comms scenario with a private pilot student of mine. We were cleared for departure on runway 25R at KDAB. We were at 500 feet when tower switched us over to departure. When my student keyed up the mic to confirm towers instructions comm/nav1 failed, along with the inside panel and instrument lights. comm/nav 2 still displayed but did not transmit or recieve either.

I took the controls trying to see if i could find out what the problem is (maybe i bumped the volume knob, headsets not plugged in all the way, etc). everything appeared fine. I checked for warning annunciators which there were none, checked engine instruments which were all green, and checked circuit breakers which none had popped.

After fiddling around, i told my student to hold the flashlight on the instruments so i could see, while i flew the airplane. we squawked 7600 and rejoined the pattern. Tower gave us the flashing green on the downwind followed by the stead green on the base and final. we landed, stopped, and recieved the flashing green to taxi. This occured at DAB, and runway 25R was in use.

When we landed my student asked me why i chose to land on 25R instead of 25L. I mentioned that i wasn't 100% on the regs, but i chose 25R to land on instead of 25L because that was the runway we departed on. Since the flashing green means "return for landing" in the air, one would assume that means land on the runway you departed on. Anybody want to chime in on this?
 
I don't have any input on the runway choice, but one thought crossed my mind as I read your account. I think that I would have considered letting the student continue to fly the plane if I felt at all confident in his abilities. This would free me to trouble shoot the issue without having to divide my attention, and reinforce to the student how much information you can get if you lose instruments just by paying attention to sounds and position of controls (how much throttle do I have in, how much rudder am I using, what does the wind noise sound like...). If I didn't smell any electrical burn smells or have other indications of an immediate issue this would be a great learning experience for both the student and the teacher. We could talk about the aircraft control issues, and priority of duties, and delegation of responsibilities, and how each pilot must rely on the other to do his part, and, well...all kinds of things!

Good job on handling the situation!
 
I'd have gone for 25R as well, for the following reasons:

-it tends to have less closed traffic on it than 25L, which means it's easier to fit yourself into the normal flow
-normally you depart from 25R because you're headed northbound, which would put you closer to it after departure than you would be to 25L, and the pattern entry is going to be much easier (this is the most important one in my mind - keeping things simple is a good thing when you've lost your comms)

But I don't think there's anything in the regs that says you have to land on a certain runway. I think you're interpreting the "return for landing" the wrong way - all it really means is that you should come back around for a landing, not necessarily to the same runway that you left from. It's not the same as the "return to starting point on airport" concept. Sometimes, the most convenient runway to you might not be the one you departed from (such as you were departing to the south off of 25R - then I might go to 25L, as long as I didn't see a lot of traffic in the pattern). There's really no right or wrong answer here.

I also agree with SteveC that had I been in the same situation, I probably would have had my student fly while I troubleshot the problem.

Kudos for handling the issue.
 
I really don't have anything new to add, just pretty much "ditto" on what Steve said.

In that situation, ATC is watching you and obviously understood what was going on, so they are ready to deal with whatever course is taken.

Did anyone find the source of the avionics / electrical problem?
 
I don't have any input on the runway choice, but one thought crossed my mind as I read your account. I think that I would have considered letting the student continue to fly the plane if I felt at all confident in his abilities. This would free me to trouble shoot the issue without having to divide my attention, and reinforce to the student how much information you can get if you lose instruments just by paying attention to sounds and position of controls (how much throttle do I have in, how much rudder am I using, what does the wind noise sound like...). If I didn't smell any electrical burn smells or have other indications of an immediate issue this would be a great learning experience for both the student and the teacher. We could talk about the aircraft control issues, and priority of duties, and delegation of responsibilities, and how each pilot must rely on the other to do his part, and, well...all kinds of things!

Good job on handling the situation!


Sit back and watch, like you said, kind of. I would sit back and watch, and after a few minutes, I would have started making sugestions. And only when I was afriad of our saftey would I have stepped in. I have been in a similar situation, departing OKB when the alternator failed in a 172 on departure. We returned to OKB on the students decision, called TRACON, asked for permission through the Mode C vail and over Charlie airspace with no transponder, and used a handheld for radio comms. I gave the student ideas on how he could complete the flight, and let him figure it out. Bottom line, you (OP) were the only one in the airplane with authority to make decisions like this, and made sure of a safe and timely outcome, so good job. Anything else would me Monday morning QB'ing.

What would concern me, is if the student was by themself, and this happened, and didn't know what to do, lost SA, and made a smoking hole in the ground. Things happen, and this was a perfect example of how to handle a situation like this. I think it's a good thing, for a student to see something like this, and how to handle a situation similar in the future. I only wish more students could see things like this more often.

As for the runway, it doesn't matter what one you use, just get it on the ground safe. Think of it as requesting a specific runway, instead of the one you are given in a clearance.
 
We were flying a C-172 SP. yes, probably should have allowed student to fly the aircraft but i guess it was just instinctive for me to take over. we did talk a lot about it while flying and once we landed. i am a newer instructor as well, and my student is a private student with only 19 or so hours. Was a learning experience for both of us.
 
I think you did a great job with this. The student learned a real and valuable lesson that he will carry with him the rest of his flying career.

Your student is well prepared for an emergency and when the next one happens, I'm sure he'll handle it very well.


Joe
 
Good job checking everything. :clap:

In that situation, IMO you don't have to worry about what runway you land on because they would never bring an aircraft in or let one take off when you are in the pattern preparing to land.
Going back to your departure runway does make everything round, but I don't think it is necessary. Honestly I'd probably pick the one with the shortest taxi.
 
so just a small update. I was flying with the same student yesterday on his first cross country flight. We had just switched from Daytona Departure to Orlando approach for flight following (heading to melbourne). he noticed a "VOLT" light flashing and the ammeter was showing a discharge. he told me about it and i asked him what he thought we should do. he noticed the alt fld circuit breaker had popped and reset it. then a minute later it popped again so he decided we should go back to daytona. i think this kid is bad luck... lol. he is a very good student though, studies hard, knows his stuff, and his flying is very good as well. he's getting lots of system failure and emergency practice lately.
 
Good job checking everything. :clap:

In that situation, IMO you don't have to worry about what runway you land on because they would never bring an aircraft in or let one take off when you are in the pattern preparing to land.
Going back to your departure runway does make everything round, but I don't think it is necessary. Honestly I'd probably pick the one with the shortest taxi.


yea i thought about this as well. oddly enough, the runway i chose (our departure runway) to land on was the one with the shortest taxi :).
 
Back
Top