a few of questions for cfi

C172

New Member
1. If you're an MEI but haven't flown multi for a year and then fly with a friend who can rent the plane from his flight school and has multi commercial only, can you legally log a the hours under the hood as a PIC?
2. If two commercial pilots are not night current, can they go up together to regain currency?
3. You are a CFI and not night current but your student who has a private pilot license and working on his IFR rating is current, can you fly with him and get current again or you have to go up by yourself?
 
1. Yes, the other pilot fully qualifies as a safety pilot

2. No

3. I think the CFI could probably ride with the student and get current, but he'd defnintely have to do the 3 full stop night landings himself. Personally, I'd probably just go up by myself and knock the landings out in about 1/2 hour and have no question about it
 
1. If you're an MEI but haven't flown multi for a year and then fly with a friend who can rent the plane from his flight school and has multi commercial only, can you legally log a the hours under the hood as a PIC?
2. If two commercial pilots are not night current, can they go up together to regain currency?
3. You are a CFI and not night current but your student who has a private pilot license and working on his IFR rating is current, can you fly with him and get current again or you have to go up by yourself?

The FAA's take on student pilots and certificated pilots is they are not passengers so they can "ride along" without violating the FAR's. The AOPA had a big article on that about two years ago.
 
The FAA's take on student pilots and certificated pilots is they are not passengers so they can "ride along" without violating the FAR's.
Not really. At least not just "ride along." In order to come under the interpretation, the CFI has to be giving instruction -n acting as a CFI, not just as another pilot or passenger who happens to have a CFI certificate.
 
1. If you're an MEI but haven't flown multi for a year and then fly with a friend who can rent the plane from his flight school and has multi commercial only, can you legally log a the hours under the hood as a PIC?
Yes. Logging PIC time as sole manipulator under 61.51(e) is based on having the appropriate aircraft category and class ratings. Nothing else is required.

2. If two commercial pilots are not night current, can they go up together to regain currency?
Not unless it's an aircraft or operation that requires two pilots for the entire flight. Unless that's the case, one of them is a passenger.

3. You are a CFI and not night current but your student who has a private pilot license and working on his IFR rating is current, can you fly with him and get current again or you have to go up by yourself?
Doesn't matter in the instructional context whether either or both or neither is current. As esa said, the FAA does not consider a CFI and a pilot on an instructional flight as a passenger. Here's the two Chief Counsel opinions on the subject:

Kortokrax (certificated pilots)
http://www.faa.gov/about/office_org...tations/data/interps/2006/Kortokraxinterp.doc

Olshock (student pilots)
http://www.faa.gov/about/office_org...tations/data/interps/2006/Kortokraxinterp.doc
 
Not really. At least not just "ride along." In order to come under the interpretation, the CFI has to be giving instruction -n acting as a CFI, not just as another pilot or passenger who happens to have a CFI certificate.

I'm sure it's FSDO dependant then because in the event of a violation the FAA has violated the highest certificated pilot on board. A friend of mine got dinged when he was riding in the back of a Seminole that busted airspace. The rationale was that since he was a MEI he had knowledge of the operation and could have prevented the bust.

When I get to a computer I'll try and find the AOPA article that lists the specific instance of a non-night current CFI flying legally with a student pilot at night.
 
A friend of mine got dinged when he was riding in the back of a Seminole that busted airspace. The rationale was that since he was a MEI he had knowledge of the operation and could have prevented the bust.

The FAA don't frown on backseat drivers? Aint that a ditch! I'd be a little upset over that. :confused:But sir, I pulled my gun out and they still didn't turn the aircraft! I didn't want to shot my friend over it. Look how big his arms are now he's gonna wanna kick my ass after all of this and I get a busted for it!
 
When I get to a computer I'll try and find the AOPA article that lists the specific instance of a non-night current CFI flying legally with a student pilot at night.

Midlifeflyer isn't disputing that, but your original post said a student and "certificated" pilot, rather than a CFI.
 
Midlifeflyer isn't disputing that, but your original post said a student and "certificated" pilot, rather than a CFI.
Hey, some people disagree with people they agree with.

Of course, I don't really buy that "back seat" story without knowing a lot, lot more about the situation.
 
I'm sure it's FSDO dependant then because in the event of a violation the FAA has violated the highest certificated pilot on board.
The FAA has. The FAA also has not.

On the other hand, "getting dinged" doesn't appear anywhere in 61.51 as a basis for logging flight time, approaches, currency, etc. Ever hear the true story of the two CFIs who said they gave each other instruction on every flight together so they could both log PIC? The result was two sets of certifciates revoked.
 
Back
Top