Scope and Medicine

C150J

Well-Known Member
As rough as our industry can be, I thought I'd cynically "re-assure" those in the trenches, as it turns out we aren't the only profession fighting to keep scope:

http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showthread.php?t=289278


To summarize, Nurse Practitioners are slowly encroaching on roles that only MDs dominated in the past. This will effect pay, and SOME argue quality of care (I have NO insight on that one, and don't mean to denigrate a NP's skill).

Just an FYI.

J.
 
scope-mouthwash-canada.jpg
 
From yet another thread. Sounds all too familiar!

"My prediction is that the first step after DNP will be DNP residency programs, tremendously weak watered down versions of what real doctors go thru. After that, you will see them start expanding the nursing scope laws. In less than 20 years, we will see at least one state nursing board write surgery into their scope of practice, defining it as "nursing" practice and ergo immune from any medical board interference."
 
On a parallel issue, my doctor here in Scottsdale is apparently a pilot and a great guy as I've heard.

But the last five or so visits to the Dr's office, I've never met the guy! :)

But the NP's tell me, "You ought to meet him, he's a pilot too and a great guy!"

Ok... Ok... :)
 
Definitely a sign of the times! I don't mean to infer that the level of care is inferior to that of a full-blown physician, but it surely makes you wonder what's driving this type of shift. I buy the growth due to the lack of primary care physicians, but the specialization of NPs makes me curious. Most physicians have been very complimentary when speaking about non-MD/DO clinicians, but the vast majority say "you don't know what you don't know" and are concerned about this trend.
 
Although not really related to scope, another profession that reminds me of regional airline pilots' predicaments is being a police officer in Pennsylvania, especially for a small department. You pay for the police academy THEN you get a part time job with a department if you can find one, sometimes more than one because they often pay very little. Oftentimes because of working multiple police jobs, you pull very long days with little rest and lots of stress. Then, in a few years, IF you're lucky, you get a full time position with benefits...at least until your department merges with another neighboring department or is eliminated altogether in an attempt to save money. I'm surprised more states aren't going this route but hopefully they don't. You might get lucky and get hired intially by a department such as Pittsburgh or Philadelphia and get paid training, but in Pennsylvania unlike other states, that's seemingly rare. Seems like "commuterization" is occurring in every industry. :whatever:
 
I now refuse to see NPs after I had a major issue with one. I had a horrible sinus infection, and went to the closest doc's office, but only an NP was available. She saw me and prescribed me some antibiotics that cause drowsiness. Big label right on the side that said not to operate heavy machinery. Well, I don't know about you, but I think a CRJ is a pretty heavy piece of machinery. I asked her for a note to give the company (since Pinnacle managers are a bunch of nazis), but she refused to give me one, saying that I should be fine to fly! I argued with her for a bit, and even asked her "would you really want to ride on a captain's flight if you knew he was taking medication that causes drowsiness," but she wouldn't even answer the question, and continued to refuse giving me a note. After that experience, I'm done with NPs. My doctor now isn't my AME, but he was a flight surgeon in the Air Force, and he knows better than to pull that crap.
 
I now refuse to see NPs after I had a major issue with one. I had a horrible sinus infection, and went to the closest doc's office, but only an NP was available. She saw me and prescribed me some antibiotics that cause drowsiness. Big label right on the side that said not to operate heavy machinery. Well, I don't know about you, but I think a CRJ is a pretty heavy piece of machinery. I asked her for a note to give the company (since Pinnacle managers are a bunch of nazis), but she refused to give me one, saying that I should be fine to fly! I argued with her for a bit, and even asked her "would you really want to ride on a captain's flight if you knew he was taking medication that causes drowsiness," but she wouldn't even answer the question, and continued to refuse giving me a note. After that experience, I'm done with NPs. My doctor now isn't my AME, but he was a flight surgeon in the Air Force, and he knows better than to pull that crap.

I have never had a nurse or doc refuse to give me a note. I mean seriously, how hard is it to sign your name on a pre-printed form that shows you were at the office? It's not like she's covering anything up. You WERE there. Not our fault management treats us like 6th graders and assumes we're playing hooky every time there's an "unplanned absence."
 
Same. I've had PA's and NP's write notes no problem (which doesn't matter because XJT won't accept them, but I always got it documented). I had a bunch of sinus infections and at one point a doctor thought I broke my wrist, and they told me in no uncertain terms I wasn't going back to work until THEY were sure that my wrist wasn't broken and I was out of a brace, and as such they kept writing notes (I also think they x-rayed the thing 15 times in a 2 week period).
 
Back
Top