Flying with Frankee

Shiner

El Capitan
I've got an interesting story to tell and I'd appreciate your thoughts and feedback.

I'm a private pilot with a recently acquired instrument rating with about 150 hours. Looking to build some time for the commercial certificate, I posted some fliers up at local airports offering to fly with people to split costs and build time. One pilot who called me was a guy named "Frankee".

Frankee told me he had logged over 150 hours and came close to taking his check ride, but had a circumstance that took him out of aviation. He recently purchased a small plane and was looking to get polished up for the check ride. He offered to let me fly his aircraft, and it was understood that he would get some stick time as well.

The first few flights were fine. I was familiar with the aircraft and at first Frankee flew sparingly. As our time progressed together, Frankee expected to do more and more of the flying. That's when things became very uncomfortable for me. It came to the point where Frankee was asking to take all of the takeoffs and landings. I allowed it, but would always be close at hand ready to take the aircraft. The problem was that all of a sudden I was playing the role of a CFI, and I was not comfortable. Especially because Frankee would not follow my suggestions on how to better fly approaches or takeoffs, and I would be forced to take the aircraft to make a safe takeoff/landing.

Today was Frankee and I's final flight together. We got very snippy with one another on both of our approaches. He likes to fly it in high and fast and just point the a/c down to the runway. I would explain to him that the proper way to fly was using pitch to control the airspeed and power to control decent rate. Despite my repeated instructions, he chose to fly his way and we had a couple of very hairy landings. It became clear to me that he did not respect my role as the PIC of the flight.

Our flying relationship came to an end when, on the way back to my car, we talk about our flight and our CRM, if you will. I let him know I was no longer willing to fly his aircraft unless I would fly all takeoffs and landings. He countered that there was no point in flying with me from now on because he needed his practice. I said that if he wanted practice he should hire a CFI so he could learn the proper way to fly. He proceeded to tell me that he already knew how to fly and that, despite is ugly landings, that was part of learning.

I guess I don't have any specific questions. I am a bit frustrated at how things got to this point. I realize I let things get out of hand and was not assertive enough. I really admire you CFI's out there. I am really looking forward to becoming one. Then again, I don't know what I'd do if I had a student like Frankee. It seems like a much harder job than I ever thought and I have mad respect. I'd appreciate any of your thoughts on the situation or being a CFI in general.
 
You should have never let him put you into a situation that you didnt feel comfortable in. I dont care if it was his airplane. You were the PIC and therefore you should have taken control and never let it get to the point you felt uncomfortable. Learn from it. Never let anyone put you in a situation you dont feel comfortable in.
 
Frankee would not follow my suggestions on how to better fly approaches or takeoffs

People are very sensitive to maintaining a perceived equality in a relationship, unless there is an explicit subordination established, such as between an instructor and student. Frankie apparently didn't perceive you to be his instructor and was offended when you treated him like a student. Not at all surprising.

Once you get the CFI, you will automatically be treated with some amount of deference just by having the title. Even so, more advanced students might be offended if your perception of their abilities is very different from their own. That situation must be approached with some delicacy. If the student gets the idea that you don't respect him, you've lost much of your ability to influence him in a positive way.
 
You should have never let him put you into a situation that you didnt feel comfortable in. I dont care if it was his airplane. You were the PIC and therefore you should have taken control and never let it get to the point you felt uncomfortable. Learn from it. Never let anyone put you in a situation you dont feel comfortable in.

:clap:Take what Inverted has told you and keep it in mind. You are not a trained CFI, and it is best if you aren't worried about wresting controls from this person.

This "Frankee" seems to have some very serious problems, and I'm not sure even a CFI could save him now. I've had some students myself where if I'm in the plane, perform and behave properly. The second I step out though, they are doing things however it is that they want to do them, then when I get in again, they cannot recall the appropriate way to land, stall, or perform some weird maneuver.
 
I would explain to him that the proper way to fly was using pitch to control the airspeed and power to control decent rate.

Stir the pot, baby yeah!

------

Once you get the certificate there will still be a Frankee or two out there but they largely go away. Basically just knock them down and if they are still lippy, send the yoker packing.
 
Back
Top