Question for regional pilots. (or mainline)

boondr

Penalty Vectorer
Short flight <30 mins, I can give you a shortcut that will cut 20+ miles off the trip or just leave you on the route. Do you want the shortcut? Does it depend on the situation? Is there a general rule I could follow?

Reason I have asked is I have seen it many ways, sometimes I get asked for the shortcut, sometimes I get told they would rather stay on the route. Other times I give a shortcut or a better altitude (IE 10,000 vs 8 or 9) and I am the coolest controller ever. And on the flip side sometimes I catch an attitude on the readback like I just pissed in their cereal.


So whats the deal you guys/gals want to milk the gate-to-gate time or you just want to get it done quick for some kind of bonus. I am all ears and open to suggestions.


Also lastly is there quick question I could ask to find out how they want it?
 
Probably depends on the situation, but 99.999% of the time I'll gleefully take a short cut!
 
I used to do some 20-30 minute hops in the regional jet out of Newark and found shortcuts weren't always favorable as you (the pilots) were already pressed for time to prepare the plane for landing (i.e. after T/O checklist, load approach, ATIS, cruise, in range checks, etc.). Said another way, you needed the extra 2-3 minutes just to make sure things were/are done right.
 
Us corporate/135 guys will take the shortcut if it cuts the trip time down, because less trip time = less fuel = less customer has to pay = happy customer = happy employer = happy crew.

:)
 
I guess I should state that my policy is as many shortcuts as possible in my airspace and as many as the next guy can handle for everyone. Because shorter trip=shorter time in my airspace=less work for me :cool:
The reason I asked this question is today I caught a bit of disappointment from a "Waterski" E145(TSA right?) when I gave a shortcut that would cut 25 miles off a 100 mile trip. He wasn't rude I just heard a little edge in the readback. I would have asked him except I was busy and this was a necessary shortcut as he was eating up a Saab 340 going on the same route.
 
Us corporate/135 guys will take the shortcut if it cuts the trip time down, because less trip time = less fuel = less customer has to pay = happy customer = happy employer = happy crew.

:)


Oh and because I am clueless part 135 is the Execjets, Options, Avantairs, Eljays etc of the world correct?
 
Depending on the type or airframe or even models within an airframe family, the crew may need that 20 miles for fuel burn so as to not land overweight.

Don't ask how I know. :o
 
Us corporate/135 guys will take the shortcut if it cuts the trip time down, because less trip time = less fuel = less customer has to pay = happy customer = happy employer = happy crew.

:)

i flew for a charter company that told us to reduce cruise speed so we could bill more hours. 95% in a citation II in cruise. lol, we called it "Sentient Power"
 
Short flight <30 mins, I can give you a shortcut that will cut 20+ miles off the trip or just leave you on the route. Do you want the shortcut? Does it depend on the situation? Is there a general rule I could follow?

Reason I have asked is I have seen it many ways, sometimes I get asked for the shortcut, sometimes I get told they would rather stay on the route. Other times I give a shortcut or a better altitude (IE 10,000 vs 8 or 9) and I am the coolest controller ever. And on the flip side sometimes I catch an attitude on the readback like I just pissed in their cereal.


So whats the deal you guys/gals want to milk the gate-to-gate time or you just want to get it done quick for some kind of bonus. I am all ears and open to suggestions.


Also lastly is there quick question I could ask to find out how they want it?

I believe they are paid by the flight hour. I will gladly take any shortcut you will give me.
 
I used to do some 20-30 minute hops in the regional jet out of Newark and found shortcuts weren't always favorable as you (the pilots) were already pressed for time to prepare the plane for landing (i.e. after T/O checklist, load approach, ATIS, cruise, in range checks, etc.). Said another way, you needed the extra 2-3 minutes just to make sure things were/are done right.

That's just because you were a newbie. Once you get time in the plane you can get everything done (be it RJ or 777) in 5 or so minutes of cruise/descent.

As far as the OP, as was said, it may depend on fuel loading. The CRJ is normally restricted by landing weight and that extra 20 miles may be the difference between getting to the airport right at Max Landing Weight and having to spin circles with the flaps out for a few minutes while the passengers in the back grumble that they can see the airport out the window and why aren't we landing.

There are enough people out there with no interpersonal skills that I guess you'll probably get some hissy fit readbacks if you offer a shortcut to a guy, but I would guess the vast majority of us appreciate the offer every time.
 
That's just because you were a newbie. Once you get time in the plane you can get everything done (be it RJ or 777) in 5 or so minutes of cruise/descent.


That's the truth... we used to give passengers PA's on our IAH-HOU run at "cruise" (3000' abeam downtown Houston.... yup, that's the Astrodome on the right, have you on the ground in less than a minute, thanks for flying with us today)

Re: shortcuts

Reasons to take them:
going home leg
you're already early, so mine as well be earlier
going home leg
saves gas
going home leg
save money
going home leg

Some reasons why we'd say no:
No gate
Already late, so milking the pay by the minute
Somebody else will get the call from scheduling if we show up late
Capt. is a company kool aid drinker and we got a time over fix message from the company
Not the going home leg
 
That's the truth... we used to give passengers PA's on our IAH-HOU run at "cruise" (3000' abeam downtown Houston.... yup, that's the Astrodome on the right, have you on the ground in less than a minute, thanks for flying with us today)

Re: shortcuts

Reasons to take them:
going home leg
you're already early, so mine as well be earlier
going home leg
saves gas
going home leg
save money
going home leg

Some reasons why we'd say no:
No gate
Already late, so milking the pay by the minute
Somebody else will get the call from scheduling if we show up late
Capt. is a company kool aid drinker and we got a time over fix message from the company
Not the going home leg


:D I suspected as much. Like I said I like giving shortcuts to everyone, but if it is going to be a problem I don't want to be taking money out of your pocket by trying to be nice. Hell last week I had 2 consequtive planes from an not to be named subsidiary-regional tell me they needed fifteen minutes of holding for fuel overage. I let them burn twenty mile vector-driven circles in my sky knowing the whole time there was a slim chance they had fifteen minutes of extra fuel from a 200 mile flight. If I have the airspace I'll give you guys delay vectors until my sup complains if you ask. Of course you should tell me that you are "overweight" so everything is kosher.

BTW do you get bonuses for being early?
 
I'm not aware of anyone who gets bonuses for being early. But being early allows you to pick up more flying, for example: you're scheduled for 28hrs in 7 days. you underblock and fly those 28 scheduled hours in 26 hours, now you can pick up a turn worth 4 hours of additional flying. then you go overblock and actually fly 26:01 - now that turn isn't legal and you're removed for a 30/7 conflict , but you're still paid the 4 hours for it.

There are some guys that game and work their schedule all the time.

Going overblock isn't as beneficial as going underblock and picking up more flying.

There are some airlines out there that don't pay any extra for going over - but there aren't any airlines that will pay you less for underblocking.

Me just personally, I'd rather get there as soon as I can, I'll take all the shortcuts.
 
I'm not aware of anyone who gets bonuses for being early. But being early allows you to pick up more flying, for example: you're scheduled for 28hrs in 7 days. you underblock and fly those 28 scheduled hours in 26 hours, now you can pick up a turn worth 4 hours of additional flying. then you go overblock and actually fly 26:01 - now that turn isn't legal and you're removed for a 30/7 conflict , but you're still paid the 4 hours for it.

There are some guys that game and work their schedule all the time.

Going overblock isn't as beneficial as going underblock and picking up more flying.

There are some airlines out there that don't pay any extra for going over - but there aren't any airlines that will pay you less for underblocking.

Me just personally, I'd rather get there as soon as I can, I'll take all the shortcuts.

You lost me with the under/overblock stuff but I think I get the drift, how 'bout I just ask "You up for a shortcut today?" and you tell me "hell yes" or "I rather be put in holding". Either way I comply?
 
Shortcuts! My company tends to block the flights at bare minimum times. 35 minutes BWI-LNS, 38 minutes LNS-BWI. That can be done, but it usually requires that we get on course pretty quickly. We pretty much rely on "Direct BWI" or "Direct LRP" in order to make it work. Not getting stuck on that 330 heading out of BWI makes our day. That controller is our best friend from then on. :D

Then again, we're paid by duty hours, not flight hours. We push to stay on the schedule, not try to milk for pay.
 
I try to get to my destination as fast as possible. Gas is cheap in light airplanes, maintenance is not. We're paid by the leg here, so if I can complete a leg in 18 minutes when I'm paid for 24, that's essentially getting free money.

Costs of Operation

Maintenance (hourly) + Flight Pay (kind of hourly for us) + Fuel (hourly burns) + Insurance (probably based on hours per year, idk) == TRY TO SHAVE OFF HOURS!
 
Shortcuts! My company tends to block the flights at bare minimum times. 35 minutes BWI-LNS, 38 minutes LNS-BWI. That can be done, but it usually requires that we get on course pretty quickly. We pretty much rely on "Direct BWI" or "Direct LRP" in order to make it work. Not getting stuck on that 330 heading out of BWI makes our day. That controller is our best friend from then on. :D

Then again, we're paid by duty hours, not flight hours. We push to stay on the schedule, not try to milk for pay.


yeah the problem with the 33R north/west departures is everything to the east until 10 DME belongs to someone else so it literally requires coordination with 3 other positions to go direct LRP on departure. Fairly easy to do when everyone is not busy but one "unable" and it is runway heading or 360 until 5000 AND 10 DME. I'll keep that in mind though, most of the time it isn't a problem unless 25.52 is busy in which case 5000 isn't the best place to be directly north/northeast of the field.
 
For the record, we've actually recieved requests from most major American Air Carriers to NOT give direct unless the pilot specifically asks for it, we're not even supposed to offer direct routings, they feel the airlines flight planning software knows better I guess....
 
Back
Top