Captain relieved of her command

Re: Captian relived of her comand.

Dunno - I have an EIB above my wings though. An EIB is a higher class badge so it always goes above the wings. I was enlisted first so maybe the O-6 was too.

Oh only reason I mentioned the EIB (which until a number of months ago, I'd never seen anything placed above wings, until you mentioned that).....the only reason I mention the EIB was due to the fact that he had the Infantry branch collar insignia; yet I always thought that if you wore wings, you were assigned to either Aviation branch or Med Services Corps?
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

Oh only reason I mentioned the EIB (which until a number of months ago, I'd never seen anything placed above wings, until you mentioned that).....the only reason I mention the EIB was due to the fact that he had the Infantry branch collar insignia; yet I always thought that if you wore wings, you were assigned to either Aviation branch or Med Services Corps?
Was he wearing ACUs? Besides a dress uniform we really don't wear anything that shows our branch anymore.

And if he wore something that showed an infantry branch, are you sure they were pilot wings and not crew member wings? (They are very similar).
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

Was he wearing ACUs? Besides a dress uniform we really don't wear anything that shows our branch anymore.

And if he wore something that showed an infantry branch, are you sure they were pilot wings and not crew member wings? (They are very similar).

Yes, he was in Class A. They could possibly have been crewmember wings, though I wasn't close enough to make out the shield on the center of them, so that's a possibility.

I've seen old school guys like this, back before aviation was a branch itself......you'd see the aviators as part of arty, infantry....one of the combat or even combat support branches. I just didn't think that was still the case today.
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

And whose to say she was "incompetent?" It's the Peter Principle. You rise to the level of your incompetence. She may have been a very fine junior officer who just finally rose her level of incompetence; the "bad behavior" emerged as a result of her frustation/stress/whatever of not being able to handle her new job" I have a hard time believing an truly incompetent officer could rise that high.

I dunno. I agree with the old observation that bad F/Os generally make bad Captains and bad Captains, if ever downgraded make TERRIBLE F/Os.

I've read quite a few books on leadership and decision making and have yet to come across one that suggests strong profanity, intimidation, abuse and screaming as good tools to use.

IF the picture of this Capt is correct, she makes Capt Queeg on the Caine look like a polished, effective leader.

Wonder if there were any strawberries missing?
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

Yes, he was in Class A. They could possibly have been crewmember wings, though I wasn't close enough to make out the shield on the center of them, so that's a possibility.

I've seen old school guys like this, back before aviation was a branch itself......you'd see the aviators as part of arty, infantry....one of the combat or even combat support branches. I just didn't think that was still the case today.

Okay - if he is currently branched infantry it is unlikely he was a pilot. In the old days it was possible.

And what's weird is that you would rarely see an active infantryman with an EIB these days. You would expect to see a CIB instead. If you looked at my uniform the EIB would make sense if you knew I was an aviator.
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

Okay - if he is currently branched infantry it is unlikely he was a pilot. In the old days it was possible.

And what's weird is that you would rarely see an active infantryman with an EIB these days. You would expect to see a CIB instead. If you looked at my uniform the EIB would make sense if you knew I was an aviator.

Yeah....the whole thing was kind of odd, but I only know just enough about Army uniforms to catch the possibility of weird stuff. Now, when it comes to a Marine or Navy uniform, I don't really know what's what. And USCG Class A/B uniforms just look like USAF uniforms with Navy insignia placed on them....:D
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

This...although Yeager is a nozzle, the sentiment is correct.

Bunk, is that Stockdale?

Funny about Yeager. Yes, Stockdale. Obviously two leaders (Olds/Stockdale) who earned their reputation under two very different circumstances. BTW, Olds memoirs are coming out 1 Apr, I'm very interested in reading them.
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

Some random thoughts...

What interests me about this is that, this kind of personality is somewhat encouraged in the military. Perhaps a better way to say it is that the military takes young men and women and actively trains, or at least contributes, to their being these kinds of tough, gung-ho, go-get-'em personalities. And I would imagine that there are times when that is exactly what is needed. But then everyone expects them to turn that off at the end of the day; we act surprised when they can't or don.t. I don't know, maybe the ability to turn it off an on is what makes a "well-rounded" soldier.

And whose to say she was "incompetent?" It's the Peter Principle. You rise to the level of your incompetence. She may have been a very fine junior officer who just finally rose her level of incompetence; the "bad behavior" emerged as a result of her frustation/stress/whatever of not being able to handle her new job" I have a hard time believing an truly incompetent officer could rise that high.

Also interesting to me is the emphasis on airmanship that many seem to value as the the most important qualification of rank. Certainly it's important, but it's not the end-all/be-all of competence. I have known many fine airmen that I wouldn't want anywhere near any kind of management position.

Here's the thing, one does not have to be a tyrant to be an effective leader. One does not have to be nice either. There is a line. The effective leaders can be tough, demanding but take care of their people at the end of the day. You don't have to like them but you can respect them. IMO, they must also possess the technical expertise to lead folks from the front. As far as aviation goes, that means from the cockpit. My last operational CO I mentioned earlier had about 2000 flight hours as CO....too many staff tours it seems. For example, my first few CO's were cockpit only types, when it was okay to do so had between 3500-5000 flight hours depending. My first operational CO broke 5000 hours as CO and your first filght in the squadron and to the boat was with him. At night to the boat, with him. He led from the cockpit. This low time CO came into OPS one day and said he was no longer flying to the boat with nuggets as he felt uncomfortable. I was in OPS (I was the training officer at the time) when he came in and told OPS as much. I heard it with my own ears. Are you kidding me? You're the f'ing CO, act like it. Lead from the front.

I knew another officer, a fine leader, flew C-130's out of Antartica for his first tour then became an E-2 pilot. He was one of the last officers to make O-5 when staying in the cockpit was okay. He had over 5000 flight hours when he retired. He was old school but damn, could lead from the front. Yeah, a heavy drinker, partier who broke his department heads thumb at a party for calling him out. However, if there was bad weather, a questionable plane, whatever, he would take the flight. I remember a dark night over Choctaw in P-cola where there were 3 E-2's and 2 C-2's in the pattern. The tower was trying to switch to the opposite runway, screwing up big time. Stacker's gruff voice came over the radio, took charge, made it easy. We all went drinking one night as a det and of course didn't designate a driver....all of us were drunk. He took care of it though I won't say how. He was a screen for a tyrant CO. He just had an uncanny ability to lead people and was one of the best sticks and ball flyer's I had ever seen. Granted he didn't drop bombs but he was one of those guys you would follow to hell knowing you weren't coming back. Yet he did not make command....a shame. Yet my last CO was a guy who didn't want to fly to the boat with nuggets. Rarely came out of his office...always on email...never spoke at safety standowns, etc. I bet he was one hell of a staff tour guy though :rolleyes:

On a side note, he earned the callsign "Stacker" due to a party antic he pulled as a JO. He decided it would be funny, while at a party, to have all the JO's take a dump at the O-4's house and not flush the toilet. Stack the if you will....thus the name Stacker.
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

Here's the thing, one does not have to be a tyrant to be an effective leader. One does not have to be nice either. There is a line. The effective leaders can be tough, demanding but take care of their people at the end of the day. You don't have to like them but you can respect them. IMO, they must also possess the technical expertise to lead folks from the front. As far as aviation goes, that means from the cockpit. My last operational CO I mentioned earlier had about 2000 flight hours as CO....too many staff tours it seems. For example, my first few CO's were cockpit only types, when it was okay to do so had between 3500-5000 flight hours depending. My first operational CO broke 5000 hours as CO and your first filght in the squadron and to the boat was with him. At night to the boat, with him. He led from the cockpit. This low time CO came into OPS one day and said he was no longer flying to the boat with nuggets as he felt uncomfortable. I was in OPS (I was the training officer at the time) when he came in and told OPS as much. I heard it with my own ears. Are you kidding me? You're the f'ing CO, act like it. Lead from the front.

I knew another officer, a fine leader, flew C-130's out of Antartica for his first tour then became an E-2 pilot. He was one of the last officers to make O-5 when staying in the cockpit was okay. He had over 5000 flight hours when he retired. He was old school but damn, could lead from the front. Yeah, a heavy drinker, partier who broke his department heads thumb at a party for calling him out. However, if there was bad weather, a questionable plane, whatever, he would take the flight. I remember a dark night over Choctaw in P-cola where there were 3 E-2's and 2 C-2's in the pattern. The tower was trying to switch to the opposite runway, screwing up big time. Stacker's gruff voice came over the radio, took charge, made it easy. We all went drinking one night as a det and of course didn't designate a driver....all of us were drunk. He took care of it though I won't say how. He was a screen for a tyrant CO. He just had an uncanny ability to lead people and was one of the best sticks and ball flyer's I had ever seen. Granted he didn't drop bombs but he was one of those guys you would follow to hell knowing you weren't coming back. Yet he did not make command....a shame. Yet my last CO was a guy who didn't want to fly to the boat with nuggets. Rarely came out of his office...always on email...never spoke at safety standowns, etc. I bet he was one hell of a staff tour guy though :rolleyes:

.

Very very similar to my experience, yet a different service. Which makes me believe that my experience isn't just USAF-specific, it's spread out across the services........this whole idea that being an ops guy/flyer used to be OK, but sometime in the mid-late 90's it no longer became hip, and if you didn't follow the rest of the clowns in the corporation called the US Military, you weren't fit to be promoted. And that's truly sad to me.

A CO not wanting to fly with nuggets because he's uncomfortable..........all I can say is wow.....just wow. WTF are you in command for then?
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

Very very similar to my experience, yet a different service. Which makes me believe that my experience isn't just USAF-specific, it's spread out across the services........this whole idea that being an ops guy/flyer used to be OK, but sometime in the mid-late 90's it no longer became hip, and if you didn't follow the rest of the clowns in the corporation called the US Military, you weren't fit to be promoted. And that's truly sad to me.

Crazy how the military has become...some folks don't care, doesn't bother them or they simply agree. Then of course, guess who gets promoted and carries on the same...

A CO not wanting to fly with nuggets because he's uncomfortable..........all I can say is wow.....just wow. WTF are you in command for then?

Yep. I hear he was one hell of staff weenie though and thus, obviously, would make a fine CO :crazy:
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

I dunno. I agree with the old observation that bad F/Os generally make bad Captains and bad Captains, if ever downgraded make TERRIBLE F/Os.

Perhaps so, but that does not mean that bad CA's were bad FO's. I've known a few people who were career FO's because they just couldn't make it as Captain. But that didn't take away from their ability to be an effective crewmember. I know a couple of guys who retired as 20+ year regional FO's because they didn't have what it took to be a CA. They knew it, and they respected their limitations.

In the case of this Navy Captain, I've not heard it said that she was a bad junior officer, just that she was a bad Commander. Unfortunately for her, the nature of the military does not seem to allow for staying in the job, and at the level, that you are most proficient at.
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

In the Army (very generally) if you become a PIC qualified for day/night and NVGs you are respected. Once you're a Major it's pretty common to expect they have senior wings (1000 hours of military flying) and by LTC you have master wings (2000 hours).

I was a fairly junior Navy Lieutenant (Army equivalent of Captain for the civilians) when I got off of active duty and I had just over 2000 hours...

Interesting how the services see things differently.


Kevin
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

I was a fairly junior Navy Lieutenant (Army equivalent of Captain for the civilians) when I got off of active duty and I had just over 2000 hours...

Interesting how the services see things differently.


Kevin

RW or FW?
Also, today things are a little different. A one year combat tour will get you 500-1000 hours of flight time in the Army.
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

I told him that I had come to this meeting not only to get promotion feedback, but I also wanted him to give me reasons why I should stay in the USAF, what with my Active Duty Service Committment being nearly up. Instead, he sealed the deal on why I should leave the corporation.

Funny how that happens on the O side of the house as well.

It's just more visible within the enlisted ranks.
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

A CO not wanting to fly with nuggets because he's uncomfortable..........all I can say is wow.....just wow. WTF are you in command for then?


Sad. Too many people are interested in being 'the boss' and not being 'a leader'.

Odd that they only make their job harder that way.
 
I would like to be the first to contradict many/any on this thread who believe her actions are an aberration as opposed to the norm. I think sometimes that far too many of that type of behavior slip through the crack, but it's definitely not the norm at least from what I've seen in the Army during my 25 years.

I will admit I've displayed those certain types of negative demeaning behavior on far too many occasions as well; however, that was never EVER the norm. Ironically, those tirades were usually levied at those less than stellar performers whom I perceived as non-team players or self-serving individuals. If you weren't genuinely striving to build teamwork or camaraderie with your subordinates, I would be slamming you. Subjective as the decision was to behave in that manner, sometimes I felt it was appropriate to "react in kind" to those demeaning, callous individuals to attempt to have them realize the problem of less than stellar subordinates WASN'T the subordinates, but their leader. Some got it; some didn't. If not, change tactics. Sometimes it helped; sometimes it didn't, but if not, their last evaluation had MY documentation enscribed with my belief I thought their leadership skills were lower than whale dung.

Someone dropped the ball severely in her case. The change of command incident when she left her destroyer was a glaring example of her having problems. Perhaps her family name indirectly attributed to her success without a black mark on her record. Can't say, but it's possible.

I do know that, as a sergeant major, which is the Navy equivalent of a Master Chief, behind closed doors, I would have cussed her out severely. Since making E6 (staff sergeant), I was told it was my responsibility to remind officers they manage soldiers, enlisted "lead" soldiers. A "time out" would have gotten threatened with bodily injury to change her ways. . .if the Master Chief is any substance of a leader.

. . .and I'm back to watching my DVD of "We We Soldiers."
 
Back
Top