CFI Initial and Bi-annual

sr71

Well-Known Member
So Does an CFI Initial Count as a Bi-annual Check? I've hear yes and No.
I don't believe it does because the CFI Certificate is a Instructor Certificate, where as the Bi-annual is for a pilot Certificate.

What is it?

Thanks
 
As said, they are two completely different things, just like a BFR does not make you instrument current.
 
I do agree with the two above posts. But I know a certain FSDO inspector that is absolutely furious over the Levy letter. If you can pass a CFI ride, then you can have a FR so he says.

And why shouldn't it. In the CFI PTS on page 5 it says

"the ability to demonstrate and simultaneously explain the key
elements of a TASK. The TASK demonstration must be to the​
COMMERCIAL PILOT skill level
2"


So essentially, if you go outside of tolerance in the Commercial PTS, you just busted your check ride.

Since this is in the PTS, I think we should all write Ms. MacPherson and either have the quoted above removed from the PTS, since I have seen people bust CFI rides for no meeting commercial standards, or have a CFI ride count as a Flight review (minus the II).

What sayith you? The reason I bring up a letter writing campaign is because I am sick of this issue being brought up all the time with all of the confusion surrounding it.
 
I've met more than one examiner that would sign off for a flight review after the completion of a check-ride. All you gotta do is ask.
 
I do agree with the two above posts. But I know a certain FSDO inspector that is absolutely furious over the Levy letter. If you can pass a CFI ride, then you can have a FR so he says.

And why shouldn't it. In the CFI PTS on page 5 it says

"the ability to demonstrate and simultaneously explain the key
elements of a TASK. The TASK demonstration must be to the​
COMMERCIAL PILOT skill level
2"


So essentially, if you go outside of tolerance in the Commercial PTS, you just busted your check ride.

Since this is in the PTS, I think we should all write Ms. MacPherson and either have the quoted above removed from the PTS, since I have seen people bust CFI rides for no meeting commercial standards, or have a CFI ride count as a Flight review (minus the II).

What sayith you? The reason I bring up a letter writing campaign is because I am sick of this issue being brought up all the time with all of the confusion surrounding it.

Nothing says the examiner can't sign off the check ride as a flight review- it is just not automatic. You need to let him/her know up front. Just another endorsement that takes what... one minute? I don't agree with the interpretation, but I've got bigger fish to fry so I'll live with it.
 
Also, if you're ready for a CFI checkride, you should know it's biennial (which means once every two years) as opposed to biannual (which means twice a year).

And check 61.56. It's now a "Flight Review." No biennial mentioned.
 
I do agree with the two above posts. But I know a certain FSDO inspector that is absolutely furious over the Levy letter. If you can pass a CFI ride, then you can have a FR so he says.

And why shouldn't it. In the CFI PTS on page 5 it says

"the ability to demonstrate and simultaneously explain the key
elements of a TASK. The TASK demonstration must be to the​
COMMERCIAL PILOT skill level
2"


So essentially, if you go outside of tolerance in the Commercial PTS, you just busted your check ride.

Since this is in the PTS, I think we should all write Ms. MacPherson and either have the quoted above removed from the PTS, since I have seen people bust CFI rides for no meeting commercial standards, or have a CFI ride count as a Flight review (minus the II).

What sayith you? The reason I bring up a letter writing campaign is because I am sick of this issue being brought up all the time with all of the confusion surrounding it.
Why would you want that removed? All is says is that when you demonstrate a maneuver as an instructor, you need to be able to do the maneuver to commercial standards. Makes sense to me without having to extrapolate it beyond what it says.

But I guess if you look hard enough for a reason to object to something you don't like, you can usually find it.
 
Why would you want that removed? All is says is that when you demonstrate a maneuver as an instructor, you need to be able to do the maneuver to commercial standards. Makes sense to me without having to extrapolate it beyond what it says.

I think the point being made was that if the FAA doesn't deem a CFI ride as a "proficiency check" or is not "primarily focused on piloting skills" then why have the commercial standards in the PTS.
 
I think the point being made was that if the FAA doesn't deem a CFI ride as a "proficiency check" or is not "primarily focused on piloting skills" then why have the commercial standards in the PTS.
You can just as easily make the point that since a CFI requires a commercial certificate, who isn't he also required to have a 2nd class medical (instead of none or at most a 3d class).

The point isn't very sharp in either case. What is the teacher applicant supposed to do? Keep bank within 80° of target when doing steep turns?
 
Also, if you're ready for a CFI checkride, you should know it's biennial (which means once every two years) as opposed to biannual (which means twice a year).

And check 61.56. It's now a "Flight Review." No biennial mentioned.

I understand the title of 61.56 is "Flight Review", but aren't you splitting hairs to say it's not a Biennial Flight Review. Is it better to say a Flight Review, done biennially. I have never read the entire regulation, so maybe there is a valid reason in there to drop the "biennial" part, all I know is I have to get one every other year.

I do agree though, I hate seeing, and hearing "biannual flight review." I even saw it in a letter from the airport where I used to fly at. They wanted a copy of everyone's "biannual." I'd like to meet the pilot that goes above and beyond, and gets them, without having too, twice per year
 
I understand the title of 61.56 is "Flight Review", but aren't you splitting hairs to say it's not a Biennial Flight Review. Is it better to say a Flight Review, done biennially. I have never read the entire regulation, so maybe there is a valid reason in there to drop the "biennial" part, all I know is I have to get one every other year.

I do agree though, I hate seeing, and hearing "biannual flight review." I even saw it in a letter from the airport where I used to fly at. They wanted a copy of everyone's "biannual." I'd like to meet the pilot that goes above and beyond, and gets them, without having too, twice per year

Actually, I tell new private pilots that they really should get two a year for the first year or two, then one a year and they should be with different instructors and learning different things. After all, airline pilots flying 75+ hours a month do some event every six months, yet we tell GA pilots who might fly on an irregular basis that they only need an event every two years. Could be part of the reason GA has a horrible accident rate when compared to 135/121. This is especially true of newly certified pilots who really need to see a CFI sooner than the 2 year mark after a check ride.
 
I understand the title of 61.56 is "Flight Review", but aren't you splitting hairs to say it's not a Biennial Flight Review. Is it better to say a Flight Review, done biennially. I have never read the entire regulation, so maybe there is a valid reason in there to drop the "biennial" part, all I know is I have to get one every other year.

I do agree though, I hate seeing, and hearing "biannual flight review." I even saw it in a letter from the airport where I used to fly at. They wanted a copy of everyone's "biannual." I'd like to meet the pilot that goes above and beyond, and gets them, without having too, twice per year

The regulation used to say "Biennial Flight Review" and now says "Flight Review." The reasoning behind the change (as it was explained to me) was the FAA wanted to get people out of the "every two years" mindset and do more proficiency training instead of the minimum. (insert commercial for WINGS)

I don't bust everyone's chops over the FR vs BFR. However, if you're a CFI or going to be a CFI soon, you really should know the regs. And the FAA doesn't call it a BFR anymore.

As far as biannual vs biennial, all I can hope to do is educate my students and other CFIs I know about not making this mistake. I can't fix everyone's stupid , not even my own sometimes. (Hell, I give primary flight instruction. That proves my stupid, right?)
 
You can just as easily make the point that since a CFI requires a commercial certificate, who isn't he also required to have a 2nd class medical (instead of none or at most a 3d class).

As far as the medical goes the reason for no 2nd is because a CFI is not making money as a Commercial Pilot, but rather an Instructor. Not really relevant when talking about a Practical exam being a proficiency check.

The point isn't very sharp in either case. What is the teacher applicant supposed to do? Keep bank within 80° of target when doing steep turns?

Simply put, if the FAA doesn't believe a CFI ride is not a "proficiency check," then why have the candidate fly to a set of standards which in itself shows a high level of proficiency.

If it truly is based on instructional capability then take the Commercial Standards out of the PTS, have the DPE fly the entire ride and the CFI take the controls to demonstrate or recover, and have the applicant actually instructing the whole flight.
 
As far as the medical goes the reason for no 2nd is because a CFI is not making money as a Commercial Pilot, but rather an Instructor. Not really relevant when talking about a Practical exam being a proficiency check.



Simply put, if the FAA doesn't believe a CFI ride is not a "proficiency check," then why have the candidate fly to a set of standards which in itself shows a high level of proficiency.

If it truly is based on instructional capability then take the Commercial Standards out of the PTS, have the DPE fly the entire ride and the CFI take the controls to demonstrate or recover, and have the applicant actually instructing the whole flight.

I don't think anyone here disagrees with that point. I think it's more the FAA reg for a Flight Review (61.56(d)) "A person who has, [within the last 24 calendar months], passed a pilot proficiency check...for a pilot certificate, rating, or operating privilege need not accomplish the flight review..." [emphasis added]

The flight instructor checkride is not a pilot proficiency check for a pilot certificate or rating. It's a proficiency check for an instructor certificate or rating.

I won't disagree with you as to the skill level you are supposed to demonstrate on a CFI ride. However, the regulations are actually pretty clear on this one, and my instructor certificate, although linked to my commercial certificate, is not a pilot certificate.
 
Simply put, if the FAA doesn't believe a CFI ride is not a "proficiency check," then why have the candidate fly to a set of standards which in itself shows a high level of proficiency.
Even more simply put, because he's supposed to be teaching it to others.

You're trying to create an issue where none exists just because you'd like a different result. That's fine. It's called jailhouse lawyering in another context. We all do it. Ever hear nosehair's theory that a pilot receiving training who is only person in the airplane whose hands and feet are on the controls is not really the "sole manipulator of the controls" and therefore can't log PIC time, unless the CFI next to him agrees to it?

As far as the medical goes the reason for no 2nd is because a CFI is not making money as a Commercial Pilot, but rather an Instructor.
And you buy that little piece of fiction and not that an instructor certificate is not a pilot certificate?
 
This entire thing is silly. It's taken care of with a simple statement prior to the checkride. "Sir/mam, would you mind having this count as my flight review as well?" After a short discussion with the incredulous examiner as to why it does not count as a flight review (bonus points for you for knowing the regulations better than the examiner and having the suporting documents to prove it), they will probably laugh and assure you that they will have no problem signing off your flight review in the event of a successful outcome. Problem solved.
 
Back
Top