Shameful BA Seeks to Continue Race and Age Discrimination

derg

Apparently a "terse" writer
Staff member
Thoughts?

Shameful BA Seeks to Continue Race and Age Discrimination

Press Release Source: Unite the Union On Monday March 1, 2010, 2:23 am

LONDON, March 1, 2010 /PRNewswire/ -- Unite the Union has today (Monday) denounced British Airways for moving to overturn a recent ruling which said it must apply UK law to its Hong Kong-based female cabin crew.

The crew's union says BA's moves are a shameful attempt to persist with its policy of dismissing its female Hong Kong cabin crew at 45 years of age - and can continue to discriminate against its employees on both age and race grounds.

In January this year the Employment Appeals Tribunal (EAT) upheld an Employment Tribunal 2008 ruling that the airline was wrong to claim that the women's Hong Kong nationality excluded them from the jurisdiction of UK employment law. Unite urged BA then to respect that judgement and move swiftly to end the discriminatory practices, however the airline has now said it will contest the EAT ruling at the Court of Appeal.

Unite national officer for civil aviation Steve Turner, said: "BA's continued mistreatment of these women is shameful. We have appealed to BA not to throw money at expensive lawyers so that they can squirm out of their obligations, but to instead respect the tribunal's wishes that these workers are covered by UK employment law and as such must not be discriminated against on any grounds, including their race or age.

"By continuing to fight this, BA is seeking to carry on treating a group of its workers as second class. This reflects very badly on BA as an employer but it also does profound damage to our country's reputation overseas to have our national carrier scrapping in court to ensure it can sack female workers at 45.

"BA should think again about the damage it is doing to its reputation, as well as the tremendous waste incurred in throwing skilled workers on the scrapheap when they still have years of service to give the airline."

Unite took the case to the EAT on behalf of one stewardess, Eliza Mak, and 16 colleagues. Eliza received her dismissal letter from BA when she turned 45, despite having worked for the airline since 1988.

BA dismisses its female Hong Kong crew when they turn 45 and denies them a pension, claiming its UK employment provisions do not apply to this workforce. Unlike their counterparts in the UK who retire with a pension at 60, the Hong Kong crew women are forced out of their jobs 15 years early and with only a one-off payment of a few thousand pounds on which to support themselves and their families.

Unite has been pushing for BA to accept that all its employees, wherever they may reside, should be covered by the company's employment agreements, including retirement age and pension rights. The January EAT ruling would allow those crew dismissed at 45 by BA to have their claims for discrimination heard in the UK courts.
 
Re: Shameful BA Seeks to Continue Race and Age Discriminatio

Is this a job available? Read the sticky, I'm not going to have to tell you again. :D
 
Re: Shameful BA Seeks to Continue Race and Age Discriminatio

Is this a job available? Read the sticky, I'm not going to have to tell you again. :D

Damn, you beat me to it!!!!!!!!!!

We'll have to ask the original message poster to please abide by the rules of the forum. Meantime I will promptly report this infraction to the webmaster.


:D:D
 
Re: Shameful BA Seeks to Continue Race and Age Discriminatio

Cue the righties with their "well they knew what they were getting into when they took the job" crap in 3...2...1...
 
Re: Shameful BA Seeks to Continue Race and Age Discriminatio

BA would be foolish to pursue this, they should back off and let them have their jobs back. What century is this anyway? SHAME ON BA! SHAME! Sounds like Mesa having their flight attendants work 18 hour days, SHAME. These companies must be checked.

Who is in a position to do it? Not the guy at the regional with a wife and young kid to feed. Leadership is required from the "major" carriers pilots, to check these illegal and immoral business practices. Without these pilots the companies make NO money. Withhold your labor. Defend the profession, defend the dignity of your coworkers and fellow pilots.

TOS
 
Re: Shameful BA Seeks to Continue Race and Age Discriminatio

Cue the righties with their "well they knew what they were getting into when they took the job" crap in 3...2...1...

Now how is that a rightie thing? I could see that being said from either side.
 
Re: Shameful BA Seeks to Continue Race and Age Discriminatio

@ the article quoted:

How is what BA doing any different than what goes on in the ME, and Africa. Write some articles about that I say to the writer of this one. Until then, ZZzZzzZzzz

That's the real world. Glad I live in a nice, safe, sugar coated, lollipop land protected by the world's finest military.
 
Re: Shameful BA Seeks to Continue Race and Age Discriminatio

Are male FAs released at 45 or is it just females? If it's guys and gals I don't see how that's much different than the government forcing airlines to dismiss pilots at 65.
 
Re: Shameful BA Seeks to Continue Race and Age Discriminatio

I'm not a lawyer but:

1) Age 65 is government mandated
2) The purpose of the age restriction is, purportedly, due to capability to do the job / medical factors.
3) It seems to me that this is not the purpose of sacking someone at age 45.
4) If a private company instituted an age 65 rule across the board, regardless of the reasons, it would likely be illegal (at least in the USA.)
 
Re: Shameful BA Seeks to Continue Race and Age Discriminatio

If we sacked our FAs at 45, we would have about 4 FAs left here.
 
Re: Shameful BA Seeks to Continue Race and Age Discriminatio

I'm not a lawyer but:

1) Age 65 is government mandated
2) The purpose of the age restriction is, purportedly, due to capability to do the job / medical factors.
3) It seems to me that this is not the purpose of sacking someone at age 45.
4) If a private company instituted an age 65 rule across the board, regardless of the reasons, it would likely be illegal (at least in the USA.)

My point exactly. Age discrimination is okay as long as it's government mandated, which is BS.
 
Re: Shameful BA Seeks to Continue Race and Age Discriminatio

It is legal, whether or not it is "OK" is not something I went into. Considering it is the government who makes laws I wouldn't think you would be surprised. The government is exempted from a number of laws.
 
Re: Shameful BA Seeks to Continue Race and Age Discriminatio

My point exactly. Age discrimination is okay as long as it's government mandated, which is BS.

I don't know a thing about this subject, but I can nearly assure you that it's much more complex than this.
 
Re: Shameful BA Seeks to Continue Race and Age Discriminatio

Train, ask one of your professors about Supreme Court rulings dealing with safety-sensitive functions and mandatory retirements. It's not that the government is exempt from age discrimination laws, it's that certain positions are safety-sensitive and require someone of able mind and body to perform the job. The Supreme Court has ruled on this several times. I believe the first case dealt with either firefighters or air traffic controllers, but I can't remember for sure.
 
Re: Shameful BA Seeks to Continue Race and Age Discriminatio

There is a difference between the Supreme Court "ruling" and refusing to grant certiorari. The latter doesn't necessarily mean they agree with the lower court ruling. It just means they declined to hear the case.
 
Re: Shameful BA Seeks to Continue Race and Age Discriminatio

There is a difference between the Supreme Court "ruling" and refusing to grant certiorari. The latter doesn't necessarily mean they agree with the lower court ruling. It just means they declined to hear the case.

Which also means that the lower court ruling stands, giving the same end result as the supreme court affirming the lower court decision.
 
Re: Shameful BA Seeks to Continue Race and Age Discriminatio

No, not true. It just means they let it stand. It doesn't mean they "agree with" it.

Remember, the Supreme Court hears limited amounts of cases--only a fraction of those appealed before the court--usually between 100-150 of more than 7,000 each year. Usually it's because there are conflicting appellatte decisions, there might be national significance or could have precedential value.

So, I stand by my point that the Supreme Court never ruled that age discrimination was ok. They just never agreed to hear a case and make a decision.
 
Re: Shameful BA Seeks to Continue Race and Age Discriminatio

No, not true. It just means they let it stand. It doesn't mean they "agree with" it.

In effect, it does. If the supreme court wants to untangle an issue, they'll take it up. Otherwise, they let the lower court decisions stand. The supreme court doesn't always have a problem with having splits among the appellate courts.


Remember, the Supreme Court hears limited amounts of cases--only a fraction of those appealed before the court--usually between 100-150 of more than 7,000 each year. Usually it's because there are conflicting appellatte decisions, there might be national significance or could have precedential value.

Exactly.

So, I stand by my point that the Supreme Court never ruled that age discrimination was ok. They just never agreed to hear a case and make a decision.

Meaning that you have a de facto decision.

Clients don't care how you get the decision, just that you get it. Winning and losing are all that matter, not splitting hairs about how it happened.
 
Re: Shameful BA Seeks to Continue Race and Age Discriminatio

Go ask your professors. I'm done trying to explain how the Supreme Court works and done with this discussion.
 
Back
Top