Deficient Areas Of The Knowledge Test

jhugz

Well-Known Member
Just got word from our FSDO that instructors have been getting violated just on the deficient areas of the knowledge test endorsement. They are telling us to not only sign the endorsement but to also make an entry in the logbook as follows:

12/9/09 1 hr of GND over the deficient areas of NAME OF PILOT's knowledge test section (blah, blah, blah, blah, blah).

Joe Blow 9999999CFI 9/99

Just lookin' out
 
Just got word from our FSDO that instructors have been getting violated just on the deficient areas of the knowledge test endorsement. They are telling us to not only sign the endorsement but to also make an entry in the logbook as follows:

12/9/09 1 hr of GND over the deficient areas of NAME OF PILOT's knowledge test section (blah, blah, blah, blah, blah).

Joe Blow 9999999CFI 9/99

Just lookin' out

Curious, which FSDO is this out of? Also, I know that my examiner DID write down each of the codes prior to starting the checkride.
 
All the examiners here in KY are looking for that. Since you ARE endorsing that you trained them on the deficient areas, they want the documentation. Anything for them to stay busy, especially when not as many people are out flying.
 
Just got word from our FSDO that instructors have been getting violated just on the deficient areas of the knowledge test endorsement. They are telling us to not only sign the endorsement but to also make an entry in the logbook as follows:

12/9/09 1 hr of GND over the deficient areas of NAME OF PILOT's knowledge test section (blah, blah, blah, blah, blah).

Joe Blow 9999999CFI 9/99

Just lookin' out
Why do they want CFIs to sign their names as "Joe Blow"?
 
Are they considering the signed knowledge test report enough? It pretty much states exactly what you would put in the logbook.
 
The regs do say that we are supposed to log both flight and ground training.

I've been trying to get better at keeping track and logging it in better detail for my students. They are paying for it after all!
 
I have not ran into a FSDO or DPE that cares. NC, NE, IA.

Just more BS and another example that 61.65E is a yoke.
 
Just got word from our FSDO that instructors have been getting violated just on the deficient areas of the knowledge test endorsement.

I wouldn't taunt the tiger, but I would certainly think the FSDO would have a heck of a difficult time finding an applicable regulation under which to violate the instructor, getting the lawyers to agree to take the case, and then making it stick in court. However, I have seen an instructor receive a 44709 reexamination for incorrect endorsements. It happened after the instructor had been told in a friendly way a couple times and continued to do it incorrectly.
 
I wouldn't taunt the tiger, but I would certainly think the FSDO would have a heck of a difficult time finding an applicable regulation under which to violate the instructor, getting the lawyers to agree to take the case, and then making it stick in court. However, I have seen an instructor receive a 44709 reexamination for incorrect endorsements. It happened after the instructor had been told in a friendly way a couple times and continued to do it incorrectly.

You could be correct, just passing it down the pipeline.
 
I think they do have a valid point, but it is a bit ticky tacky. 61.51 requires the ground training towards the certificate to be logged. Since you are endorsing that you covered the deficient areas, there should be a log of the ground training.
 
I think they do have a valid point, but it is a bit ticky tacky. 61.51 requires the ground training towards the certificate to be logged. Since you are endorsing that you covered the deficient areas, there should be a log of the ground training.

I was thinking this regulation would be the one that would apply.

Sec. 61.189 - Flight instructor records.
(a) A flight instructor must sign the logbook of each person to whom that instructor has given flight training or ground training.
 
Slightly off topic. Would an instructor need to log ground training for someone who as graduated from an approved ground course? I read it as the instructor must log all the ground covered to meet the knowledge areas in 61. If they cover that in a 141 ground school then is the instructor providing ground training or is he just reviewing?
 
Slightly off topic. Would an instructor need to log ground training for someone who as graduated from an approved ground course? I read it as the instructor must log all the ground covered to meet the knowledge areas in 61. If they cover that in a 141 ground school then is the instructor providing ground training or is he just reviewing?

The 141 ground instructor could cover the endorsement for the written test. The endorsement for 61.39 would depend on who gave the additional instruction on the knowledge areas found deficient and then found the applicant proficient.

Another big misunderstanding is that 61.39 requires 3 hours of flight training within 60 days. It only requires flight training withing the preceding 60 days (which could in theory be .1 hours).

However, most initial certificates require 3 hours within the preceding 60 days (pvt, IFR, Com etc). but, most add on ratings do NOT require the 3 hours, such as adding single commercial privileges to a commercial multi certificate.
 
I thought this endorsement was only required if they failed the knowledge test and had to retake it.

61.39(a)6
"Have an endorsement, if required by this part, in the applicant's logbook or training record that has been signed by an authorized instructor who certifies that the applicant—..."

"(iii) Has demonstrated satisfactory knowledge of the subject areas in which the applicant was deficient on the airman knowledge test"
 
I thought this endorsement was only required if they failed the knowledge test and had to retake it.

61.39(a)6
"Have an endorsement, if required by this part, in the applicant's logbook or training record that has been signed by an authorized instructor who certifies that the applicant—..."

"(iii) Has demonstrated satisfactory knowledge of the subject areas in which the applicant was deficient on the airman knowledge test"

That endorsement is for all practical test applicants where a knowledge test is required.

This one is for retesting.



Sec. 61.49 - Retesting after failure.

(a) An applicant for a knowledge or practical test who fails that test may reapply for the test only after the applicant has received:

(1) The necessary training from an authorized instructor who has determined that the applicant is proficient to pass the test; and

(2) An endorsement from an authorized instructor who gave the applicant the additional training.
 
I thought this endorsement was only required if they failed the knowledge test and had to retake it.

61.39(a)6
"Have an endorsement, if required by this part, in the applicant's logbook or training record that has been signed by an authorized instructor who certifies that the applicant—..."

"(iii) Has demonstrated satisfactory knowledge of the subject areas in which the applicant was deficient on the airman knowledge test"

Correct. The bolded bit could be left out but either (i) or (ii) requires that the endorsement also reads something to the effect of "has received flight training within the preceding 60 days..."
 
Back
Top