small turn coord question.

deek

New Member
What is so special about 3 degrees or 2 min turns that made it a standard and worthy of a little thin white line on the dial? I'm just trying to hear "The rest of the story".
 
What is so special about 3 degrees or 2 min turns that made it a standard and worthy of a little thin white line on the dial? I'm just trying to hear "The rest of the story".

I don't think it is so much that it is "special." But I would suspect it has more to do with a humans physiological resistance to spatial disorientation. This is a complete guess. But I would assume that it is the steepest possible bank that yields an acceptable percentage chance of not getting disoriented. We all know that it is safer to have a less steep bank in IMC because of its effect on our inner ear.
 
I don't think it is so much that it is "special." But I would suspect it has more to do with a humans physiological resistance to spatial disorientation. This is a complete guess. But I would assume that it is the steepest possible bank that yields an acceptable percentage chance of not getting disoriented. We all know that it is safer to have a less steep bank in IMC because of its effect on our inner ear.

But the bank angle changes based on speed, ever done a standard rate at about 200 knots... Helluva lot of bank...
 
What is so special about 3 degrees or 2 min turns that made it a standard and worthy of a little thin white line on the dial? I'm just trying to hear "The rest of the story".

It's not too special....larger aircraft have 4 minute turn coordinators because the bank angle to achieve a two minute turn would be excessive. As far as I know, the only significance behind the particular rate chosen is its convenience in computing timed turns.
 
What is so special about 3 degrees or 2 min turns that made it a standard and worthy of a little thin white line on the dial? I'm just trying to hear "The rest of the story".

The 2 (or 4) minute turn gives you easy math if you are no gyro flying off a wet compass (ie using your basic instrument skills in an emergency). I don't know the "whole story" but it is just an easy to use reference, and at most airspeeds the 2 or 4 min standard turn yields a comfortable turn.
 
For what?? I was responding to your post....

Faster aircraft use 4 minute TC so they are not at excessive banks. My point, like I said only a guess/opinion, was that when these 2/4 min TC's were designed it had something to do with physiological limitations. Find the maximum speed an aircraft flies, check its bank angle at that speed for a 2 minute turn, is it within an acceptable limit? If yes, put in the 2 min TC, if no, put in the 4 min. Like I said though, only an opinion, it seems logical/sensible in my head, to check human limitations when designing an instrument.
 
Faster aircraft use 4 minute TC so they are not at excessive banks. My point, like I said only a guess/opinion, was that when these 2/4 min TC's were designed it had something to do with physiological limitations. Find the maximum speed an aircraft flies, check its bank angle at that speed for a 2 minute turn, is it within an acceptable limit? If yes, put in the 2 min TC, if no, put in the 4 min. Like I said though, only an opinion, it seems logical/sensible in my head, to check human limitations when designing an instrument.

OK, I misunderstood what you were trying to say then in your first post. I was just pointing out that rate is not associated with a specific bank...
 
In the ATC/IFR system, the FAA has to set a standard for controllers and pilots alike so that when a controller says "fly heading 320" The pilot and the controller both know at what minimum rate the pilot will need to turn at. This could be especially useful for controllers vectoring people for traffic avoidance purposes.

ie converging contacts = when should I turn them away to keep em safe and to minimize delay!
 
Here's what I think:

In the early days of flying, I think the standard rate turn was developed so that pilots flying in weather would have a way to determine heading based on time. (I.E. if I turn to the right from 360 for 60 seconds my new heading will be 180.)

I also think that with airspeed changes they we able to formulate the appropriate bank angle for a specific speed with this formula:

Bank Angle= [TAS / 10]+5

I think it has to do with determining the amount of time it takes to make a 360 degree turn at a given angle of bank.

If that makes sense...
 
Back
Top