Icing

The FAA did change their stance so flying through a cloud when the temp is below 0 isn't technically flying into known ice conditions anymore.

No, they didn't change their stance. They refined their interpretation of known icing conditions.

http://www.aerolegalservices.com/Articles/2009-01-16%20Known%20Icing%20Legal%20Interpretation.pdf

"Pilots should not expose themselves or others to the risk associated with flying into conditions in which ice is likely to adhere to an aircraft"
I'm sure we all learned in 3rd grade science class that clouds are made of water and water freezes at 0*C. Seems pretty clear cut to me what the FAA means by that statement.
 
No IMC below +10 C sounds a little conservative.

I enjoyed your story above. Just wanted to point out that above conservative approach will shut the doors to non-certified IFR GA in western NY and New England for 6-8 months of the year.

Which is why most sensible people keep their planes parked when there is even a conservative chance of ice. I'd watch those rubber tires (no fairings) for any ice, run like hell if you see the front of the tire get a little frosty.
 
Picked it up 3 times in a C172, light rime all 3 times, I was able to get out of it very quickly.

My friend picked up a ton of ice on his 172, I saw pictures, there was a lot of clear on the prop. It was just him and half tanks, he had to use full power to maintain the GS.

Another school picked up about 1.5 inches on their Piper, flew just fine.

I have a powerpoint I just put together to teach a bunch of student pilots, I could email it to ya.

Kind of macho attitude that gets pilots killed.
 
I'd watch those rubber tires (no fairings) for any ice, run like hell if you see the front of the tire get a little frosty.

OAT probe that pokes through the windshield is the first place you'll see it on the Pipers.
 
No, they didn't change their stance. They refined their interpretation of known icing conditions.

http://www.aerolegalservices.com/Articles/2009-01-16%20Known%20Icing%20Legal%20Interpretation.pdf

I'm sure we all learned in 3rd grade science class that clouds are made of water and water freezes at 0*C. Seems pretty clear cut to me what the FAA means by that statement.

No no. Go back and read that B/CA article again. The author's big thing was the fact that 0C isn't the freezing point of water, it's the melting point of ice! And thus, the discussion goes into super cooled liquid droplets (SLD).

Good stuff, but a lot of those guys write way over my head too.

I wound up giving my copy to a guy sitting next to me on an Airtran flight the other night. I felt like he was was reading over my shoulder, he seemed to like that Pete Agur article on private jet justification. Turned out to be a pilot-owner in the insurance business based in Williamsburg. Small world huh?
 
No no. Go back and read that B/CA article again. The author's big thing was the fact that 0C isn't the freezing point of water, it's the melting point of ice! And thus, the discussion goes into super cooled liquid droplets (SLD).

Good point. I forgot about that.
 
<object width="425" height="344"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/_ifKduc1hE8&hl=en&fs=1&"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/_ifKduc1hE8&hl=en&fs=1&" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="425" height="344"></embed></object>

NASA makes a great Icing video. The best I have ever seen.

This youtube video is only a portion of it.

I think it was perfect for a guy in my shoes wanting to learn more before experiencing more. It sounds like you are in those shoes too. :beer:
 
I've read numerous articles on icing and also took a look at the asf's course today.
Don't forget that the guy with the Cirrus 22 was late to depart, by about 35 minutes. He was facing darkness, mountains and low time in actual IMC. On top of that, on the departure frequency, a SWA 737 was picking up rime at 17.5K.

I wonder if I would think in that situation to get an updated weather briefing?? This guy wanted to get home before the bad weather the next day!!

:(
 
I wonder if I would think in that situation to get an updated weather briefing?? This guy wanted to get home before the bad weather the next day!!

"Dear weather,

Please don't throw me any curve balls, as I am unprepared, unequipped and running late. A free pass would be greatly appreciated.

Sincerely,
Me"

In other words, the weather doesn't give a crap about the circumstances.
 
"Dear weather,

Please don't throw me any curve balls, as I am unprepared, unequipped and running late. A free pass would be greatly appreciated.

Sincerely,
Me"

In other words, the weather doesn't give a crap about the circumstances.

:clap:
 
The Piper flew just fine with 1.5"? What is your definition of fine? At what angle of attack would it stall? What speed would that equate to in straight and level flight? What are the characteristics of such a stall? What are the indications of such a stall? Would it stall at the tips first? The root? Would the ailerons be effective into the stall?

Nope. Don't screw around with ice in non-certified airplanes. Nomatter how many stories you hear from the superheros that had an icing encounter and lived.

If you get into icing in a single engine airplane (not certified for known icing) than you have made a mistake. You have eyeballs and an OAT gauge.

I agree 100%. In a non certified plane avoid areas were you know it exists or where you think it might exist. Bottom line is each time you pick up ice it will be a unique situation than the last time. You don't know how it will build on the frame and how the bird will fly afterward. I personally know a pilot who within moments of picking up ice in a 172 found the situation to be virtually non-flyable and was able to do a "controlled" descent and crash landing in a field, seriously injuring him and his passenger. To this day he has pins in his body. They were not being careless with the ice, there were no reports or airmets and they had what they thought was a very good "out" in case there was an encounter. At an equivalent time in my career as a CFI I probably would have made the same decisions had I been in their shoes.

I have also heard the stories of guys picking up "over an inch of ice" and being ok. Personally when I have had over an inch of ice on the Brasilia, it often shook like hell and needed lots of power from both 1800 shp engines to climb. (And the Brasilia does a pretty good job in the ice too!!) Every year in the Rockies I find myself in moderate ice & occasionally maybe a little worse than I would like. The plane is equipped for it, but still I find a way out as quickly as possible. Usually when the heavy ice occurs, in my experience, it comes on very fast. In that kind of ice the last place I would want to be is in a small uncertified plane as it WOULD bring it down. Respect the ice.
 
They were not being careless with the ice, there were no reports or airmets and they had what they thought was a very good "out" in case there was an encounter.

I find this statement contradictory. If there was no threat of ice, why did they need an "out"?
 
Nope. Don't screw around with ice in non-certified airplanes. Nomatter how many stories you hear from the superheros that had an icing encounter and lived.

I wish I could put that in RED and have it blinking for you all. We have trouble with moderate rime in a Part 25 Ice-Certified Airliner- what makes you think a 172 can handle it. Dont die guys.
 
Back
Top