Having now seen the reserve language in the TA, I agree, ya'll would be insane to vote that in. It's absolute crap and I'm really happy to see that there is some political action taking place to slap those that even considered it acceptable.
A great deal of my job deals with arbitrations. Believe me when I tell you that you can never count on certain results from arbitrations. Arbitrations are final and binding, and rarely do they go as planned. If your people are saying that they know how it will go, then trust me, they don't have any "street cred."