Time Logging Question

Look up one post
_pointup__by_PunkyB.gif

Yup, just read it. The letter states that the pilot "Under the hood" flying without the required endorsements can still log PIC because they are the "sole manipulator". My so called "question" still refers back to what if the safety pilot who is not under the hood, can they log PIC if they do not have the required endorsements. I read from your website that they can log SIC. Do you have a link for that SIC interpretation?

EDIT:
Wait. Are you looking for the safety pilot one? The FAA Chief Counsel opinion site is actibg up a bit. Go here http://www.faa.gov/about/office_org.../agc/pol_adjudication/agc200/Interpretations/

type safety pilot in the search box. The opinion is from 1992.

That's what I was looking for, thanks!
 
And just FYI, to the kid that wants to know about logging this time.

If you log it, depending on the type of operation you are going to get into, expect to be asked question about that aircraft and how you logged the time if you don't have a HP and complex endorsement.

Sure, folks here will point to a website and say, "SEE!!! SEE!!! YOU CAN LOG IT!!! YOU NEED TO LOG IT!!!" I don't personally take that attitude.

You see, I've been in interviews, and I've been involved in the interview process before, and I've been asked about the electrical system on the King Air 200. I've only got 10 hours in the King Air, MAYBE, but I was sitting there answering questions about the systems because I was legally current due to my recent Part 135 SIC training in the Beech 99/King Air.

So if you're going to log that time, you'd better take it upon yourself to actually know about the aircraft, and you'd better be able to explain to somebody, under scrutiny, how you logged that time in a legal fashion.

And they won't take, "Well this internet website told me so..." as an answer.

Just a few things to consider.
All true. On the other hand one never knows when one will happen across an available job flying frieght in 210's that requires 25 hours logged in type to apply. It is likely that operator is not going to care whether or not you were acting as PIC or simply logging it as sole manip. And getting that job could lead to several hundred hours of acting PIC in type... which could lead to several hundred hours of acting PIC in a light twin... which could in turn lead to several hundred hours of acting PIC in a twin turbine... which in turn could lead to an interview with a 121 operator.

No one can predict the future and the thought of not logging time that you're legally entitled to log simply because of something that may or may not be asked on an interview that you may or may not ever take just seems silly to me. Log the time, acknowledge the possible remifications of it down the road, except them and move on.
 
Yup, just read it. The letter states that the pilot "Under the hood" flying without the required endorsements can still log PIC because they are the "sole manipulator". My so called "question" still refers back to what if the safety pilot who is not under the hood, can they log PIC if they do not have the required endorsements. I read from your website that they can log SIC. Do you have a link for that SIC interpretation?

EDIT:

That's what I was looking for, thanks!
Guess you noticed that it's in the same interpretation letter.
 
Thank you for that. This needs to be posted at my flight school to settle the debate.
Want to have fun? Show them that the "debate" was settled almost 30 years ago, probably before most of them started flying and maybe before some of them were even born):

==============================
OCT. 28, 1980

WINSTON SCOTT JONES

Dear Mr. Jones:

This is in response to your letter in which you request an interpretation of Section 61.51(2)(c) of the Federal Aviation Regulations, regarding logging of pilot-in-command (PIC) flight time.

Specifically, you ask what time may be logged as PIC time when the pilot in the right seat is a certificated flight instructor (CFI) along for the purpose of instruction and is not a required crewmember, and the pilot in the left seat holds either a private or commercial certificate in an aircraft for which he is rated.

Section 61.51 is a flight-time logging regulation, under which PIC time may be logged by one who is not actually the pilot in command (i.e., not "ultimately" responsible for the aircraft) during that time. This is consistent with the purpose of Section 61.51, which as stated in 61.51(a) is to record aeronautical training and experience used to meet the requirements for a certificate or rating, or the recent flight experience requirements of Section 61.

Section 61.51(c)(2)(i) provides that a private or commercial pilot may log as pilot-in-command time only that flight time during which the pilot--

1. Is the sole manipulator of the controls of an aircraft for which he is rated; or

2. Is the sole occupant of the aircraft; or

3. Acts as pilot-in-command of an aircraft on which more than one pilot is required under the type certification of the aircraft, or the regulations under which the flight is conducted.

Under Section 61.51(c)(2)(iii) a certificated flight instructor may log as pilot-in-command time all flight time during which he or she acts as a flight instructor. Sections 61.51(b)(2)(iii) and (iv) provide for logging of flight instruction and instrument flight instruction received.

Accordingly, two or more pilots may each log PIC time for the same flight time. For example, a pilot who is the sole manipulator of the controls of an aircraft for which he or she is rated may log that time as PIC time under 61.51(c)(2)(i) while receiving instruction, and the instructor may log that same time as PIC time under 61.51(c)(2)(iii).

There is no provision in the FAR's for logging of "dual" flight time; however, we assume that you are referring to logging time as instruction received. Section 61.51(b)(2)(iii) and (iv) allow flight instruction and instrument instruction received time to be recorded. There is nothing in the FAR's which prevents a pilot from logging the same time as both instruction received and PIC time, as long as each requirement is met. The pilot may also log the same time as instrument instruction. Note, though, that one hour of flight logged both as one hour of PIC and one hour of instruction received still adds up to only one hour total flight time.

You request interpretations of these regulations for situations in which:

1. The purpose of the flight is instruction in advanced maneuvers.

2. The purpose of the flight is simulated instrument instruction in actual VFR conditions.

3. The purpose of the flight is instrument instruction actual IFR conditions.

4. The pilot in the left seat is not current in the aircraft or in the conditions of flight.

5. The purpose of the flight is transition from tricycle to conventional landing gear.

6. The purpose of the flight is obtaining logbook endorsement authorizing operation of a high performance aircraft, as required by FAR 61.31(e).

7. The purpose of the flight is transition to a different type aircraft of the same category and class for which the left seat pilot is rated and a type rating is not required.

In each situation, the CFI may log PIC time for all flight time during which she or he acts as flight instructor. The pilot receiving instruction may also log PIC time in each of these situations, as the pilot is the sole manipulator of the controls of an aircraft for which she or he is rated. Specifically, neither the currency requirements of situation 4 nor the log book endorsement of situation 6 are ratings within the meaning of Section 61.51. "Rating" as used in that section refers to the rating in categories, classes, and types, as listed in Section 61.5, which are placed on pilot certificates.

We trust that this discussion answers your questions.

Sincerely,

EDWARD P. FABERMAN
Acting Assistant Chief Counsel
Regulations and Enforcement Division
==============================
 
KVNC - does this help answer your question? It's from the FAA Chief Counsel. 2 months ago, repeating what they've been saying for 30 years.

http://www.faa.gov/about/office_org.../interpretations/data/interps/2009/Herman.pdf


Hey jtrain, will they take the FAA Chief Counsel's formal opinion as an answer, or are there other areas in which they decide to use their own interpretations of the regs instead of the FAAs?

I'm sure they will, but I'd be referencing that, and understanding the opinion instead of attempting to cite http://forums.jetcareers.com/.
 
I know I'm digging something up from the forum grave here, but just for fun. You know what the difference is from that 80's letter and today that I read? It's the 61.51E(1)(i)
More specifically; Is the sole manipulator of the controls of an aircraft for which the pilot is rated or has privileges. I'm not on one side of the matter or the other, but what do you suppose privileges means? Does it mean you have the proper ratings and endorsements to ACT as PIC? :dunno: I just thought I'd put that out there for discussion seeing that a similar thread has been brought up about the PC-12 and I didn't want to hijack that one.
 
Ah brilliant...i was wondering abot that as well.
Yep. The "or has privileges" (and note, ackeight, that's it's OR has privileges, not
and" has privileges) language was added as part of the amendments to Part 61 that added the sport pilot certificate pretty much because sport pilots aren't "rated" in anything. All they have is "privileges."
 
It's also possible for a CFI to, for example, sign off a PP with a SEL rating to fly solo in a twin. Maybe that's also what they mean by 'privileges'.

Also, log all the PIC time you want, but it likely has limited value unless you signed for the airplane.
 
Yep. The "or has privileges" (and note, ackeight, that's it's OR has privileges, not
and" has privileges) language was added as part of the amendments to Part 61 that added the sport pilot certificate pretty much because sport pilots aren't "rated" in anything. All they have is "privileges."
I always sort of figured it was referring to endorsements, ie HP, complex, tailwheel, etc.
 
Also, log all the PIC time you want, but it likely has limited value unless you signed for the airplane.
Everyone tends to be so focused on the airline prize, they all tend to forget that part 91 and 135 jobs have mins too. And more often than not, no one at any of those jobs are going to care how you logged your hours so long as all of it was legal.
 
in the regs it keeps mentioning that one can log PIC tims as the sole manip. of the controls for an wircraft that he or she is rrated in. Does that mean that if i have my PPL and am signed off only for the C172 and go up in a 210 with someone who is rated in the 210; and he/she lets me fly for an hour.....can i log that time since I was flying or no?


talk about a run-on sentence.... hahaha
 
in the regs it keeps mentioning that one can log PIC tims as the sole manip. of the controls for an wircraft that he or she is rrated in. Does that mean that if i have my PPL and am signed off only for the C172 and go up in a 210 with someone who is rated in the 210; and he/she lets me fly for an hour.....can i log that time since I was flying or no?
Yes. You may log it as PIC time. As much as some folks just don't like it, that's exactly what it means.
 
in the regs it keeps mentioning that one can log PIC tims as the sole manip. of the controls for an wircraft that he or she is rrated in. Does that mean that if i have my PPL and am signed off only for the C172 and go up in a 210 with someone who is rated in the 210; and he/she lets me fly for an hour.....can i log that time since I was flying or no?


talk about a run-on sentence.... hahaha
When it says you can log sole manip in any aircraft you're rated in, it means 'rated'. A CFI signoff to fly a particular model of airplane is not a rating. A rating is what it says on your pilot certificate. If your pilot certificate says airplane single engine land, then you can log PIC anytime you are sole manipulator of the controls in a single engine land airplane. That includes any single engine land airplane which does not require a type rating. Go up for an hour with a buddy in a C210, you can legally log it. Go up for an hour with a rich Cougar in her Pilatus PC12, you can legally log it. Do an hour in a Stearman, you can legally log it.

Now that I've written that, the joy police will be along to remind you of all the wonderful and quite hypothetical reasons why you shouldn't log any of it even though its perfectly legal to do so. Suffice it to say that I do not agree with their reasoning and I have yet to meet anyone personally whose career was ruined due to logging this type of time.
 
Yes. You may log it as PIC time. As much as some folks just don't like it, that's exactly what it means.

No, I don't like it at all, but it's irrelavent what I think. You are absolutely correct--it may be legally logged.

BUT, if I were you guys, I'd find a way to separately keep track of your Part 1 PIC time, because you just might be asked to present it that way on job applications.
 
No, I don't like it at all, but it's irrelavent what I think. You are absolutely correct--it may be legally logged.

BUT, if I were you guys, I'd find a way to separately keep track of your Part 1 PIC time, because you just might be asked to present it that way on job applications.
That makes a lot of sense, but I think you really do need both, even for that job.

The job application may be concerned with your "real" command time to show your real experience being in charge of a flight, and you should be able to give that information.

But the job application may be concerned with whether you meet FAA minimum requirements for the job. And that's your 61.51 PIC time. You're instructing at Podunk that also does check runs. The regular pilot is gone and all they care about is whether you meet Part 135 minimums. Don't short-change yourself by losing an opportunity by being too proud to use your time in Uncle Joe's 210 or acting as PIC-safety pilot in a 152.

Also remember that the rule works the other way, too. There are times Part 1 PIC is =not= Part 61.51 PIC and =can't= be logged as PIC time toward FAA certificate, ratings and qualifications.
 
Back
Top