would and could this work

matt it seems like this is flamebait! :dunno:. i will agree that a obese person that takes up 2 seats should pay for 2 seats. However, there would be so many lawsuits about discrimnation. oh yeah matt the PENS suck!:insane:
hahaha the redwings need to trade their wings for a new pair. Wow that was cheesy. :rotfl:Hey are yall planning to resign Hossa?


cant wait until next year.:rawk:;):D
 
Or we could just turn socialist and let the government make everyone get a physical. I'm sure THAT would go over very smooth.
 
Or we could just turn socialist and let the government make everyone get a physical. I'm sure THAT would go over very smooth.
We should just put the obese passengers on a mandatory diet and exercise regime. Or maybe they could require a doctors note to eat at McDonald or buy soda.
 
wow, this i sstarting to get ugly....should have though before posting. Lesson well learned

Happens sometime here, don't sweat it too much. Oh, dude, spellcheck......Seriously!


My personal opinion regarding your question. No, it would not work and it could not work. While you attempt to make it sound simple enough there are just too many variables to consider, not to mention a very shaky precedent to stand on.

Why air travel? Why not have a physical for cab rides, cruises, Greyhound, Am-track? It's all transportation, right?

What would the criteria be for "Fit to fly?" Lloyd pointed out above, although you disagreed, that you seem to have been singling out obese persons as the basis for the need for a physical.

Anyway, without too much extra detail, I would say no and no.
 
Happens sometime here, don't sweat it too much. Oh, dude, spellcheck......Seriously!


My personal opinion regarding your question. No, it would not work and it could not work. While you attempt to make it sound simple enough there are just too many variables to consider, not to mention a very shaky precedent to stand on.

Why air travel? Why not have a physical for cab rides, cruises, Greyhound, Am-track? It's all transportation, right?

What would the criteria be for "Fit to fly?" Lloyd pointed out above, although you disagreed, that you seem to have been singling out obese persons as the basis for the need for a physical.

Anyway, without too much extra detail, I would say no and no.
yeah i seem to type fast and just click reply lol. After looking at the post and all the replies i do agree with you one hundred percent. My reasoning is that up in the air in a pressurized metal tube, things can get ugly, fast, especially if something goes wrong and there must be an emergency evac. idk there are alot of types of people that could hinder safety. Im sorry if i offended anyone with this thread. I apologize sincerely and i wont let it happen again.

-matt

i will stand against my opinion and say that people do need to take a second to see if they are fit to fly. If they have a chronic illness, maybe it is not safe for one to fly, maybe one is too old, or too obese, or just has problems when flying. We all need to check our selves mentally every now and then so we dont hurt oursleves and other people.

I hope there isn't any bad blood from this thread.
 
My qeustion is this. Would it be too much of a hassle to make everyone get a pre flight check up by their Dr. to make sure they are " fit to fly?"
Fit to fly? So I take it that you feel people are now getting on airplanes even though they're not fit enough to sit in an uncomfortable chair for a couple of hours. So tell me, what exactly happens when someone isn't 'fit to fly'? And what exactly does someones weight have to do with that?
 
Fit to fly? So I take it that you feel people are now getting on airplanes even though they're not fit enough to sit in an uncomfortable chair for a couple of hours. So tell me, what exactly happens when someone isn't 'fit to fly'? And what exactly does someones weight have to do with that?
well for one they can pose a significant health risk. No one wants somebody who is sick coughing, vomiting or spewing other bacteria in a tube with recycled air for 2 hours. Do you? Those people who are morbidly obese...meanign 400-500 pounds not 200-300 pounds, who don't bathe also cause health risks. That's bacteria that could cause illness as well. im NOT SAYING that ALL obese people are not fit to fly. Use common sense here.

Also tell me this, if you had to get out of an aircraft FAST, would you wat for an morbidly obese person to barely get out of their chair and take up valubale time becasue they cant get out fast enough. NO YOU WOULDN'T.

Lets put a scenario on this for you if i may. Say you were on an intl. flight and a passenger was sick with a bug that is very severe. Even though she knew she had symptoms of this illness, she still got on board because she felt she was entitled to the luxury and because she already payed the fees. Now, everyone on board has been exposed to this illness and you are all infected. Think of it like that. Granted that is an extreme case but it proves the point.

I have nothing agianst these people as implied by my story in the original post. I do howver have problems with ALL TYPES of people who are unfit to fly getting on aircraft becasue they feel they are entitled to do so.

not everyone is entitled to fly and you know that so dont act like everyone is. being in a plane is not like being in a car, lets face it.

I should have worded the orignal post to include ALL TYPES of people who are unfit to fly not just obese people. It was a mistake and i apologized already. I just got done reading stories about what other people have had to go through and it was fresh in my mind.

ONCE AGAIN i am sorry if i have offended anyone in this thread.
 
There are already rules in place about flying with communicable diseases....

I don't have the time nor energy to search carriers' contracts of carriage but I'm pretty sure it's in there somewhere.
 
Those people who are morbidly obese...meanign 400-500 pounds not 200-300 pounds, who don't bathe also cause health risks.
So there are no thin people who don't bath? And there are no obese people who do?
That's bacteria that could cause illness as well. im NOT SAYING that ALL obese people are not fit to fly.
I suggest you take some microbiology (or get a better teacher) before you go forming too many more theories about what poses a health risk and what doesn't.
Use common sense here.
Funny, I was thinking of recommending the same thing to you.


Also tell me this, if you had to get out of an aircraft FAST, would you wat for an morbidly obese person to barely get out of their chair and take up valubale time becasue they cant get out fast enough. NO YOU WOULDN'T.
So we should ban handicapped people from flying then? And old people, lets not forget them. They generally can't move very fast so we'd better just go ahead and ban them too while we're at it. And what about people to tend to panic and freeze when faced with dire emergencies? I guess they're walking as well. Perhaps they can help all those banned handicapped people and old folks get on the bus. Or should we ban them from busses also? Can't be too careful you know.


Lets put a scenario on this for you if i may. Say you were on an intl. flight and a passenger was sick with a bug that is very severe. Even though she knew she had symptoms of this illness, she still got on board because she felt she was entitled to the luxury and because she already payed the fees. Now, everyone on board has been exposed to this illness and you are all infected. Think of it like that. Granted that is an extreme case but it proves the point.
It proves that you believe people who have known contagious illnesses shouldn't be allowed to fly. I don't see what that has to do with obese people.

But I'll play ball with you for a while. Lets assume that your logic has merit. If that's the case, then we should probably extend your logic to cover all groups of people who are likely to pose a threat to safety on a commercial flight, be it due to their inability to get the 'eff out of the way in an emergency or due to the fact that they might have pose a public health risk. So first and foremost, we'd have ban the gays because they could have HIV. Obviously not of all of them do (lets use common sense like you said) but many of them do and that's not the sort of thing you want being spread around a cabin at 30kft. Then we'd better ban the blacks as well because they tend to be poor and don't get the high quality health care that wealthy people tend to get. Mexicans? Swine Flu, 'nuff said, the Mexicans are out. And since we can't always tell the Mexicans from Cubans, from the Puerto Ricans just by looking at them, we'd better go ahead and ban them all. Jews? Actually, the Jews can stay. They've been through enough already.

Do you think I've offended enough groups yet? See what happens when we start making assumptions about people based on hunches and ignorance and then as a result, decide to make rules for them?
 
Back
Top