After reading every single post on this thread, there have been many insightful answers and a lot of excellent advice. Allow me to tell you my story, which is surprisingly similar to yours. I broke up with my ex-girlfriend on March 12th. This decision was made in the heat of the moment and is one I wish I had never made. My decision tore both of us apart and continues to do so. For the past two months and nine days I have been trying to get back together with her. We both agree that we miss each other very much, that we still love each other, and miss the relationship we had. However, between March and now we have both grown and matured. I have started flying full-time once again and will be a flight instructor by the end of the summer. She re-gained admission to UCF and Army ROTC. Starting this fall, she will be on scholarship for nursing. Quite simply, we are both very independent people now; something that we both thought we would never be because we were so dependent upon each other. We literally spent every waking moment together for the past year and a half, and surprisingly that wasn’t our demise. Now, we are both chasing our dreams with the determination that reflects our true passion. When you sit down and think logically about it, if we got back together it would never work. Can you imagine a pilot and an Army nurse having a successful relationship whilst being separated by many lines of longitude for the next six years? It is difficult to imagine, yet I am still holding out for her (sort of) because she says she has not had enough time to make a decision on whether or not she wants to be with me. The point is I see that you still love him just like I love my ex. You hope that you guys will get back together even though you obviously have serious doubts about the viability of the relationship just like I do. We both know the answer to our issue, yet we both refuse to accept the reality of our situations. In my case, just staying best friends with my ex is the way to go. I believe this to be the best answer in your case as well. Allow me to share some advice which I was given by a very wise person: “everything happens for a reason.” Maybe your relationship, like mine, just wasn’t meant to be.