My Bitter Sweet Reality

Maurus

The Great Gazoo
As I sit at my desk with a whisky at my side I can’t help but reminisce over my career. Early on I was given a stark reality check. The day after obtaining my instrument rating my flight instructor was involved in a fatal midair collision over a VOR. During what should have been a time of celebration disaster struck. This flight instructor was one of the best I had during my initial training. He was a great teacher and most importantly a great mentor. Especially to a young 19-year-old idiot like I was.

Having a loss like this has always been on my mind during my career. Asking myself how to prevent what occurred and executing a mitigation plan has literally saved my life. The day this accident occurred I decided that I would use flight following whenever possible. I avoided many potential midair collisions because of CAK and CLE approach watching my flights. Even then, I still had many close calls over my career. These range from non-controlled airport miscommunications to military aircraft turning their transponder on near me causing an immediate RA.

Over time I have had to add tail numbers that I have flown to a list that have had accidents and even fatal accidents. More and more lessons are being learned with a form of survivor bias constantly trying to pull me back into complacency. I added another tail number to my list last night. This time it was a big one.

While I was a CA at PSA I remember a point where it felt like I had almost all the answers. Confidence was at an all-time high. Even then, I made mistakes. As an LCA I had new students tell me, indirectly, I was an idiot. They were right! My passengers were at unnecessary risk due to my own actions at times. Our two-pilot system caught those mistakes and for that I am grateful. I am also thankful that my goal of listening to every FO’s concern as a CA and taking a conservative approach to my decisions has resulted in successful and safe flights. Being "right" doesn't matter. Being safe is exponentially better.

A bit over 3 years ago I was hired at my dream job flying a big widget around. I have had the quintessential airline dream going international and all over the country. I have experienced and enjoyed places I never expected to visit. I have learned a lot from my CAs. Some things I never thought of even as an LCA at a regional.

Here I am again, recently completing IOE as a CA at a legacy airline being humbled. You can do everything right, think you know all the right answers, and yet the worst result is always possible. Last night was yet again another reminder of the reality we live in. Be careful, strive to learn from others, and don’t let a survivor bias control you. It is way too easy to allow ego to dictate reason.

My check airmen have helped put me in my place. While I wasn’t stressed about training, compared to past experiences, they showed me that there is still a crap ton to learn. Every time I thought I was on top of things they found more items I needed to think about and plan for. I was given tools that were not in my toolbox in the past and that I intend to use in the future. The training I received was excellent. I honestly wish this level of training existed at the regional level and that I provided even a fraction of it while I was an LCA.

I will say, while the LCAs did a fantastic job they also were not perfect. No one ever is perfect. Still, I learned a crap ton over a couple of trips and I hope the LCAs did as well. I know I did when I was teaching as a CFI and as an LCA in the past.

JC has been a tremendous resource in my career. I obviously have had heated debates on this platform, but that has ultimately led to me learning soooooooooooooo much more than I would have learned otherwise. I started here as an embarrassing conservative anti-union bum (seriously, look up my post history early on) and changed significantly with the input here along with other life experience. JC has impacted my focus on learning tremendously and set me up for a ton of my success. I may have been a bit of a pain in the ass (you totally can say ass here while retracting flaps in the flare) but it has been for the greater good. Thank you @derg and the rest of the JC family! @jtrain609 , you still suck but only because you don’t post as often as you should 🙃
 
Last edited:
As I sit at my desk with a whisky at my side I can’t help but reminisce over my career. Early on I was given a stark reality check. The day after obtaining my instrument rating my flight instructor was involved in a fatal midair collision over a VOR. During what should have been a time of celebration disaster struck. This flight instructor was one of the best I had during my initial training. He was a great teacher and most importantly a great mentor. Especially to a young 19-year-old idiot like I was.

Having a loss like this has always been on my mind during my career. Asking myself how to prevent what occurred and executing a mitigation plan has literally saved my life. The day this accident occurred I decided that I would use flight following whenever possible. I avoided many potential midair collisions because of CAK and CLE approach watching my flights. Even then, I still had many close calls over my career. These range from non-controlled airport miscommunications to military aircraft turning their transponder on near me causing an immediate RA.

Over time I have had to add tail numbers that I have flown to a list that have had accidents and even fatal accidents. More and more lessons are being learned with a form of survivor bias constantly trying to pull me back into complacency. I added another tail number to my list last night. This time it was a big one.

While I was a CA at PSA I remember a point where it felt like I had almost all the answers. Confidence was at an all-time high. Even then, I made mistakes. As an LCA I had new students tell me, indirectly, I was an idiot. They were right! My passengers were at unnecessary risk due to my own actions at times. Our two-pilot system caught those mistakes and for that I am grateful. I am also thankful that my goal of listening to every FO’s concern as a CA and taking a conservative approach to my decisions has resulted in successful and safe flights. Being "right" doesn't matter. Being safe is exponentially better.

A bit over 3 years ago I was hired at my dream job flying a big widget around. I have had the quintessential airline dream going international and all over the country. I have experienced and enjoyed places I never expected to visit. I have learned a lot from my CAs. Some things I never thought of even as an LCA at a regional.

Here I am again, recently completing IOE as a CA at a legacy airline being humbled. You can do everything right, think you know all the right answers, and yet the worst result is always possible. Last night was yet again another reminder of the reality we live in. Be careful, strive to learn from others, and don’t let a survivor bias control you. It is way too easy to allow ego to dictate reason.

My check airmen have helped put me in my place. While I wasn’t stressed about training, compared to past experiences, they showed me that there is still a crap ton to learn. Every time I thought I was on top of things they found more items I needed to think about and plan for. I was given tools that were not in my toolbox in the past and that I intend to use in the future. The training I received was excellent. I honestly wish this level of training existed at the regional level and that I provided even a fraction of it while I was an LCA.

I will say, while the LCAs did a fantastic job they also were not perfect. No one ever is perfect. Still, I learned a crap ton over a couple of trips and I hope the LCAs did as well. I know I did when I was teaching as a CFI and as an LCA in the past.

JC has been a tremendous resource in my career. I obviously have had heated debates on this platform, but that has ultimately led to me learning soooooooooooooo much more than I would have learned otherwise. I started here as an embarrassing conservative anti-union bum (seriously, look up my post history early on) and changed significantly with the input here along with other life experience. JC has impacted my focus on learning tremendously and set me up for a ton of my success. I may have been a bit of a pain in the ass (you totally can say ass here while retracting flaps in the flare) but it has been for the greater good. Thank you @derg and the rest of the JC family! @jtrain609 , you still suck but only because you don’t post as often as you should 🙃

Hey so since you asked for it.

I tell guys in my pairing brief that if I'm doing something creative, I'm probably just • it up and to please say something.

On the literal first leg of OE I gave as LCA I tried to convince an FO to call for push back without running any checklists, because I was sure we'd done them already. He asked me if I wanted to run the before pushback checklist first.

A checklist I had absolutely not done yet.

We're all fallible, and we're always learning. Nice work taking those opportunities to suck less, and congrats on the upgrade.
 
Hey so since you asked for it.

I tell guys in my pairing brief that if I'm doing something creative, I'm probably just • it up and to please say something.

On the literal first leg of OE I gave as LCA I tried to convince an FO to call for push back without running any checklists, because I was sure we'd done them already. He asked me if I wanted to run the before pushback checklist first.

A checklist I had absolutely not done yet.

We're all fallible, and we're always learning. Nice work taking those opportunities to suck less, and congrats on the upgrade.
Seriously though. I need to start my brief with "I will F something up." Just a matter of time.
 
"If it looks like I'm doing something stupid or unsafe, let me know because I probably am." Breaks the ice with folks I haven't flown with before. I learned about authority gradient fairly early on as a CFI thanks to the contracts with Asian airlines they took to pay for new airplanes and high-end hockey recruits. My goal is to make it clear I'm ultimately responsible but also both fallible and that I value and welcome the knowledge and experience of the other pilot.
 
Hey so since you asked for it.

I tell guys in my pairing brief that if I'm doing something creative, I'm probably just • it up and to please say something.

On the literal first leg of OE I gave as LCA I tried to convince an FO to call for push back without running any checklists, because I was sure we'd done them already. He asked me if I wanted to run the before pushback checklist first.

A checklist I had absolutely not done yet.

We're all fallible, and we're always learning. Nice work taking those opportunities to suck less, and congrats on the upgrade.

“I’m a LCP which means that I screw up stealthily or spectacularly, but I’m fallible and I’m human. If something doesn’t look right, please speak up and I will buy a round for doing your job. If you speak up, you’re not correct and we talk about it, I’ll buy you two rounds because I’m happy you said something and we cleared it up, so please please please, don’t be reluctant to speak up”
 
Being a professional pilot doesn’t mean being perfect, in either seat or as a LCA. Being professional is keeping that always learning mindset, harnessing the awareness of vulnerability, limitations and threats. Then delicately balancing that out against efficiency and economics. Not all humans can be pilots, but all pilots are human. To me, the ones with the ego’s are the most dangerous type, because they seem to create an atmosphere where it’s hard to speak up when needed. I’ve read more than one NTSB report thinking to myself, yup the ego killed ‘em there.

I now have two tail numbers in my log book that have claimed the lives of pilots. Well technically one was a ramper, but still a life. It is an eerie feeling, I even remember the exact legs in those airplanes to this day. Yet I don’t seem to remember where I parked my car for this 4 day trip every week…

Fly safe out there, and thanks for sharing with us
 
The day you have an absolutely perfect flight without the slightest mess up, is the day to hang up your wings for good.
 
“I’m a LCP which means that I screw up stealthily or spectacularly, but I’m fallible and I’m human. If something doesn’t look right, please speak up and I will buy a round for doing your job. If you speak up, you’re not correct and we talk about it, I’ll buy you two rounds because I’m happy you said something and we cleared it up, so please please please, don’t be reluctant to speak up”
“Either way, cocktails will be involved so that is a win.”
 
And then there are captains that get upset when one hovers their hand near the flap lever so that it isn’t forgotten. Hopefully those kinds are few and far between.
 
And then there are captains that get upset when one hovers their hand near the flap lever so that it isn’t forgotten. Hopefully those kinds are few and far between.

Technically, and don’t shoot the messenger, we’re specifically instructed not to do that for a few human factors reasons.

Again, I didn’t make the rules, but I follow them and get showered with ducats on the first and fifteenth.

Expectation bias. If you hover your hand over a control anticipating a configuration change, If you call for “A” but your hand is over “B”, there’s a high probability you’re going to do what your hand is over instead of that’s commanded.

Gesture Bullying. I still haven’t cracked this nut but to some personality types, you’re non-verbally communication “look dumbass, you need this now”. Also you really don’t want the captain reaching over for the flaps for an extended period when the thrust levers are moving back and forth because there may be a light tap on the TOGA buttons and we’re off to the rodeo.

Distraction. This is one I dig. I have the peripheral vision of a freaking gecko and I can focus straight ahead on the runway but every time the other pilot fidgets in the other seat, it’s in my visual range so when someone starts reaching for the gear handle when THEY think it should come down, but it’s not time, it’s a distraction.
 
And then there are captains that get upset when one hovers their hand near the flap lever so that it isn’t forgotten. Hopefully those kinds are few and far between.

Technically, and don’t shoot the messenger, we’re specifically instructed not to do that for a few human factors reasons.

Again, I didn’t make the rules, but I follow them and get showered with ducats on the first and fifteenth.

Expectation bias. If you hover your hand over a control anticipating a configuration change, If you call for “A” but your hand is over “B”, there’s a high probability you’re going to do what your hand is over instead of that’s commanded.

Gesture Bullying. I still haven’t cracked this nut but to some personality types, you’re non-verbally communication “look dumbass, you need this now”. Also you really don’t want the captain reaching over for the flaps for an extended period when the thrust levers are moving back and forth because there may be a light tap on the TOGA buttons and we’re off to the rodeo.

Distraction. This is one I dig. I have the peripheral vision of a freaking gecko and I can focus straight ahead on the runway but every time the other pilot fidgets in the other seat, it’s in my visual range so when someone starts reaching for the gear handle when THEY think it should come down, but it’s not time, it’s a distraction.

Single pilot > flying by committee. 😆
 
Expectation bias. If you hover your hand over a control anticipating a configuration change, If you call for “A” but your hand is over “B”, there’s a high probability you’re going to do what your hand is over instead of that’s commanded.
At PSA it was common to say "gear down flaps 30" in the same breath. One time I only said gear down because we were too fast for flaps. All of a sudden I saw the red tape at my airspeed and an overspeed alarm go off. Expectation bias can certainly get you.

It turned out to be a non-event after an ASAP and logbook write-up. Expectation bias can certainly get you in trouble though.
 
Meh. I don’t care. You can put your hand there all day long. Just don’t move it until I say so.

As long as you don’t say “with you.”
 
Meh. I don’t care. You can put your hand there all day long. Just don’t move it until I say so.

As long as you don’t say “with you.”

I had a hand over move the flap to clean machine when we were still below the flap 1 speed. He was a hand hoverer.

Keep your stinkin paws to yourself. :) I haven't forgotten the flaps. We are still too slow for them to come up.
 
Back
Top