JAA Private to FAA Private Conversion: Night Flying?

CoffeeIcePapers

Well-Hung Member
I have a student with a JAA Private License from Italy that he converted to an FAA Pilot Certificate. His FAA Private is based on his JAA Private, which is restricted to day time only. In order to meet the requirements for the FAA Commercial, he needs solo night time, obviously. Is there an endorsement I can give him that will allow him to fly at night solo? I was thinking if he got an FAA Student Pilot Certificate, I could give him a 61.87(o) endorsement, assuming I give him that training.

Is this correct? Day VFR, he will be using the privileges of his FAA private, and at night will be using the privileges of his student pilot certificate/endorsement.
 
I have a student with a JAA Private License from Italy that he converted to an FAA Pilot Certificate. His FAA Private is based on his JAA Private, which is restricted to day time only. In order to meet the requirements for the FAA Commercial, he needs solo night time, obviously. Is there an endorsement I can give him that will allow him to fly at night solo? I was thinking if he got an FAA Student Pilot Certificate, I could give him a 61.87(o) endorsement, assuming I give him that training.

Is this correct? Day VFR, he will be using the privileges of his FAA private, and at night will be using the privileges of his student pilot certificate/endorsement.

Why not just get the night restriction lifted by meeting the night private requirments?
 
Because he would need 3 hours of test prep, a private written exam and a checkride.

Came to U.S. in 1999 and validated European Private.
3 Hours Testprep, Night, Written & Checkride for unlimited U.S. PPL then.

Anyhow, directly from my logbook, the endorsement for night & night cross country (1 rampcheck, looked at endorsement, no issues)

I certify that I have given Mr. Xxxxx Xxxxx, Holder of Foreign Pilot Certificate # XXXX ground and flight instruction for night operations and find him competent to fly safe, solo Night VFR. Xxx Xxxxxxxxxx CFI XXXXXXX Exp. XX/XX

Today, almost 10 years later working on my own CFI, I realize that I would have been scared out of my pants to endorse something like that for someone I had flown for lousy 3 hours with... :D
 
Came to U.S. in 1999 and validated European Private.
3 Hours Testprep, Night, Written & Checkride for unlimited U.S. PPL then.

Anyhow, directly from my logbook, the endorsement for night & night cross country (1 rampcheck, looked at endorsement, no issues)



Today, almost 10 years later working on my own CFI, I realize that I would have been scared out of my pants to endorse something like that for someone I had flown for lousy 3 hours with... :D


Weird that there is no FAR listed in the endorsement. Thanks for the help.
 
Weird that there is no FAR listed in the endorsement. Thanks for the help.

I'd almost see what the Ops Inspector at your FSDO has to say.
Back then I never worried, when I ran into my rampy there was no problem. But again - thta was in 1999. I'm sure there was no precanned endorsement available, I wanted to fly night xc's in excess of 50NM and had not taken my U.S. checkride yet. Guess he wanted to help me.
Had a bunch of hours then as well and we had spent more than the mins on prior night checkout.

Good luck!
 
Weird that there is no FAR listed in the endorsement. Thanks for the help.
AC 61-65E, page 7:

"a.​
[FONT=JFIKGN+TimesNewRomanPSMT,Times New Roman PSMT][FONT=JFIKGN+TimesNewRomanPSMT,Times New Roman PSMT]A student pilot may operate an aircraft in solo flight at night provided that student has received the required flight training at night and the appropriate endorsements as required by Par 11 Page 7 AC 61-65E 11/29/05 ​

section 61.87(o). A student pilot seeking a sport pilot certificate is not authorized to operate a light-sport aircraft at night, per section 61.89(c)."

[/FONT]
[/FONT]
 
Adding night privileges to the JAA certificate isn't that hard; might be another avenue to investigate.
 
AC 61-65E, page 7:

"a.​
[FONT=JFIKGN+TimesNewRomanPSMT,Times New Roman PSMT][FONT=JFIKGN+TimesNewRomanPSMT,Times New Roman PSMT]A student pilot may operate an aircraft in solo flight at night provided that student has received the required flight training at night and the appropriate endorsements as required by Par 11 Page 7 AC 61-65E 11/29/05 [/FONT][/FONT]​
[FONT=JFIKGN+TimesNewRomanPSMT,Times New Roman PSMT][FONT=JFIKGN+TimesNewRomanPSMT,Times New Roman PSMT]
section 61.87(o). A student pilot seeking a sport pilot certificate is not authorized to operate a light-sport aircraft at night, per section 61.89(c)."

[/FONT]
[/FONT]

I referenced 61.87(o) in the first post. My question is, can he operate under the privileges of a student pilot at night?
 
I referenced 61.87(o) in the first post. My question is, can he operate under the privileges of a student pilot at night?

He's not a student pilot if he is flying on a validated JAA license.
Would he not need to convert his JAA private into a FAA private
(3 hours night, 3 hours test prep, written & oral & flight test) in order to get those limits lifted? He's fine to fly solo on an endorsement by you, but the limitation remains intact. I don't think you can endorse him to carry pax.

Remember the JAA license is just what the FAA license is 'based' on, if his JAA license reads "Night Flying & Special VFR prohibited" (like mine did) he'll carry these limitations over onto his FAA tickets. If you are trying for a standalone FAA Commercial I'd talk to the FSDO and see what they want (extra testing for night during the Commercial Checkride) and confirm it with Oh Oh City. The goal must be to get the limit of his JAA lifted.

Hope this makes sense?
 
If he has an FAA license he is not and can never be a student pilot again.
Absolutely right.

And my best guess on the endorsement is 61.31 (d)(3).

And I don't think this guy's JAA cert means anything anymore (here in the US) since he's flying on an FAA cert.

I could be wrong on both counts, though. ;)
 
Absolutely right.

And my best guess on the endorsement is 61.31 (d)(3).

And I don't think this guy's JAA cert means anything anymore (here in the US) since he's flying on an FAA cert.

I could be wrong on both counts, though. ;)

Yeah, I'd guess it's endorsement #62 in AC61-65E as well...

"To act as PIC of an aircraft in solo operations when the pilot does not hold an appropriate category/class rating: section 61.31(d)(3).
I certify that (First name, MI, Last name) has received the training as required by section 61.31(d)(3) to serve as a PIC in a (category and class of aircraft). I have determined that he/she is prepared to serve as PIC in that (make and model of aircraft).
/s/ [date] J. J. Jones 987654321CFI Exp. 12-31-05"

Or, you could cure this problem by doing his multi-commercial and get the 5 hours of night by using 61.129(b)(4) "...10 hours of flight time performing the duties of pilot in command in a multiengine airplane with an authorized instructor." That way you wouldn't have to solo him ;). Just a thought.
 
He's not a student pilot if he is flying on a validated JAA license.
Would he not need to convert his JAA private into a FAA private
(3 hours night, 3 hours test prep, written & oral & flight test) in order to get those limits lifted? He's fine to fly solo on an endorsement by you, but the limitation remains intact. I don't think you can endorse him to carry pax.

Remember the JAA license is just what the FAA license is 'based' on, if his JAA license reads "Night Flying & Special VFR prohibited" (like mine did) he'll carry these limitations over onto his FAA tickets. If you are trying for a standalone FAA Commercial I'd talk to the FSDO and see what they want (extra testing for night during the Commercial Checkride) and confirm it with Oh Oh City. The goal must be to get the limit of his JAA lifted.

Hope this makes sense?
You are correct. He can not be endorsed to carry pax using his FAA private based upon the foreign certificate (although I've been able to do this in the past with some FSDOs). Any restrictions on his foreign certificate will always be in place on his US certificate. Reference is 8710.3E:
http://www.faa.gov/documentLibrary/media/Order/ND/8710_3E-C21.pdf
 
Absolutely right.

And my best guess on the endorsement is 61.31 (d)(3).

And I don't think this guy's JAA cert means anything anymore (here in the US) since he's flying on an FAA cert.

I could be wrong on both counts, though. ;)

Yes.. wrong I'm afraid as he is flying on his JAA licence the FAA "ticket" he has is essentially just a letter of authorization allowing him to fly US registered aircraft using a none US licence.

I would speak to the FSDO because it is a funny case.. You can add additional ratings onto the FAA licence but there is no such thing as a night rating in the US. (It's part of the PPL)

In most other countries (all of Euro land included) the night rating is a separate rating that requires specific training + licence application to the CAA.
 
Or, you could cure this problem by doing his multi-commercial and get the 5 hours of night by using 61.129(b)(4) "...10 hours of flight time performing the duties of pilot in command in a multiengine airplane with an authorized instructor." That way you wouldn't have to solo him ;). Just a thought.
This won't work either. The requirement is night solo.;)

The only way I know that is legal is for him to give up his FAA PP, and get an FAA student certificate, endorse it for night solo, have him fly the night solo, get his FAA PP back based on his foreign license, and take his cax ride. ...or get the night restriction removed from the foreign license, which is even more complicated. ...or do the illegal night solo endorsment for a PP with a night restriction. It isn't legal, but it gets away with it.;)
 
This won't work either. The requirement is night solo.;)

The only way I know that is legal is for him to give up his FAA PP, and get an FAA student certificate, endorse it for night solo, have him fly the night solo, get his FAA PP back based on his foreign license, and take his cax ride. ...or get the night restriction removed from the foreign license, which is even more complicated. ...or do the illegal night solo endorsment for a PP with a night restriction. It isn't legal, but it gets away with it.;)

??? Perfectly legal for the person to get a night solo endorsement and fly solo at night on their US Private certificate based upon a foreign certificate. Once the person gets their stand alone US private pilot certificate they may carry passangers at night.

From chapter 21 of 8710.3E
​
(4) [FONT=Times New Roman,Times New Roman][FONT=Times New Roman,Times New Roman]Some foreign-pilot licenses contain a restriction that prohibits the person from operating an aircraft at night. As an example, some foreign CAAs require their citizens to hold an instrument rating and/or a night flying privilege in order to operate an aircraft at night. That person must also comply with that night operating restriction of their foreign-pilot license when exercising the privileges of their § 61.75 pilot certificate (see § 61.75(e)(3)). A point of clarification: the FAA may not remove the night flying restriction. It is permissible for a foreign pilot who receives a U.S. pilot certificate based on his or her foreign-pilot license to accomplish the required night flying training (for the appropriate grade level of U.S. pilot certificate held) from a holder of an FAA flight instructor certificate, and to receive a solo endorsement to exercise night flying privileges on his or her U.S. pilot certificate.

[/FONT]
[/FONT][FONT=Times New Roman,Times New Roman][FONT=Times New Roman,Times New Roman]

[/FONT]
[/FONT]
 
This won't work either. The requirement is night solo.;)

The only way I know that is legal is for him to give up his FAA PP, and get an FAA student certificate, endorse it for night solo, have him fly the night solo, get his FAA PP back based on his foreign license, and take his cax ride. ...or get the night restriction removed from the foreign license, which is even more complicated. ...or do the illegal night solo endorsment for a PP with a night restriction. It isn't legal, but it gets away with it.;)

It is night solo OR "performing the duties of pilot in command with an authorized instructor." Therefore it doesn't necessarily need to be solo if it's in a multi. It will work just fine if they do a multi-commercial initial.

And yes, the 61.31(d)(3) is for cat and class which of course he already has, so that won't work if you still need him to do night solo in a single. Screw that, do the multi initial. Or call your FSDO.
 
From chapter 21 of 8710.3E

[FONT=Times New Roman,Times New Roman][FONT=Times New Roman,Times New Roman]It is permissible for a foreign pilot who receives a U.S. pilot certificate based on his or her foreign-pilot license to accomplish the required night flying training (for the appropriate grade level of U.S. pilot certificate held) from a holder of an FAA flight instructor certificate, and to receive a solo endorsement to exercise night flying privileges on his or her U.S. pilot certificate. [/FONT][/FONT][FONT=Times New Roman,Times New Roman]

[/FONT][FONT=Times New Roman,Times New Roman]

[/FONT]
Hey! Thanks for the quote from the FAA Inspector's Handbook, Blackhawk. I did not know that was there.:)
 
Back
Top