Re: I know that this should be in the \"Schools\" postings, but since there is more traffic here
I was in your shoes just a few months ago and was asking the same questions on the forum. Though the answers I got were all heartfelt and genuine, I can see how the topic of "school A vs. school B" gets beaten to death now that I've spent some time on JC.
As a recent new student, my advice would be to find the school that fits YOU the best. There are so many qualities and factors to consider (time frame, cost, goals, location, attitude, etc.) that it's literally impossible to name the best school, even when given the choice of two that are of similar caliber. The best advice I got was initially from Doug and then repeated by six or seven other JCers: Visit, visit, visit, then choose the school that feels the best to you personally and that offers you the best chance to leave with a low debt.
Some of the factors that I took into consideration: location, teaching style, aircraft fleet and condition, initial impression, cost, overall feel, current student feelings, former student (graduates and 'leavers') feelings, instructor feelings, impressions from JCers, syllabus, time frame, size, housing, schedule, reflection on marketing and advertising campaigns, school philosophy, and alleged promises and guarantees, to name a few.
I ended up compromising on location (I hate this town but love the mountains that are only an hour or so away) and cost (could have done it for less, though it's a LOT less than many others). Besides those two things, the school I chose met or exceeded my desires on all other counts. It took me a while to find it and I gave myself a good month to think before making a decision, but I am thrilled with my experience so far.
So, beware of marketing, hype, and promises and make your decision based upon your own feelings, impressions, and desires. Opinions and thoughts of others have their place, but my hope for you is that you find the school that's the best for your personality, goals, and wants.
A bit preachy, I know, but regardless, good luck and fly safe. It's worth every long night studying and every bump in the road on your way here!