Dear Ford and Harrison...

Hogwash, it's about being a sheep. There's absolutely no reason for you to try and find something beneficial for both sides. That's not what being a pilot is about. Management is Stalin, and we are the dissent. They'll kill us as soon as they get around to us. You're either WITH us or AGAINST us and if you're not 100% WITH us, you're 100% AGAINST us.

Yeah BOOOOY! I couldn't agree more.

:nana2:
 
And, whether you like to admit it or not, airline unions use "guerilla tactics" to get what they what. Eastern's "Fly Safe," "American's "sick out," United's "summer of hell" are all examples.

Those are not "guerilla tactics". Those are the only negotiating tools available to use against certain managment teams who view employees as nothing more than troublesome ATM machines. Using that kind of teminology paints union members in a bad light, and as a pilot I wouldn't think that's the kind of message you want to be sending.
 
Those are not "guerilla tactics". Those are the only negotiating tools available to use against certain managment teams who view employees as nothing more than troublesome ATM machines. Using that kind of teminology paints union members in a bad light, and as a pilot I wouldn't think that's the kind of message you want to be sending.

Oh Jim, don't be so naive.

Some pilots, don't care about other pilots.
 
Those are not "guerilla tactics". Those are the only negotiating tools available to use against certain managment teams who view employees as nothing more than troublesome ATM machines. Using that kind of teminology paints union members in a bad light, and as a pilot I wouldn't think that's the kind of message you want to be sending.

Assuming pilot groups even GET to use their tactics. I'll point to NWA and Mesaba. Pilots want to strike, but can't thanks to the courts tying their hands. Meanwhile, management is free to implement whatever they feel is "fair." In that case, there are NO legal tactics the labor groups can use anymore. Sure, you can do a sick out, but you can bet your bottom dollar there's gonna be a suit filed, and you might even get tagged with the "not bargaining in good faith" deal, too.
 
Assuming pilot groups even GET to use their tactics. I'll point to NWA and Mesaba. Pilots want to strike, but can't thanks to the courts tying their hands. Meanwhile, management is free to implement whatever they feel is "fair." In that case, there are NO legal tactics the labor groups can use anymore. Sure, you can do a sick out, but you can bet your bottom dollar there's gonna be a suit filed, and you might even get tagged with the "not bargaining in good faith" deal, too.
Right?

I always throw up in my mouth a little bit when I hear people sympathizing with the plight of the poor put-upon managment whose wicked little emplyoees demands for a livable wage and a decent retirement make it difficult for them to enjoy their quarterly bonuses, box seats, and lakefront summer homes.
 
On a side note, and utterly unrelated to union-managment friction:

Wildly sucessful companies have something in common. Know what it is? Satisfied employees. Witness Microsoft. Soutwest Airlines. Even at the small business level, like Skymates, satisfied employees are the foundation of sucessful business. People are beginning to notice this, and I'm hopefull that the old way of looking at employee/mamagment relationships will become so out-of-fashion and discredited that places like Ford and Harrison will go the way of the dodo.
 
Ah, bologna.

It is much smarter to understand your opponent rather than villianize him. If you understand his motivations and desires you can find a way to negotiate things that are beneficial to both sides. If you villianize your oponent and turn it into a war, then both sides lose. Just like arguing on the internet - when you let your emotions take over instead of your brain you will usually end up looking the fool and making mistakes.

Labor vs management is all about negotiations, tactics, strategies, and who can best play the game. Get out the game films, study your opponent, put on your game face, and play by the rules.

skydog and M_F got it right. These guys are just the management equivalent of bringing in ALPA.

Hey ahh....guys I was kinda just pointin' out how people are getting flamed a lot these days and threads are turning into pissing contests. I figured the redneck speak would make it obvious, but I probably shoulda put a sarcasm tag after all of that.

I also kinda figured the "you're either with us or against us" line would scream ########.
 
Wildly sucessful companies have something in common. Know what it is? Satisfied employees. Witness Microsoft. Soutwest Airlines. Even at the small business level, like Skymates, satisfied employees are the foundation of sucessful business. People are beginning to notice this, and I'm hopefull that the old way of looking at employee/mamagment relationships will become so out-of-fashion and discredited that places like Ford and Harrison will go the way of the dodo.

I think this has been conventional wisdom for a long time. But it is a two way street. Unions often try to drive a wedge between management and workers as a means of increasing their clout. In fact I'd say that's SOP.
 
Yeah! How dare they be anti-pilot? Why, everyone knows that pilots are the bringers of all the goodness and light in the world.

Dude, you need to settle down and not take things so personally. Companies have as much right to resist unionization as unions have to organize. What do you expect? Do you think that management will just roll over and die at the first sign of a union coming over the hill? No, they are going to fight it. Ford and Harrison is simply a law firm that specializes in labor law. Their job is to advise their clients on the provisions of labor law, and how best to use those laws to their advantage. And don't forget that unions bring their own lawyers to the table when the time comes. You didn't seem to have any problem with ALPA using lawyers to their benefit in the Skywest union drive.

And, whether you like to admit it or not, airline unions use "guerilla tactics" to get what they what. Eastern's "Fly Safe," "American's "sick out," United's "summer of hell" are all examples.


Trust me I am not taking this personally, but should we as people sit there and let management TELL us what they want us to do or isn't it nice to have a voice and say these are some things we would want.
 
I think this has been conventional wisdom for a long time. But it is a two way street. Unions often try to drive a wedge between management and workers as a means of increasing their clout. In fact I'd say that's SOP.

As wisdom goes, I don't think it's conventional as you might think. And I can't think of a single example of a workforce that ended up the worse for having a union on property, although I'm sure there may be one or two. The bottom line is that if a company really wants to keep unions away, they should treat their employees as prize-fighters instead of coolies. The former will win you the championship. The latter will require an army of supervisors just to be sure the job is done remotely properly. Whither middle managment? Whither corporate America?
 
Trust me I am not taking this personally, but should we as people sit there and let management TELL us what they want us to do or isn't it nice to have a voice and say these are some things we would want.

Of course it is nice when management give us a say, but as employees our job is do what we're told to do. Calling the shots is a privilege reserved for the entrepenuers, investors, owners, and risk takers. We as employees are none of the above.

That's always been my biggest problem with unions is that they try and take control of the company away from the people who should have it.
 
The bottom line is that if a company really wants to keep unions away, they should treat their employees as prize-fighters instead of coolies.

:yeahthat:

If you take care of your employees, they'll take care of you and the profits will follow. Look at the correlation between Fortune's best companies to work for and stock returns.

Some companies get it. Others do not and shaft their employees on a regular basis and wonder why their employees aren't motivated to do anything beyond what they have to do.

If you're a manager and you don't want an union on site, don't give your employees a reason to want one!

Oh, and Jimbo, be careful with using the word "coolie." Some people get really offended when they hear that word -- I don't, but others might.
 
Of course it is nice when management give us a say, but as employees our job is do what we're told to do. Calling the shots is a privilege reserved for the entrepenuers, investors, owners, and risk takers. We as employees are none of the above.

That's always been my biggest problem with unions is that they try and take control of the company away from the people who should have it.

All I gotta say is WOW.
 
Of course it is nice when management give us a say, but as employees our job is do what we're told to do. Calling the shots is a privilege reserved for the entrepenuers, investors, owners, and risk takers. We as employees are none of the above.

That's always been my biggest problem with unions is that they try and take control of the company away from the people who should have it.

This is an astonishingly disturbing point of view. I'm quite honestly so shocked that anyone would post this on a pilot forum that I'm at a total loss as to how to answer it. But Jesus, just read it!
 
This is an astonishingly disturbing point of view. I'm quite honestly so shocked that anyone would post this on a pilot forum that I'm at a total loss as to how to answer it. But Jesus, just read it!

:yeahthat:

The people who know how to do the job best usually aren't the guys in the corner offices.

To say that they should call all the shots is just absurd. The best managed companies listen to their employees because they understand the front line worker knows a hell of a lot more about what's going on than the corner office exec.
 
Of course it is nice when management give us a say, but as employees our job is do what we're told to do. Calling the shots is a privilege reserved for the entrepenuers, investors, owners, and risk takers. We as employees are none of the above.

That's always been my biggest problem with unions is that they try and take control of the company away from the people who should have it.

Ooh, I'm going to have to have a couple of beers before I reply to this one.

I think even Ayn Rand is sitting up in her grave!
 
Back
Top