"Spoon Feeding and Adjusting"

desertdog71

Girthy Member
I will start this thread with the fact that these statements are of my personal opinion. Please do not read anything into this.

I have been reading some threads about flight training. Academy vs college vs FBO, you know the usual debate. The most disturbing thing I have seen, and its been repeated several times, is the whole "its not the schools responsibility to spoon feed or adjust to you"

Are you kidding me with these statements? It is EXACTLY the schools job and responsibility to "spoon feed" and "adjust" to you as a student. I find this attitude just plain arrogant.

Remember students, you are always the customer. These places should be doing everything they can to adjust to your needs. Not treat it like a Gestapo training camp. I guess some places have just gotten so big that customer service no longer means anything to them.

Do your research and choose carefully when looking at places to train. Ask tough questions and talk to students both current and prior. This is a huge investment of time and money. Its also really hard work, and if the environment doesn't meet your needs it only makes things more difficult. You are paying these places to TEACH, so expect them to TEACH.

The quality of instruction is ALWAYS the most important aspect of your training. You really need to interview the CFI's and management before making a selection. The school is trying to get your business and money. Make them earn it.
 
It is EXACTLY the schools job and responsibility to "spoon feed" and "adjust" to you as a student. I find this attitude just plain arrogant

I cannot imagine a statement regarding instruction with which I disagree more.

While in principle you may argue that a customer should get whatever he wants, the fact is, the customer, in this situation, cannot get what he wants without investing a great deal of effort.

No instructor, no team of instructors, no school can spoon feed a student at the rate and level of intensity necessary to achieve a real mastery of the material. Even if they could, they would have done the student a real disservice by not teaching him how to learn. This is a case of giving the customer what he needs, not what he wants.

Anyone who expects to be spoon fed has some growing up to do, regardless of his age.
 
Methinks interpretation is being taken to extremes - I've seen different definitions of spoon feeding over the years...

I think what DD is saying is that not all students fit the same mold, and they need to find instruction which is willing to work with them for their particular learning styles and needs, based on what they want to do with their training.

Do your research and choose carefully when looking at places to train. Ask tough questions and talk to students both current and prior. This is a huge investment of time and money. Its also really hard work, and if the environment doesn't meet your needs it only makes things more difficult. You are paying these places to TEACH, so expect them to TEACH.

The above is the most important part of what he said.
 
Spoon feeding gets pilots killed. End of story.

If one learns to fly by having ever answer handed to them they won't know where to go to find stuff. From day 1 I always pushed my students to find stuff themselves. Granted, I was teaching in a fast track pilot mill and that was sort of expected, but even if I hadn't I would have done it the same way. A student needs to be able to be 100% competent on their own when the 8710 is signed.

I don't mean that a CFI shouldn't teach. They should most defiantly do that, and if that is what you meant, then yes, you are correct. But to me teaching is much more about shaping a students way of acquiring knowledge rather then actually giving them the knowledge.

And if someone wants to make it to the 121 (and I assume 135) world that is the way thy are going to have to learn. In my 2 weeks of indoc and 2 weeks of systems I didn't have anything taught to me. The time was "This is where you will find this. Moving on...."
 
Are you kidding me with these statements? It is EXACTLY the schools job and responsibility to "spoon feed" and "adjust" to you as a student. I find this attitude just plain arrogant.
You are right that a student needs spoon feeding in the beginning. It is as necessary as spoon feeding a baby. Gestapo methods will not work.

However, the baby must grow up - that is the ultimate responsibility of any parent with a child as it is an instructor with a student pilot.

That still does not require Gestapo methods, but spoon feeding must gradually be weaned to a point where the student has become fully responsible for self.

Spoon feeding, or "pleasing the customer" creates pilots who think that others can be held responsible for their actions, and ultimately cannot maintain control in stressful situations.

It's a very fine line, and is the main difference between "proffesional" instruction, and "Walmart" instruction.

Students, like children, are not aware of the possible dangers of the flying environment, and it is the instructor's responsibility to put them into "simulated" environments which may test their emotional response.

If a person expects to be catered to, he may be a danger to himself and others in our environment.

Again, Gestapo, or military methods are not necessary to achieve this training. If that is what you are really talking about, I agree. But I/we have seen too many "students" who want to be taken care of and treated like "customers".

I cannot do my job, if I think of you as my boss.

I treat you like a guy who wants to learn how to take care of himself in the worst most possible scenario that I can think of. In the Air.
 
Perhaps what I am reading into the "Spoon Feeding" comments is incorerect. The perception I am getting is that if the student can't hang with the particular mold or method of that school, well then they should just go somewhere else.

Telling someone to go read the books isn't teaching. There is a lot of abstract and technical areas that require more explanation. Again maybe this is just my perception from what I have been reading. I get the impression that if a student requires extra attention to get through something, then they are being told to go away.

Reality is that there will be some students that require much more attention than others. We can't simply blow these people off because its a little more difficult or time consuming or it cuts into the bottom line.

Now of course students should be expected to self study and be taught how to use the tools around them to get information. However when a student asks a question about something, the answer can't always be "look it up" or "Go read"

If the student just isn't comprehending the material then we have failed as an instructor. Not the other way around.

Now if what is called "spoon feeding" is something else all together, I apologize for the rant.
 
Now of course students should be expected to self study and be taught how to use the tools around them to get information. However when a student asks a question about something, the answer can't always be "look it up" or "Go read"

If the student just isn't comprehending the material then we have failed as an instructor. Not the other way around.

Agreed.

Here's spoon feeding:

I had a student not long ago who refused to memorize the prep material that I had provided him prior to an instrument checkride. Things like "what requirements must be met before you can descend below MDA/DA". We had gone over it a number of times and I had explained in great, glorious detail, but he couldn't remember the stuff.

When I was quizzing him and he couldn't cough up the answers, he had a temper tantrum and told me it was my job to repeat the material enough times until he remembered it, because that's what he was paying for.

I was able to make him see the light, but I expect that his attitude isn't unique, even when not expressed so explicitly.
 
Agreed.

Here's spoon feeding:

I had a student not long ago who refused to memorize the prep material that I had provided him prior to an instrument checkride. Things like "what requirements must be met before you can descend below MDA/DA". We had gone over it a number of times and I had explained in great, glorious detail, but he couldn't remember the stuff.

When I was quizzing him and he couldn't cough up the answers, he had a temper tantrum and told me it was my job to repeat the material enough times until he remembered it, because that's what he was paying for.

I was able to make him see the light, but I expect that his attitude isn't unique, even when not expressed so explicitly.

Not what I thought people meant by spoon feeding at all. Again just an impression I got from some other threads on here. I was seeing it more like this.

Student comes in for a lesson.
Student: Here for my lesson
Instructor: Good, did you read that material I assigned you?
Student: Yes, but I have some questions
Instructor: Well, you read the material right?
Student: Yes
Instructor: Well you shouldn't have any questions, its all right there. I don't have time to "spoon feed" everything to you. You have to study this on your own, that is what the books are for.

Sure it looks ridiculous, but this is how things have been portrayed by some individuals. Now the truth is somewhere in the middle as always. My real point to this is that people really need to do their research when selecting a place to train.

The Part 121/135 example that BobDDuck used is a good example though. IF it is your intent to move into a part 121/135 environment, you really need to be self motivated and sharp. you will need to understand things quickly and retain that information or you will bounce right out of training. Which would suck big time since you worked so hard to get the interview, and the job in the first place.
 
Well you shouldn't have any questions, its all right there. I don't have time to "spoon feed" everything to you. You have to study this on your own, that is what the books are for.

I certainly don't view that as spoon feeding, and I suspect the instructor didn't as well. It's a control technique: I blame you for your inadequacies in order to reduce your demands on me.
 
I agree with van on this one as a student. With the amount of money i'm spending when I ask a question don't tell me to go home a read about it. It is the schools job to make sure you learn the material your way, BUT it does not mean that the student can get away with out doing homework and such.
 
I agree with van on this one as a student. With the amount of money i'm spending when I ask a question don't tell me to go home a read about it. It is the schools job to make sure you learn the material your way, BUT it does not mean that the student can get away with out doing homework and such.

Okay...so the following scenario would NOT be spoon feeding, correct?

Me: I did the reading I was supposed to do, and I have some questions. I wrote them down. Can you clarify?
CFI: Yeah. Here's how this works...when you add power here....
 
Okay...so the following scenario would NOT be spoon feeding, correct?

Me: I did the reading I was supposed to do, and I have some questions. I wrote them down. Can you clarify?
CFI: Yeah. Here's how this works...when you add power here....
Thats what I was trying to say
 
I used the term "spoon feed" in a recent post, so I'll give my $0.02 on what I meant...

I consider S.F. to be when I'm teaching CFI-initial, CFII, or MEI students and they are constantly asking me for answers to questions that could easily be found with a little research. I get tons of systems/weather questions that are blantantly answered in the POH, AIM, etc. Ex: "Um...how many fuel pumps are there in this plane?" or "What do the codes in the remarks section of a METAR mean?" And honestly, those are questions that anyone (except maybe a fresh PPL) should be able to answer or look up. Students who demonstrate that they can at least pick out the correct reference manual for the answer get my full support. Those who whine and tell me that it's my responsibility to hand out answers probably won't be my student for very long.

If a student simply can't master they necessary flight skills, then I recommend that they might consider a second opinion. Perhaps another instructor will have a different teach style that will better assist them during the training. Same goes for flight schools. The school is responsible for providing a service, and many schools are geared toward certain types of students. If it's not working out, then the school should reserve the right to have the student seek training services elsewhere.

I make my students aware of my expectations the first time we meet. I feel that it is only fair to lay my expectations on the table and let them decide if they want to meet the challenge. If schools are upfront regarding the expectations of their programs, then the burden is on the student to meet those expectations.
 
I consider S.F. to be when I'm teaching CFI-initial, CFII, or MEI students and they are constantly asking me for answers to questions that could easily be found with a little research. I get tons of systems/weather questions that are blantantly answered in the POH, AIM, etc. Ex: "Um...how many fuel pumps are there in this plane?" or "What do the codes in the remarks section of a METAR mean?" And honestly, those are questions that anyone (except maybe a fresh PPL) should be able to answer or look up. Students who demonstrate that they can at least pick out the correct reference manual for the answer get my full support. Those who whine and tell me that it's my responsibility to hand out answers probably won't be my student for very long.

I can go along with that. I just misunderstood what was meant by the term I guess.
 
I agree with van on this one as a student. With the amount of money i'm spending when I ask a question don't tell me to go home a read about it. It is the schools job to make sure you learn the material your way, BUT it does not mean that the student can get away with out doing homework and such.

I say you should read stuff at home about critical engines and 23.149 and stop posting on this website so much....:insane: :sarcasm:
 
My 2 pennies?

I think alot of schools do take a crap on alot of their students. I know of a few here in Phoenix that are famous for being excessively rude to students and charging them seemingly unnecessary charges.

Nevertheless, there must be an amicable relationship between the service provider and the customer for both parties to feel good about the transaction.
 
I think the crap you take is directly proportional to the amout of money you have in their account. This is a good reason to not go to a school that makes you pay up front. Doing so takes away your options. That's a bad thing.
 
I think the crap you take is directly proportional to the amout of money you have in their account. This is a good reason to not go to a school that makes you pay up front. Doing so takes away your options. That's a bad thing.

100% agreed! (pay as you go :P )
 
I think the crap you take is directly proportional to the amout of money you have in their account. This is a good reason to not go to a school that makes you pay up front. Doing so takes away your options. That's a bad thing.
Good schools also need upfront money to provide good resources to provide good training and have good instructors and airplanes, and....etc.

Having to pay up front, in and of itself, is not a good way to judge it.

Ask around with other students currently in a program, the user, to see what you are buying.
 
"Good schools also need upfront money to provide good resources to provide good training and have good instructors and airplanes"

I don't see why. Maybe your big academies just run that way. But I don't see it as necessary. I know of big FBO's that are on par with the academies running newer aircraft. They don't make you pay upfront though you get a discount for pay in advance block rates.

If you pay up front you have no leverage and you're sticking your neck out. I guess many places expect you to do that, though.
 
Back
Top