UAL settles with Buddhist pilot who didn’t want to attend AA meetings

Sweetie, I’m not the one having trouble understanding two very simple English words.
I understand them. We are laying the ground work for a discussion on alcoholism, addiction, and disease. I need to know what you define those terms as. You started this by bringing up the scientific community. So I was just asking you to define the terms as you see them in that context.
 
I understand them. We are laying the ground work for a discussion on alcoholism, addiction, and disease. I need to know what you define those terms as. You started this by bringing up the scientific community. So I was just asking you to define the terms as you see them in that context.

I see them using the dictionary definitions of the words, sweetheart.
 
Regarding addiction as a disease -

At a certain point, decades ago, mental health professionals adopted a “disease model” for treatment. Folks got lazy with the terminology and dropped the “model” part of the terminology. At the same time, it was widely understood that viewing addiction as a disease would remove some of the stigma associated with addiction.

It’s not a disease.
 
Regarding addiction as a disease -

At a certain point, decades ago, mental health professionals adopted a “disease model” for treatment. Folks got lazy with the terminology and dropped the “model” part of the terminology. At the same time, it was widely understood that viewing addiction as a disease would remove some of the stigma associated with addiction.

It’s not a disease.

From the Mayo Clinic. Which I think is a better source than *checks notes* some pilot on the internet.

C5EDBD72-D2DD-4E19-B2ED-57CAC03920F9.jpeg
 
From the Mayo Clinic. Which I think is a better source than *checks notes* some pilot on the internet.

View attachment 67913

Fair enough. If you’re interested, dive a little deeper. Research “disease model” vs disease.

I have two psychiatrists in the family specializing in substance abuse treatment and have watched the landscape evolve.

Most folks that have a problem with calling addiction a disease have another agenda. For me, it’s more a matter of semantics. Language, the precision of language, matters.
 
Sorry, I don’t buy this BS “addiction” excuse. We’re all adults that have the ability to make our own decisions.
It kills me when someone says they have been sober for 10 months and people applaud. F***, I’ve been sober for 67 years and no one is applauding for me.
  • I choose not to take drugs and be a burden on society.
  • I choose not to drive drunk.
  • I choose not to try illegal drugs.
  • I choose not to steal to support my drug habit.
  • I choose not to live in a broken down motor home throwing my trash and human waste on the street.
I pay more than my share of taxes to support these people. People who will always be a burden on society.
 
Last edited:
It kills me when someone says they have been sober for 10 months and people applaud. F***, I’ve been sober for 67 years and no one is applauding for me.
  • I choose not to take drugs and be a burden on society.
  • I choose not to drive drunk.
  • I choose not to try illegal drugs.
  • I choose not to steal to support my drug habit.
  • I choose not to live in a broken down motor home throwing my trash and human waste on the street.
I pay more than my share of taxes to support these people. People who will always be a burden on society.

So you want me to applaud you for fortunate genetics and boo others for their poor luck in unfortunate genetics? Seems a little too Nazi, so I think I’ll pass.
 
I think it’s a disease, but I’m not a doctor.

Even if it wasn’t, I think it’s good to see addictive behavior AS a disease so we can use resources to treat it, rather than the 1950’s version of “snap yourself out of it” which doesn’t work.
 
Back
Top