AirAsia A320 Possibly Missing

I'm a big fan of Airbus but incidents like this are scary:
http://www.aeroinside.com/item/4946...on-nov-5th-2014-loss-of-4000-feet-of-altitude

A Lufthansa Airbus A321-200, registration D-AIDP performing flight LH-1829 from Bilbao,SP (Spain) to Munich (Germany) with 109 people on board, was climbing through FL310 out of Bilbao about 15 minutes into the flight at 07:03Z, when the aircraft on autopilot unexpectedly lowered the nose and entered a descent reaching 4000 fpm rate of descent. The flight crew was able to stop the descent at FL270 and continued the flight at FL270, later climbing to FL280, and landed safely in Munich about 110 minutes after the occurrence.

The French BEA reported in their weekly bulletin that the occurrence was rated a serious incident and is being investigated by Germany's BFU.

The occurrence aircraft remained on the ground in Munich for 75 hours before resuming service on Nov 8th.

The Aviation Herald learned that the loss of altitude had been caused by two angle of attack sensors having frozen in their positions during climb at an angle, that caused the fly by wire protection to assume, the aircraft entered a stall while it climbed through FL310. The Alpha Protection activated forcing the aircraft to pitch down, which could not be corrected even by full back stick input. The crew eventually disconnected the related Air Data Units and was able to recover the aircraft.

Following the occurrence EASA released emergency airworthiness directive 2014-0266-E_1 stating:

An occurrence was reported where an Airbus A321 aeroplane encountered a blockage of two Angle Of Attack (AOA) probes during climb, leading to activation of the Alpha Protection (Alpha Prot) while the Mach number increased. The flight crew managed to regain full control and the flight landed uneventfully.

When Alpha Prot is activated due to blocked AOA probes, the flight control laws order a continuous nose down pitch rate that, in a worst case scenario, cannot be stopped with backward sidestick inputs, even in the full backward position. If the Mach number increases during a nose down order, the AOA value of the Alpha Prot will continue to decrease. As a result, the flight control laws will continue to order a nose down pitch rate, even if the speed is above minimum selectable speed, known as VLS.

This condition, if not corrected, could result in loss of control of the aeroplane.

The EASA requires as immediate emergency action that the flight crew operating manuals must be amended with a procedure to keep only one Air Data Reference Unit operative and turning the other two off in following cases:

- the aircraft goes into a continuous nose down pitch movement that can not be stopped by full backward stick deflection
- the Alpha Max (red) strip completely hides the Alpha Prot strip (black/amber) without increase in load factor
- the Alpha Prot strip rapidly changes by more than 30 knots during flight maneouvers with increase in load factor while autopilot is on and speedbrakes are retracted

Airbus guys is there a quick way to disconnect the ADUs or do you have to pull CBs?
 
His picture is an infrared satellite image. Red/Blue just means high cloud tops. Could be storms, or it could just be high stratus/cumulus layers. However, the areas of green(low, warm clouds) immediately surrounding the areas of red would indicate to me that that formation is most likely a storm. It could also be high clouds on top of lower layers. It just doesn't give you the whole story about what is going on there.

There does appear to be a few areas of only green and yellow that you could probably fly over top of for sure and that is where I would plan to go if I was still on the ground. I wouldn't not go just based on that image alone.

In the Caribbean/around Venezuela, I've found the infrared satellite picture to be pretty useless the more time I use it. By useless, I mean getting worked up over a "scary" picture. Plan for it being there, but realize that it probably isn't.

Radar/water vapor satellite imagery, and some forecast products can help complete the picture. Radar is spotty though(in the middle of the sea, go figure! :) ), and the water vapor satellite doesn't image the area down here(I actually think it only covers the continental US). I'm not sure what weather products are available where the plane went down.

In general, more gas, request/act on deviations as early as possible if needed. In the Caribbean at least, there's a big enough hole somewhere, even for lowish slowish turbo-props.

Thanks for the explanation. I didn't realize that was infrared satellite. I thought it was some kind of composite/doppler image. That definitely helps me understand.
 
I'm a big fan of Airbus but incidents like this are scary:
http://www.aeroinside.com/item/4946...on-nov-5th-2014-loss-of-4000-feet-of-altitude



Airbus guys is there a quick way to disconnect the ADUs or do you have to pull CBs?
Yes the AD was issued telling us to turn off 2 of the 3 ADR units.

Yes it's frigging scary.

Combine that with the new issue that was discovered on A321s, where as the if the fueler doesn't reset the panel back correctly, you cannot access the ACT tanks in the back (10,000# of fuel).

There is literally zero ECAM or other warnings that the panel is not reset back to it's correct position. The FOB still reports as accurate and is completely misleading.

This will most likely mean no ETOPS for A321s. Just a hunch. This is a huge deal for companies wanting to go overseas in them as well.
 
Sometimes I think I'm smarter than most. Times like this I know it.

That didn't come from an airplane. Folks that's lumber, looks like it's a 2" x 12"!

I'm sure they have found the debris field but that's not it!

Hey, it WAS an Airbus; it might be a spar!

It's pretty sad that news agencies are showing actual bodies being recovered. Family members shouldn't have to see this.....
 
Hey, it WAS an Airbus; it might be a spar!

Nothing wrong with a wood spar but that isn't one.

This Bellanca spar hit a mountain near Crescent City CA leaving the wing behind. The wood spar held up fine. The steel welds broke.

23kx3tg.jpg
 
Yes the AD was issued telling us to turn off 2 of the 3 ADR units.

Yes it's frigging scary.

Combine that with the new issue that was discovered on A321s, where as the if the fueler doesn't reset the panel back correctly, you cannot access the ACT tanks in the back (10,000# of fuel).

There is literally zero ECAM or other warnings that the panel is not reset back to it's correct position. The FOB still reports as accurate and is completely misleading.

This will most likely mean no ETOPS for A321s. Just a hunch. This is a huge deal for companies wanting to go overseas in them as well.

Whoa that fuel issue adds to the scariness. Just to clarify it's relatively easy to turn off the 2 and 3 ADR units or is it a find and pull CBs issue?
 
I'm a big fan of Airbus but incidents like this are scary:
http://www.aeroinside.com/item/4946...on-nov-5th-2014-loss-of-4000-feet-of-altitude



Airbus guys is there a quick way to disconnect the ADUs or do you have to pull CBs?

Here's another scary Airbus incident, Air France A340 from 2011 over the Caribbean, got within 3 knots of stalling in cruise. Maybe inadvertent autopilot disconnection was a contributing factor?

An Air France Airbus A340-300, registration F-GLZU performing flight AF-471 (dep Jul 21st) from Caracas (Venezuela) to Paris Charles de Gaulle (France), was enroute at FL350 about 145nm northeast of Point A Pitre (Guadeloupe) in night and instrument meteorological conditions at around 01:11Z (Jul 22nd) when the crew received an overspeed alert, the autopilot disconnected, the crew observed the indicated airspeeds had increased to 0.88 mach (MMO 0.86 mach) and 304 knots, the aircraft gradually increased its pitch attitude to 11 degrees and climbed with up to 5000 feet/minute up to FL380, reaching FL380 at 0.66 mach/ 205 KIAS - stall speed was computed at 202 KIAS - before the pitch attitude decreased again and the aircraft returned to normal flight parameters.
Contributing factors were:

- the aural alert "Autopilot Disconnect" was not heard because the simultaneous aural alert "Overspeed" had priority

- the turbulence experienced at the beginning of the upset made reading the instruments difficult

- the "severe turbulence checklist" item to verify whether the autopilot was still engaged was not carried out

- inappropriate use of the weather radar permitted entry into a zone of turbulence

http://avherald.com/h?article=44280b2a
 
Sometimes I think I'm smarter than most. Times like this I know it.

That didn't come from an airplane. Folks that's lumber, looks like it's a 2" x 12"!

I'm sure they have found the debris field but that's not it!

2h66101.png
I think it's foolish state with any absolute confidence what exactly the floating debris may or may not be. I know that I am certainly not "smart" enough to do so at this point. We aren't there. The photos are not very good and angles especially with nothing to compare an object to, may look like something they are not. The only "good" photos are of some of the objects that have been presented for a press conference. I cannot say with any certainly what that object is, nor can I tell how much of that object may be below the surface either, but I am not immediately going to discount it because I don't really know what it is and neither do you, even though you have an opinion on what you believe it is. There is a large difference between opinion and fact. There was cargo on this plane as well which has been confirmed by one of the Navy recovery crews.

I am only relieved that the recovery of the pax and crew has begun and an article I just read in the China Post states that over 40 remains thus far have been recovered. I don't even know how accurate that info is either. This is such an incredibly painful and agonizing time for the families and loved ones of the missing and my thoughts and hopes are for them. Hopefully the aircraft itself and the recorders will be found sooner rather than later now.
 
Last edited:
I think it's foolish state with any absolute confidence what exactly the floating debris may or may not be. I know that I am certainly not "smart" enough to do so at this point.
I've been a pilot since 1972, I was a carpenter for 13 years following the PATCO strike. That my friend is a piece of lumber.

I heard a new report saying they can see the shadow of the plane under water from the air.

2h66101.jpg
 
Last edited:
https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=1014708785222736&id=529802693713350

What's worse than news agencies speculating the cause is pilots speculating. She also believes the red on the sattilite picture is "radar returns"

I would estimate 1/3 of the pilots I know couldn't tell you about satellite vs radar returns. At my regional I would show an FO a satellite while headed to Mexico and get a deer in headlights look. Similarly now going towards the Caribbean guys are virtually unaware of the different satellite images available and how to read them.
 
This will most likely mean no ETOPS for A321s. Just a hunch. This is a huge deal for companies wanting to go overseas in them as well.

Because Airbus won't be able to figure out the programming glitch? Nobody is trying to go overseas next week or even in '15. Yeah, they'll just let that one go....
 
Because Airbus won't be able to figure out the programming glitch? Nobody is trying to go overseas next week or even in '15. Yeah, they'll just let that one go....
I'm not concerned just about this programming "glitch" (which resulted in a crew declaring an emergency). It was previously unknown throughout the Airbus community that this could happen. That is my main concern.

What else is hiding in the Airbus "logic"?

In the past month we've seen two very serious issues with how the airplane processes errors. It's concerning not knowing what else is hiding in its brain.
 
What else is hiding in the Airbus "logic"?

In the past month we've seen two very serious issues with how the airplane processes errors. It's concerning not knowing what else is hiding in its brain.

I guess we'll see, seeing as it's a pretty new design. Hell Boeing still has flaming batteries, but they're contained in a box at least while at 370 over the Pacific.
 
I guess we'll see, seeing as it's a pretty new design. Hell Boeing still has flaming batteries, but they're contained in a box at least while at 370 over the Pacific.

Off topic, I personally really enjoy the Gulfstream checklist for personal electronic device battery fire.

Down to 10k,
Slow to 160,
Depressurize,
Open aft bag door,
Throw item on fire out (don't ask me how I am carrying it at this point)
Close door,
Resume normal ops.
Brew some more coffee and make a sandwich.

The airbus AOA thing is freaking scary.
 
Off topic, I personally really enjoy the Gulfstream checklist for personal electronic device battery fire.

Down to 10k,
Slow to 160,
Depressurize,
Open aft bag door,
Throw item on fire out (don't ask me how I am carrying it at this point)
Close door,
Resume normal ops.
Brew some more coffee and make a sandwich.

The airbus AOA thing is freaking scary.

Haha really!?

We invested in a LiPo battery fire bag. It comes with some cool oven mitts. Of course if I ever had to use this IRL I'd find it much less funny.
 
I guess we'll see, seeing as it's a pretty new design. Hell Boeing still has flaming batteries, but they're contained in a box at least while at 370 over the Pacific.
When I toured the American mx facility in Dallas they said it was a charger issue, not a battery one fwiw.
 
Back
Top