dasleben
That's just, like, your opinion, man
Man, I just surfed Pipes up in San Elijo not too long ago. I'll let you know if I get up there again!When I was learning to stand up I practiced on the shore a lot like a couple other folks suggested. Going through the mechanics slowly and focusing on form and technique. I found it helped translate to the water to have the muscle memory down. The more I did it on land the faster and better I got at popping up on a wave. I also used go to a knee first then stand up, rather than going straight to my feet. It helped me find my balance for a split second before getting on my feet.
Best of luck, keep at it and if you're ever headed to any north county spots, let me know. The first round is on me!
About the pop-ups... I've been doing the same as you did, practicing on land as much as possible to cement the muscle memory. For the first time yesterday, I got up and rode the wave until it petered out, which I was thrilled about. Hopping down on my own accord (rather than falling off) is something I hadn't done before.
Kinda funny though, the water temp came up quite a bit since I was last at home, so the rest of the session my wax was melting off. I ended up having to call it a day once my board turned into a slip n'slide. Guess it's time to ditch the full suit, too.