Pinnacle Mesaba Colgan Transition and merger

Sorry to creep in here-

Is there a potential that a late 2005 hire would be back on reserve as a Q400 captain in Newark, post SLI?


Depends on what happens with fences and who bids the Q400 in EWR. I HIGHLY doubt reserve would go all the way back to 2005, though. MEM CRJ CA, yes. EWR Q400 CA, probably not.
 
If it did, then Colgan guys got a raw deal.
Eh, call it even if that happens. Pinnacle got a 'raw deal' when Colgan was purchased and expanded at an exponential rate while Pinnacle itself stagnated and was told our ALPA contract proposal would bankrupt the company. It's time to give a little somethin' back to the collective pot.
 
Eh, call it even if that happens. Pinnacle got a 'raw deal' when Colgan was purchased and expanded at an exponential rate while Pinnacle itself stagnated and was told our ALPA contract proposal would bankrupt the company. It's time to give a little somethin' back to the collective pot.

Relax man, give it up. So what of your an fo for another 3 years. I don't care. I'm pretty sure

2005 hire was well before the purchase, and for those of us who were captains before the purchase benefited little from it.

Its a good thing you never got on with eagle, with the " I want my upgrade NOW talk, some 6 year fo prob would have thrown you infront of the crew bus.

All you are going to do with this bickering is puss off people you wil potentially have to work with.
 
Eh, call it even if that happens. Pinnacle got a 'raw deal' when Colgan was purchased and expanded at an exponential rate while Pinnacle itself stagnated and was told our ALPA contract proposal would bankrupt the company. It's time to give a little somethin' back to the collective pot.

0.jpg


"ITS MY UPGRADE AND I NEED IT NOW!"
 
Relax man, give it up. So what of your an fo for another 3 years. I don't care. I'm pretty sure

2005 hire was well before the purchase, and for those of us who were captains before the purchase benefited little from it.

Its a good thing you never got on with eagle, with the " I want my upgrade NOW talk, some 6 year fo prob would have thrown you infront of the crew bus.

All you are going to do with this bickering is puss off people you wil potentially have to work with.

"So what of your an fo for another 3 years. I don't care."

Really? Sure. How about this one. "So what if you get DOH integration with Pinnacle? I don't care."

As for Eagle, don't be so quick to judge them. Their most junior upgrade is already down to a May 2006 DOH. Pinnacle's most junior DOH on the last vacancy was a Dec 2006 DOH. Depending on how this SLI goes, I wouldn't be surprised to see Eagle 2007 upgrades happen before a 2007 Pinnacle DOH upgrade. I had a friend who started at Eagle exactly the same date I started at Pinnacle, and he's gunning for the first upgrade he gets. We will see. I've already told him he'll see the left seat before I will.
 
"So what of your an fo for another 3 years. I don't care."

Really? Sure. How about this one. "So what if you get DOH integration with Pinnacle? I don't care."

As for Eagle, don't be so quick to judge them. Their most junior upgrade is already down to a May 2006 DOH. Pinnacle's most junior DOH on the last vacancy was a Dec 2006 DOH. Depending on how this SLI goes, I wouldn't be surprised to see Eagle 2007 upgrades happen before a 2007 Pinnacle DOH upgrade. I had a friend who started at Eagle exactly the same date I started at Pinnacle, and he's gunning for the first upgrade he gets. We will see. I've already told him he'll see the left seat before I will.

Good.
 
"ITS MY UPGRADE AND I NEED IT NOW!"
Actually, it's my money, and I need it now! Seems the checks will go out Apr 18. Let me guess, you want your hand in that cookie jar, too? I've actually heard two different Colgan guys say that the 10 million should have at least been split among the Pinnacle and Colgan pilot group, because they felt that they too had served under a below-industry average contract.
 
"So what of your an fo for another 3 years. I don't care."

Really? Sure. How about this one. "So what if you get DOH integration with Pinnacle? I don't care."

As for Eagle, don't be so quick to judge them. Their most junior upgrade is already down to a May 2006 DOH. Pinnacle's most junior DOH on the last vacancy was a Dec 2006 DOH. Depending on how this SLI goes, I wouldn't be surprised to see Eagle 2007 upgrades happen before a 2007 Pinnacle DOH upgrade. I had a friend who started at Eagle exactly the same date I started at Pinnacle, and he's gunning for the first upgrade he gets. We will see. I've already told him he'll see the left seat before I will.

Doh would be perfectly fine, but I bet you would hate doh with messaba.

People like you are the reason we will never have a national sen. List, or for that matter, portable longevity. If they have been working longer than me, then they should be senior to me. I fail to see why that is so hard to accept.
 
Doh would be perfectly fine, but I bet you would hate doh with messaba.

People like you are the reason we will never have a national sen. List, or for that matter, portable longevity. If they have been working longer than me, then they should be senior to me. I fail to see why that is so hard to accept.

Actually, for a long time, I was ok with DOH with Mesaba. Because whether I looked at relative or DOH with Mesaba, in my position, I fell at pretty much the same place. But now my view changed because I never first considered 'career expectation' of a Mesaba pilot before the buyout. And being narrowed down to just 60 RJs is a bleak future with a loss of all turboprops. So, I think DOH is too lenient considering career expectation. But it doesn't matter what I think, it matters what the arbitrator thinks. And arbitrator Dana E. put career expecation as the #1 guiding principle for the SLI for Republic/Frontier/Lynx/MidEx. So if that is any indication.....

"If they have been working longer than me, then they should be senior to me. I fail to see why that is so hard to accept."

LOL! Tell THAT to 60% of the Colgan pilot group! Every Colgan pilot I've talked to thinks that relative integration is the only "fair" way from their standpoint. So whatever happened to "if they have been working longer than me, they should be senior to me." ??????? They try to justify it as their fast growth, attrition, etc, but at the end of the day, their collective time at Pinnacle holdings is nothing compared to the more senior Pinnacle/Mesaba folks, YET, they still feel relative is the way to go. Obviously, in their case, the equation of "worked longer than I have, they should be senior to me" doesn't hold true....

I really hope when the dust settles, we can find out what our MECs views were and what we presented to the table for SLI.
 
I really hope when the dust settles, we can find out what our MECs views were and what we presented to the table for SLI.

"Chair-oh-kee wants this" multiple choice:
A.) Because I feel like I'll be able to make peace with this whole process and move forward with my life
B.) I just want something else to get mad at, I'm running out of steam
C.) There's probably some cannon fodder in there for my hysterics after I find out the SLI didn't go the way I think it should have
D.) Even though you have no reason to trust my levity in these situations, I truly am looking for an understanding on SLI processes since this isn't likely to be the last one we go through.


Everyone go ahead and answer, you can pick more than one.

My answer: B.)
 
Everyone go ahead and answer, you can pick more than one.

My answer: B.)
Hahahahaaa. Nice post. But actually, no, the real answer is E. "None of the above."

I want to say something, but can't, due to the private nature of the SLI and because I don't want trouble. But from personal, inside sources, I've heard certain things about a certain group. That's all I can say. :)
 
LOL! Tell THAT to 60% of the Colgan pilot group! Every Colgan pilot I've talked to thinks that relative integration is the only "fair" way from their standpoint. So whatever happened to "if they have been working longer than me, they should be senior to me." ??????? They try to justify it as their fast growth, attrition, etc, but at the end of the day, their collective time at Pinnacle holdings is nothing compared to the more senior Pinnacle/Mesaba folks, YET, they still feel relative is the way to go. Obviously, in their case, the equation of "worked longer than I have, they should be senior to me" doesn't hold true....

I really hope when the dust settles, we can find out what our MECs views were and what we presented to the table for SLI.

Names of every colgan pilot you talked to... I want to see a list containing 325+ names. Oh, right, you don't know, and haven't talked to more than what 5? 10 pilots? I don't trust your internet numbers, so, names please. Initials will work.

Relative is the easiest way to merge without pissing off too many people, but it won't work that way. If you want to go career expectations, then you will get hosed by the colgan pilots, But hey, for what It's worth 95% of the pinnacle pilots I know disagree with you.
 
"Chair-oh-kee wants this" multiple choice:
A.) Because I feel like I'll be able to make peace with this whole process and move forward with my life
B.) I just want something else to get mad at, I'm running out of steam
C.) There's probably some cannon fodder in there for my hysterics after I find out the SLI didn't go the way I think it should have
D.) Even though you have no reason to trust my levity in these situations, I truly am looking for an understanding on SLI processes since this isn't likely to be the last one we go through.


Everyone go ahead and answer, you can pick more than one.

My answer: B.)

My answer is threeve, a combination of the numbers three and five.

Simply stunning.
 
Hahahahaaa. Nice post. But actually, no, the real answer is E. "None of the above."

I want to say something, but can't, due to the private nature of the SLI and because I don't want trouble. But from personal, inside sources, I've heard certain things about a certain group. That's all I can say. :)

Let's say your worst fears are confirmed. You're reaction afterwards is not going to be none of the above, it's going to be B. I'll be happy to relay you're concerns to our union guys. Perhaps we can issue a formal apology for contrived or perceived injustices to you directly after the SLI. This whole merger is simply about settling scores that you make up, and I see no reason to stop your eruptions.
 
Doh would be perfectly fine, but I bet you would hate doh with messaba.

People like you are the reason we will never have a national sen. List, or for that matter, portable longevity. If they have been working longer than me, then they should be senior to me. I fail to see why that is so hard to accept.

Would DOH work well in every scenario? There are XJ furloughs that have relatively "senior" DOH, yet have actually worked cumulatively LESS than roughly 30-40 9E FO's that were never furloughed. Would it be fair to stick the furloughed XJ pilots above the 9E pilots who had slaved away on reserve for 2+ years, even possibly pushing the 9E pilots back down onto reserve?
 
Would DOH work well in every scenario? There are XJ furloughs that have relatively "senior" DOH, yet have actually worked cumulatively LESS than roughly 30-40 9E FO's that were never furloughed. Would it be fair to stick the furloughed XJ pilots above the 9E pilots who had slaved away on reserve for 2+ years, even possibly pushing the 9E pilots back down onto reserve?

I'm guessing those furloughed XJ guys just sat on the couch, scratching their butt waiting for a recall? A furlough is not something that is easy to live with. I would be fine with DOH. I didn't say everybody was, or would be.

Heck, I'm just about ready to start bidding call me last, or long call rsv again.. but I liked "not" working as much as I did then. Recently, i've been blocking over 95 hrs a month, and it's a bit old. 97 hours projected this month, with spring weather in EWR, I'm sure I will end up right against 100 hours.

Look, nobody is going to like how this turns out. As soon as you move past that point, it's much easier to deal with. fwiw, 60% of colgan pilots don't really worry about the SLI, because they are more focused on getting to the next job, then fighting over the current one. For most everybody on this board, this SLI won't mean much of anything in 2-5 years, so It's really not worth getting bent out of shape about.

Remember, Career expectations are based upon the expectations at the time of SLI... expectation of a 9l pilot is a SHORT upgrade right now. The Q program is still growing, and, will prob. continue to expand. Right now. 9E has some movement, but no real "growth" messaba is kinda status quo. With the 9l name going away, you could argue that Messaba expectaions are for a growing q400 program, and enough saab flying to keep everybody on board.

Really though, strong indications are, that 9l is going to need an additional 180+ pilots over the next 2 years. coupple that with expected attrition, and the hiring over here isn't going to stop. Cherokee, It's more likely that you would end up in the Q400 as a ca, than a colgan guy will be flying a CRJ from the left seat.
 
Hahahahaaa. Nice post. But actually, no, the real answer is E. "None of the above."

I want to say something, but can't, due to the private nature of the SLI and because I don't want trouble. But from personal, inside sources, I've heard certain things about a certain group. That's all I can say. :)

This is BS. If your "personal inside source" is a member of the negotiating team or the MEC, they're stabbing the others in the back since they're not supposed to be talking about it to ANYONE. Maybe their spouses, but certainly none of the other pilots. If that's the case, said person has lost my respect, and you can even pass that along to them....assuming they exist. If it's second or third hand information, it's suspect at best. We've all played the "telephone game." You don't want trouble, but you're pretty quick to say "I've got a secret and I'm not telling."

I started class at 9E the exact same day as another JC member started at Eagle. He got off reserve when I upgraded, and he's upgrading now. However, you don't see him blasting the world because he didn't upgrade quickly. I'm sorry the world crapped on you and you didn't upgrade in two years like JetU said you would. Boo-friggin-hoo. Mergers are a way of life in the airline biz. If you're gonna play "poor me" every time a merger happen, maybe you should jump back to your former career.

In this thread you have done nothing but present yourself as a childish, selfish individual, and you're embarassing the rest of the 9E pilots.
 
I'm pleading the fifth on the "info" I know. It isn't the teams directly, because as you said, they are all super-secret. It's a second hand info, and while you are correct it could be suspect, my best hunch is it wasn't. But whatever. There are too many rumors floating around anyway, probably best to ignore it all.

However, you don't see him blasting the world because he didn't upgrade quickly.
I'm not unhappy about my current situation. The upgrades will eventually come, and there's nothing I can do about the time that I started. Sure, it would have been nicer if I was hired at the same time you were, but we can't change that. I have no beef with that. My only reservation is with the SLI process and from what I've heard in the crew rooms and from certain pilots belonging to another airline that starts with 'C'

This is a forum. People vent here, and I'm no different. There are but a couple of Pinnacle pilots who actually read this particular forum. That's all there is to it. We share concerns, problems, vent, etc. I do it here so I don't have to do it in the crew room, or worse, in the cockpit. By venting it all out here, it makes for a better flying because you don't talk or discuss this stuff. Very rarely will I talk about this with other crew members.

Another thing I wanna know is why we even bothered with direct pilot negotiations in the first place for SLI. Did anyone really think 9 pilots could ALL UNANIMOUSLY agree 100% on a SLI method? With the diverse range of pilot seniority across all 3 groups, there's no way in hell it could have been done. So why did we even bother? What did NWA/DAL do? Did they even engage in direct pilot-pilot negotiations for SLI? Or did they say the arbitrator (Bloch) will do it from the get-go?? Anyone know? To me, it seems to be a waste of time trying to get 9 guys, 3 from each group, to agree 100% to a SLI method. Because we are far too diverse on seniority, there literally was no way all 9 could agree on 100% the same method. To me, this represents a waste of time. Time that could have been better off sending this to the arbitrator Bloch in the first place, and by now, we'd have our SLI already.

So. What's the "final" arbitrator award date? I've heard two conflicting dates. One is latest by May 1, and the other latest by May 15. Anyone know which one it is? I thought it was 30 days from when everyone was sent packing on March 31, so that should be May 1. Is that the latest date for Bloch's award?
 
Back
Top