No More Clearing Turns!

Phantom017

Up up and awaaaaayyy!
Just had a private student come back from a passed check ride and he told me that when he was in the flight portion and was about to do a clearing turn that the DE told him that clearing turns were no longer required for the test. Said the rule was just recently released.

Doesnt hurt my feelings at all. Just curious what you all think of this new rule
 
I'd believe this guy. Hes one of the best in the state. Everybody loves going to him because he sets you at ease and makes it educational and fun.

Also I was told that you no longer need to enter ground ref manuvers WITH the wind anymore... i.e. turns around a point, S-turns, and Rectangular courses
 
I'd believe this guy.

I don't believe the student's report of what the guy said.

Clearing turns aren't required even in the current PTS, but the document does require that you "clear the area". I cannot believe that the FAA no longer cares whether or not you do this.

In the Private PTS, the only maneuver that specifically requires a downwind entry is the rectangular course. However, the Airplane Flying Handbook specifies (or at least suggests) a downwind entry for most maneuvers, and that document is included by reference in the PTS. Perhaps the FAA is merely saying not doing so isn't a failure item.
 
I don't know that the PTS ever specifically said "Clearning turns" as a standard. However, in the Special Emphasis Area it had, and still has, as item number 4 in the commercial and private PTS "collision avoidance".

Personally, I'm not sure how effective clearing turns necessarily are in some situations (such as slow flight and stalls), but perhaps more necessary prior to doing such things as steep turns. I also like to put more emphasis on pilots actually looking prior to turning, making patterns rectangular with a full roll out on cross wind/base so they can look for traffic, lifting a high wing or dipping a low wing.
 
:eek: NO POSSIBLE WAY I will stop doing clearing turns, or let my students stop doing them. The FAR's DO still place responsibility on the pilot to 'see and avoid'.

That guy may be an excellent examiner there, but I know several examiners here that would REALLY appreciate applicants doing clearing turns.

Just my .02
 
Personally, I'm not sure how effective clearing turns necessarily are in some situations (such as slow flight and stalls), but perhaps more necessary prior to doing such things as steep turns. I also like to put more emphasis on pilots actually looking prior to turning, making patterns rectangular with a full roll out on cross wind/base so they can look for traffic, lifting a high wing or dipping a low wing.

I personally think that clearing turns aren't very effective at preventing midairs. I rarely ever spot other traffic when ATC points it out, much less by random scanning.

That said, most DPEs still will want to see it. So you need to teach your students to do them.
 
A problem I've seen is the rote mechanical "proceeedure" of "doing the clearing turn".

I've seen students start the turn without looking, and after a left and right 90, fly another minute or two restablishing altitude, speed, and/or heading etc, and by the time they start the maneuver, they have flown several miles away from the cleared area, and not really looking around in the meantime.

The Clearing Turn replaces the Swivel Neck All the Time technique.

Maybe that's what the DE is sick to death of.
 
I personally think that clearing turns aren't very effective at preventing midairs. I rarely ever spot other traffic when ATC points it out, much less by random scanning.

True, I can't remember a time when I saw a plane because of a clearing turn.
To stay positive I like to think of it as a maneuver to help the area traffic see me, instead of me seeing them.
-I'm the size of a barn door on the horizon instead of a thin line.
-Maybe they will catch a glint off of my wings.

That is the way I look at it.
 
True, I can't remember a time when I saw a plane because of a clearing turn.
To stay positive I like to think of it as a maneuver to help the area traffic see me, instead of me see them.
-I'm the size of a barn door on the horizon instead of a thin line.
-Maybe they will catch a glint off of my wings.

That is the way I look at it.
That is how I often taught it as well.
 
True, I can't remember a time when I saw a plane because of a clearing turn.
To stay positive I like to think of it as a maneuver to help the area traffic see me, instead of me seeing them.
-I'm the size of a barn door on the horizon instead of a thin line.
-Maybe they will catch a glint off of my wings.

That is the way I look at it.

:yeahthat:
 
The only time I remember clearing turns being useful was in aero. Flipping inverted to grab a quick look below you before spinning to loose a few thousand feet. Aside from that, scan the horizon regularly is sufficient, IMO.

I am sorry, but a steep turn in my book does not qualify as a maneuver. Heck my clearing turns are often at 60 degree when I am up goofing around. If I am up doing aero I will clearing turn before making any drastic climbs/descents. Other than that it is a normal scan of the horizon (the guys that are at your altitude and will cause you problems).

tgray said:
I also heard that midair collisions are now forbidden in the PTS.

If you take them out and land w/o major damages you get extra points, it is like an instant pass for super skill. :D
 
I also heard that midair collisions are now forbidden in the PTS.

Well played.


The idea that some people are blowing off their clearing turns scares me. You'll probably get away with it in podunk no where, but in our area not a chance. There has been 4+ (15+ fatalities) mid airs in my area in the last 3 years.

Trust me, clearing turns will keep you alive longer.
 
I don't buy it either. My guess is the student misunderstood the DE. Maybe they'll get rid of the preflight inspection too. :insane:
 
there are 4 reasons to unsat a check in the front of the pts, one of them is " failure to clear the area before beginning a maneuver" or something worded very close to this.

not doing clearing turns is just idiotic
 
True, I can't remember a time when I saw a plane because of a clearing turn.
To stay positive I like to think of it as a maneuver to help the area traffic see me, instead of me seeing them.
-I'm the size of a barn door on the horizon instead of a thin line.
-Maybe they will catch a glint off of my wings.

That is the way I look at it.

I guess it depends on where you practice, but I have seen quite a few aircraft in my practice area doing clearing turns. I think turning 90 degrees in either direction is overkill, as long as you are actively scanning for traffic.
 
Back
Top