Pilot's Bill of Rights

Ehhh...I think it'd be a waste of time. I'd be for it if pilots were constantly getting abused by the FAA, but frankly, they're not. The laws and procedures we already have in place work fine, for the most part.
 
Ehhh...I think it'd be a waste of time. I'd be for it if pilots were constantly getting abused by the FAA, but frankly, they're not. The laws and procedures we already have in place work fine, for the most part.

It's not happening enough for your taste so we shouldn't do it? It is happening enough for me.

The FAA's abuses are documented well in my mind from friends and neighbors and colleagues. I'm done pretending like the process is "in whole" fair. It isn't.

I absolutely support the pilots bill of rights.
 
It's not happening enough for your taste so we shouldn't do it?

Basically, yeah.

Apparently you know people who haven't been treated fairly. I don't.

In all the dealings I've had with the feds, and all the interactions my friends have had, the feds have been surprisingly fair and helpful. In a few cases, I've actually been surprised at what they let slide.

It's all anecdotal evidence on both sides. You've had bad experiences, I've had good, who's to say what's actually happening, system-wide? We have to put it to a vote, I guess. As for now, I'm not going to support fixing a system I don't think is broken.
 
Basically, yeah.

Apparently you know people who haven't been treated fairly. I don't.

In all the dealings I've had with the feds, and all the interactions my friends have had, the feds have been surprisingly fair and helpful. In a few cases, I've actually been surprised at what they let slide.

It's all anecdotal evidence on both sides. You've had bad experiences, I've had good, who's to say what's actually happening, system-wide? We have to put it to a vote, I guess. As for now, I'm not going to support fixing a system I don't think is broken.

Agreed.
 
Perhaps I'm one of the select few that believe that the FAA isn't out to nail us for everything we've done wrong.

The system is in place to protect aviation in general. While I'm sure people get screwed on occasion, I believe as a whole pilots are treated fairly and the system does its job.
 
Perhaps I'm one of the select few that believe that the FAA isn't out to nail us for everything we've done wrong.

The system is in place to protect aviation in general. While I'm sure people get screwed on occasion, I believe as a whole pilots are treated fairly and the system does its job.

Lol.

They are.
 
Author: "upon finding that said authority is not playing by the rules, we need to defy them and insist that our rights be respected."

Declaration of Independence: "But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security."

That thief!

However, I completely agree with him. I haven't had any bad experiences with the FAA, yet. Though without rules to prevent them from over stepping their bounds it is only a matter of time. Some will says, why bother because things don't appear broken. Well if you didn't have miranda rights and various others, as we do today, do you think every person being convicted would get relatively equal treatment? Probably not.

This isn't a bill designed to undermine anyones authority. It is, instead, a bill to put up boundaries or guidelines for FAA officials to follow. Currently we can have a bad FAA official and they will not be held accountable for their actions. With something like this they would be required to show common courtesies and couldn't trample over us if they didn't get laid the night before.

The bad side that I can see is lawyers. God I hate them! No offense midlife. With a bill like this, pilots who deserve to be convicted might get off on a technicality, that irks me.

But all in all, I am for it.
 
I'd much rather error on the side of the innocent.

I've watch examiners let guys loose for pulling their gear up on taxi and lie about it just to recant it later. Then months later LOI a guy because a passenger (student pilot) made a complaint to her CFI who made a complaint to a FSDO. Anyway, stories like this go on and on and on and there never seems to be an end to this.

Ask yourself, all, is there anything in this bill proposal you believe is wrong or unfair? If not, then there is little reason to reject it.
 
The vast majority of FAA inspectors are great guys who do their job well, and treat pilots fairly. They only go after legitimatly unsafe pilots and/or operations. There is only a small minority who abuse their power.

The exact same thing can be said about Cops.


We have civil rights to protect us from the small minority of police who abuse their power, why not the FAA?
 
I'd much rather error on the side of the innocent.

I've watch examiners let guys loose for pulling their gear up on taxi and lie about it just to recant it later. Then months later LOI a guy because a passenger (student pilot) made a complaint to her CFI who made a complaint to a FSDO. Anyway, stories like this go on and on and on and there never seems to be an end to this.

Ask yourself, all, is there anything in this bill proposal you believe is wrong or unfair? If not, then there is little reason to reject it.

Bingo! Yeah, I know guys who should not be flying. Guys who habitually do things that are patently unsafe (I mean, hey, we all screw up, but habitually?). They don't get any complaints or problems from the federales and coast along. Good pilots make one screw up however, and get the shaft. Bad juju all in all.
 
I think the FAA is out to nail the airline I fly for. Those of us employed would just be collateral damage.
 
Being a pilot is a privilege, not a right. I think it should stay that way.

Same as it is for being a citizen or having your drivers license. We aren't entitled to be citizens, it is a privilege, if we violate civil laws we can lose that right. That is why we have prisons and systems in place to protect people from being wrongfully accused, even if they are not perfect. This system doesn't exist for the FAA.

The FAA system isn't much better then the Gestapo. They can essentially do and treat you however they want without and repercussions. All this is are rights to prevent that.
 
Same as it is for being a citizen or having your drivers license.

you sure about that?

"Even the legislature has no power to deny to a citizen the right to travel upon the highway and transport his property in the ordinary course of his business or pleasure, though this right may be regulated in accordance with the public interest and convenience. - Chicago Motor Coach v Chicago 169 NE 22

"The right of the citizen to travel upon the public highways and to transport his property thereon, either by carriage or by automobile, is not a mere privilege which a city may prohibit or permit at will, but a common right which he has under the right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness."- Thompson v Smith 154 SE 579.

"The right to travel is a part of the liberty of which the citizen cannot be deprived without due process of law under the 5th Amendment." - Kent v Dulles, 357 U.S. 116, 125.

"Undoubtedly the right of locomotion, the right to remove from one place to another according to inclination, is an attribute of personal Liberty, and the right, ordinarily, of free transit from or through the
territory of any State is a right secured by the l4th Amendment and by other provisions of the Constitution." - Schactman v Dulles, 96 App D.C. 287, 293.
 
you sure about that?

Positive, and quoting freedoms we have as citizens doesn't change what I said. If you run naked down the street at your house you get arrested and jailed. You now have citizen rights to due process. If you buzz the tower and get your certificate revoked you loose your rights to be a pilot and there is no due process.

If you speed down the highway, in your car, using your 'privileged' drivers license, and play bumper cars just because you are bored you will likely get arrested. However, when being arrested a process exists with laws that the officers doing the arresting must follow. The cops have rules and the FAA doesn't yet both have power over our privileges. Police/courts over civil freedoms (one of which is driving, identical to that of flying) and FAA over a pilots license.

Anything you have in this world is a privilege pending you follow the laws of the civilization you take part in. I am unsure how you can possibly argue that.
 
Anything you have in this world is a privilege pending you follow the laws of the civilization you take part in. I am unsure how you can possibly argue that.

...and those are called Slaves.


So let's just say there is a law to take away everything you own in this civilization we take part in. Can they? nope. It is my unalienable right to own 'stuff', including my body. Go research unalienable rights and you'll see what I mean. A right is the exact opposite of a privilege and you are blending the two together.
 
I've never had a run-in with the FAA myself, but if you ever happen to read the "legal counsel" articles in AOPA magazine, there are MANY examples of the "system" slanted against the certificate holder, pretty much regardless of the underlying facts. Of course the FAA lawyers aren't interested in what's the most appropriate resolution, they're interested in winning the government's case so they can keep their jobs.

While I wouldn't be opposed to making the process more fair for accused airmen, these "bill of rights" probably go over the top.
 
Perhaps I'm one of the select few that believe that the FAA isn't out to nail us for everything we've done wrong.

The system is in place to protect aviation in general. While I'm sure people get screwed on occasion, I believe as a whole pilots are treated fairly and the system does its job.


Yeah, wait untill you hear those words "High I am from the FAA, and I am here to help."

I have seen this go down a few times, and it's never good. Thankfully it hasn't happened to me.
 
Back
Top